"Quality is the parent, the source of all subjects and objects." - Robert Pirsig |
Attention Workers In Neuroscience, Brain Science, Philosophy & Philosophy of Mind, Cognitive Science, Psychology, Learning Theory, Researchers and Theoreticians of Mind, Consciousness, & Brain Development.'To Brain & Mind Scientist => This Webpage You Are Currently Reading Is Titled => “Thoughts, Ideas, Future Plans, Actions, That Become Consciousness In Our Mind, Are Each => A Single Coherent, Holistic, Unified Right Now View Of The World, Created As A Solution To The Problem Of How To Best Respond To Our Second By Second Sensory Input From Our Surrounding Environment.” where the “Official Start” '' is 20 Inches Below, Please Know That This WebPage, And It’s Linked Pages => 1) Introduces Henry Gur’s entirely new kind of => Theory Explanation Of How Our Mind Works. which Is Fully Confirmed By Direct Observation. And =>
…This Theory Explanation, Offers A Very Viable Answer To The Mind-Body Problem, And In So Doing, Closes The Explanatory Gap. 2) Are a General Theory Explanation, and has major parts that well agree with the conclusions of other experts, but the overall panorama of understanding is mostly not presented in existing literature.
3) This view Into The Workings Of Our Mind, is so different that => At first reading you will have difficulty perceiving what it says, and indeed, at first, you will not believe it has any truth.
4) For this reason: In your reading of the below (and other linked WebPages), you will have to go slow & let the ideas sink in, so you can begin to see that what is said, actually fits your own direct experience. This way the truth of what is presented will gradually be become evident.
5) And you will gradually come to see, that the ideas & conclusions of this Theory Explanation, do in fact, stand true to your own direct observation.
6) So, if you are young, and of agile flexible mind, and at the start of your career, you will discover this overall viewpoint, offers a way for you to see into The Workings Of Your Own Mind, not to be found any where else.
7) And from this, as you will discover, you will become more effective in your personal daily life, learn how to break out of problem hangups, and have more creative ideas. Effectively you will have a => A Brain Owner’s Manual.
7) And, from this, better understand the mind of other persons, and thus be able to better communicate with them.
8) AND as can be directly observed => The Mental Arrival Results of our Problem Solving Brain, are exactly the Source All Human Creativity!
You Actually Will See It Happen, As Mental Arrivals, Automatically, Spontaneously, Again And Again!
“If I have seen further, it is by standing on the shoulders of giants.”NOTICE This Document Below Is In Final Stage of Writing, And =>...A) A few of the Blue Internet Links may be broken, plus
1) Will be a useful review of ideas, and thus boost your understanding & comprehension of ideas.
2) And in reading these “repeats” these ideas will more fully integrate & solidify into your mind.
3) Many of these “repeats” are expressed in different words, which may be enough to suddenly shift your mind enough to achieve new clarify.
SIDE NOTE: On this WebPage you are currently reading, the meanings of “Best”, “Quality”, “Merit”, & “Coherence” are as stated in a Dictionary. For More On “Dictionary Meanings”, scroll down to .. Have A Meaning, Of That Of Most Dictionaries …
...F) FOR EASIER READING OF THIS WEBPAGE:=>
Please email me (Click “Contact Me” At bottom This Document), if you want to suggest Edit Corrections, or you see ways to improve this WebPage, or have new information to suggest. Henry Gurr ZMMQ SiteMaster Nov 7-13, 2022, &. Jan 12-20, 2023, May 15-21, 2023, & June 14, & Sept 25, 2023, March 14, 2024.
This link will REALLY Help You Learn A Deep, Full Understanding Of The Flash Of Insight Phenomena And Other Similar Mental Arrivals (such as => Suddenly Realized, It Hit Me. Light-Bulb, Lightning Bolt, Bolt-From-The-Blue, It-Just-Dawned-On-Me, Epiphany, Etc) : You must learn this understanding, because this AHA experience (and the brain machinery which creates it), is what my Theory (Explanation) is totally built around. => As You Will See => It Is Important To Experience AHA’s At First Hand, And Clearly Observe These VERY Important Facts That => a) Our UN-Conscious Mind automatically, will find Optimal (Best or Near Best) Problem Solutions & Answers =>
b) Which then Mentally Arrive into our Conscious Mind.
c) You should eventually realize that => Every thought, every perception, is found by the same “machinery & methods”, as Mental Arrivals such as the Flash of Insight, but nearly all the time, we just don’t know it!
d) What this means is, (for our normal conscious thoughts and perception), we have NO awareness of our UN-conscious brain processes,
e) UNLESS there is a HALT, in our thinking, waiting for a Mental Arrival:
f) The sudden Mental Arrival into our Conscious Mind, is practically the ONLY way we know there 'must have been UN-conscious Problem Solving Brain Processes, running in our brain, with minimal clue of their presence!
g) Here It Is Important To Notice That => Our Problem Solving Ability, Indeed All Or Our Mental / Brain Functioning At All Moments, Depends On => Our Brain’s Own Internal Massive Memory: …
I) This “Brain’s Memory” is used to => i) Re-Call, Re-Member, Re-Construct, Re-Create => Answers, Thoughts, Ideas, Conclusions, Intentions, Behavior, Etc, as Mental Arrivals, into our Conscious Mind., and/or ii) Available for our other UN-Conscious Problem Solving Brain Processes.
h) To understand just how all this could be true, especially the role of Our Brain’s Memory, please study, especially Hopfield Neural Network Model, in My MPPS Article => (Click 3rd Blue Link Below where you see MPPS Article.)
NOTE1: Continued From g) Above: For Reasons & Discussion Given In PROPOSITION 3e) Below, (As Well As Mentioned Other Places) => In This Document You Are Currently Reading => Our Brain’s Own Internal Memory, Is Simply Called “Memory” OR “Brain’s Memory.
… Our Brain’s Neuron-Based Memory, Should Be Clearly Distinguished, From What Could Be Called “Human Remember Ability”. Officially called “Declarative memory”, or sometimes called “Explicit Memory”., which includes the Memory Recall of say =>Names, Poems, Songs, Stories, Data, Charts, Maps, Images, Visualizations, Etc.
NOTE2: As you read my MPPS Article (blue link next down), please pay special attention to EACH of the 32 discussions of word PERCEPTION, and study to see how => Memory, Perception, and "Flash Of Insight* Problem Solving are really just different outward manifestations of a single intellectual process which in turn can be understood as Networks of Neurons, that can solve problems. This VERY important idea is herein named => “ Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory”.
NOTE3: As you read my MPPS Article you will notice cartoons, puzzles, and jokes, near the end but please do NOT look at these, until you are told (with link) to look at one. Otherwise you may MISS MY MESSAGE concerning How Our Mind Works with “Solving a Problem Called a Cartoon or Joke” … ((NOTE: The above-mentioned “Compact Explanation”. Page, This is the 2nd down Blue Link in Menu at Top Left. )) … ((NOTE: This is the 3rd down Blue Link in Menu at Top Left. )) => Where are collected into one WebPage, are the ALL of the Properties & Characteristics Of Every Mental Arrival: (These are such as “Flash Of Insight”, which come automatically, spontaneously, Into Our Conscious Mind, For Our Every Waking Moment, Second By Second:)
OFFICIAL START OF HENRY GURR’S THEORY EXPLANATION. Thoughts, Ideas, Future Plans, Actions, That Become Consciousness In Our Mind, Are Each => A Single Coherent, Holistic, Unified Right Now View Of The World, Created As A Solution To The Problem Of How To Best** Respond To Our Second By Second Sensory Input From Our Surrounding Environment.A Striking New KIND of Theory (Explanation) of How Our Mind Works, In General & With Metaphor, Analogy, Simile, & Allegory !!!Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works, With Practical Applications.” Finding Single Best** (Or Near Best)** Solutions, is Practically The Only Way To Guide All Of Our Senses, In Perception, To Decode “What Is There”, And To Decide And Achieve Practical Future Actions. (ie Intention). As you read the above Best**, you may immediately think of whacko, crazy people who make obviously bad decisions:
Most Of The Presentation Below Comes From Literature On Creativity, Mind, Brain Science, Vision, Psychology Especially Gestalt Psychology, Creative Problem Solving, Invention, Teaching, Learning, Writing, Philosophy, And Other Areas. Click Here To Go To A CLICKABLE TABLE OF CONTENTS, Which You May Use To Go Directly To The Indicated Discussion: For example you will see “Go Directly to Start of The 23 PROPOSITIONS’ of Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” . This way you may skip over lengthy Introductory Overview Portions, until later when you may need them, or return to a portion you were studying previously.
ABSTRACT & SUMMARY, FOR THIS WEBPAGE YOU ARE READING NOW =>… I) Our Ideas, Thoughts, Perceptions, Future Plans, and Automatic, Spontaneous, Mental Arrivals (Similar To Flash Of Insight), That Suddenly Come Into Our Conscious Mind, Most Usefully May Be Considered To Be => Solutions To Life’s Oncoming Problems, Which Mentally Arrive Into Our Conscious Mind, From Spontaneous & Automatic UN-Conscious Brain Processes:
… III) As Is Observed In Ourselves And Other People, And True For Nearly All Of Our Problem Solving Brain Solutions (Answers), These Mental Models Are Generated, Constructed, Created => On the basis of Best or Near Best, (or Optimum Coherence, or Optimal Fit), for what is ”there” or “available”, such as in our surrounding external environment.
… IV) Everyday Example(s) Of => Our Problem Solving Brain’s Automatic, Spontaneous, Generated, Constructed, Created, Optimum (Best or Near Best) Solutions (Answers) => A) Life’s Problems Our Brain Very Quickly, Yields A Valid, Near Optimum Problem Solution, (i.e. best or near best answers), to life’s problems coming at us:
B) Elementary Examples =>
1) What is the name of the Capital of Iowa?
2) Whose face is that?
3) How can I best get all these suitcases into my car?
4) Which sunset scene was the most glorious.
5) What manpower, materials, and time will it takes to build a pyramid.
6 In Writing and composition, typing, or hand-writing, and suddenly finding the correct word.
7) Operate the controls, clutch, gear shift, and steering wheel of a car.
8) Sudden Danger Recognition > Body Motion Evasive Action
9) Speaking words & sentences of the Chinese Language
C) Perception Examples: Our Brain’s General Problem Solving Response To Sensory Input From Our External Environment, Generally Called Perception, by various workers.
1) Perception Is A Human Ability, In which UN-Conscious Brain Processes automatically, responding to the 9 Senses, Generates, Constructs, Creates =>What is called a Mental Model of The Exterior World, that then Mentally Arrive into Conscious Mind, which in This Document, is called “Primary Consciousness ” .
2) A Sub Category Of Perception Is Called (by various workers), Pattern Recognition.
3) However In This Document You Are Currently Reading, Pattern Recognition is called a more general (more inclusive) term => Partial Fit Problem Solutions.
3)cont To learn more about “Partial Fit”, which is a very important & highly useful mental ability, please scroll to and read below at => On How Our Problem Solving Brain Achieves Perception, Pattern Recognition, Partial Fit Problem Solution
4) Related to Perception is what Owen Barfield calls ”Figuration”. => “Figuration is the construction by the "percipient mind" of the recognizable and namable objects we call "things." In other words, that "something . . . required in us to convert sensations into 'things'"; all that in the representation which is not sensation. (Figuration, Barfield says, presupposes of course that "the sense-organs must be related to the particles in such a way as to give rise to sensations")
D) As Pointed Out In My Above Mentioned MPPS Article => These Best or Near Best Solutions (which Mentally Arrive into Consciousness), Are Of Necessity derived from an Optimal (Best or Near Best) Fit To Memory of Similar Previous Optimal Solutions, but weighted to fit the current oncoming sensory input(s).
E) These Problem Solutions Are Based On An Optimal (Best or Near Best), Combined Fit Of =>
1) All sensory input up to that current moment,
2) All memories of similar circumstances, and
3) What was the survival success value of the previous actions, for that and similar circumstances.
F) These (“only-one-at-a-time”) Solutions nearly always include Future Plans, along with Optimal (Best or Near Best), Physical Actions that should be completed: Plus accompanying Emotions & Feelings.
G) Altogether these above D), only appear (as Mental Arrivals Into Conscious Mind) ONLY when they are of sufficient Quality, Merit, or Overall Coherence, or said figuratively, have sufficient “Resonance Strength”.
H) The Above-Mentioned “Solutions” (of the present existing problem), Effectively Perform An Associative Memory Retrieval, To Then Generate, Construct, Create => What Appears (as Mental Arrivals) Into Our Conscious Mind. And as importantly mentioned above this is automatically spontaneously done by our => “Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory”.
i) NOTE1: This WebPage you are currently reading, discusses extensively => “Mental Arrivals Into Conscious Mind”. Please be aware => A Mental Arrival, and “A Gestal\t” are both pointing at the SAME Mental Phenomena, and thus have close to the same meaning! Is Approximately The Same Meaning
… AND this means that ”The Enormous Body Of Research & Writing In The Area Of Gestalt Psychology”, will have much additional insight, into all the topics directly related to Henry Gurr’s “Explanation (Theory) Of How Our Mind Works, '' as are discussed in the TOP EIGHT Blue Links, In The At Left Main Menu. NOTE: The 4 really interesting Gestalt principles are, proximity, similarity, continuation and closure, where proximity is possibly *the* most important. These Gestalt principles, or course should fit the overall discussion of this WebPage you are now reading, but would take added explanation. Please ask in an email, if you want to know more.
… V) As Is Observed In Ourselves And Other People => The Above-Mentioned “Solutions”, A) thru H), That Mentally Arrive Into Our Conscious Mind, From Automatic, Spontaneous, UN-Conscious Brain Processes, Are Observed To Come Into Conscious Mind, In The Same Way, And Same Brain Machinery & Actions, As Are Used For => The Flash Of Insight, And Other Similar Mental Arrival Events.
… VI) ALSO: The Above A) Thru F), Will Be Seen To Be In Close Agreement With Robert Pirsig In His Book “Zen And The Art Of Motorcycle Maintenance.” (ZMM):
EXPLANATION: What Makes These Above-Mentioned => “Best And Near Best Solutions” Possible, Functional, Indeed Very Fast, Successful, & Amazingly Powerful Is => a) Our Brain’s Massive Computational Power,
b) Using and Supported by Our Brain’s Massive Memory Of => A Lifetime Of Successful Previous Problem Solutions, saved-up for this very purpose of previous “Best And Near Best Solutions” being immediately available to be adapted to a new circumstance, and appropriately use again.
c) These Previous Problem Solutions were from previous successful sensory perceptual decoding of the person’s surroundings, and included attendant planned-future-actions, that themselves were also previously successful.
The problem solutions (and concomitant plans plus emotions), present to conscious mind => A One-At-A-Time, Unified, Whole & Complete, Logical, Max Coherent, No Parts Left Out, Holistic, Full of Meaning, All-At-Once Solution => Good Answers, With Positive Feeling Of Success & joy, Emotional Satisfaction, & Feeling of Achievement, even Laughter! AND remarkably free of contradictions, inconsistencies, errors, non-factual data, and other spurious ideas & wrong conclusions. These are an immediate response to ongoing sensory input integrated with relevant memories, on a weighted basis to how recent, occurrence frequency, relation to circumstance, and survival value.
… For Our Problem Solving Brain Be Sure to Note Well => The Above-Mentioned Problem Solutions, Then Stored In Brain’s Memory ARE =>An Automatic Spontaneous Optimizing Creative Memory Cycle =>, Which Achieves New Learning, Refinement Of Skills, Better Habits, Improved, Solidified, Updated Knowledge, And Many More Examples.
1) The Automatic Spontaneous Optimizing Creative Memory Cycle Steps Are => Original Memory > Memory ReAccesed > Provides Memory Base For Perception & Other What Do Next > Problem Solving Brain Mental Arrival to Consciousness With Future-Plans, Emotions & Feelings, Etc > Action > Success > Refine & Improve Solution Back Into Memory > Enhance & ReFurbish Memory. =>
2) Above Shortened To => A Regenerative Memory Cycle Of ReAccess & ReFurbish =>
3) Above Abbreviate To => ReAccess & ReFurbish Cycle.
4) Above Abbreviate To Useful Acronym => RRC << For more related Discussion & Problem Solving Brain usages > See 18 Each > Edit > Find > …RRC …
… This cycle is also discussed in the Single and Double-Loop Learning, discussed and diagramed, half way down this Wikipedia Page. … You Have Now Just Finished Reading => ABSTRACT & SUMMARY Which Started ~30 Inches Above. …
Please Be Sure To Re-Read These & Re-Mind As Needed.
A Clickable TABLE Of CONTENTS For This Document You Are Currently Reading. You May Click A Line Of Blue Text To Jump To That Place. (NOTE: Click The Back Arrow, Usually In The Upper Left Of Your Browser, To Return To Where You Were.) AN EXPLANATION: What Makes These Above-Mentioned => “Best And Near Best Solutions” Possible, Functional, Indeed Very Fast, Successful, & Amazingly Powerful Is => Our Brain’s Massive Computational Power. (This is ~8 inches above.)
A Lengthily Expansion Upon And Further Explanation Of The FinePoints Of Henry Gurr’s Proto-Theory. The Nature Of Creative Writing (And Creativity In General), And => What It Took To Evolve & Achieve => “A Gradual Full Realization Of A Very Important IDEA & FACT, Concerning MEANINGS.”
What You Need To Know About The Flash of Insight. The Required Main Components => To Devise A Theory Of How Our Mind Works.
What Will Be Accomplished By A Theory Of How Our Mind Works.. U C Berkley Philosophy Professor John R Searle’s Own Writing On Mind, Provides A Foundation For A => Scientific Explanation Of Consciousness.
MOST READERS WILL WANT TO SKIP OVER “INTRODUCTORY REPETITIOUS VERBIAGE” & BEGIN READING FULL EXPLANATIONS HERE AT START OF => THE 23 PROPOSITIONS FOR A NEW KIND OF “PHILOSOPHY OF MIND” =>
A Clickable TABLE Of CONTENTS For => APPENDIX I to XVII of This Document You Are Currently Reading. … You May Click A Line Of Blue Text To Jump To That Place. (Click The Back Arrow, Usually In The Upper Left Of Your Browser, To Return To Where You Were.)APPENDIX XVI: POSSIBLE OBJECTIONS TO “A THEORY OF HOW OUR MIND WORKS AND REPLIES TO THESE OBJECTIONS APPENDIX XVIII: How The Ideas Of Poet, Linguist, & Philosopher Owen Barfield Partly Support The Discussion Of => “PROPOSITION 10c) How The Problem Solving Brain Is => THE WELL SPRING (BOTH SOURCE & MECHANISM OF) OF ALL HUMAN CREATIVITY, Including Social Creativity: ” These Owen Barfield Ideas (From His Many Very Insightful Books), Are Pointed Out & Discussed Below: Also shown is how Mr Barfield’s Ideas & Conclusions partly confirm above-mentioned “PROPOSITION 10d): If You Know of Good Books, Authors, Articles, or have other Suggestions/Observations, Etc,
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib. ADDITIONAL, SOMEWHAT REPETITIOUS, EXPLANATION OF & EXPANSION UPON THE ABOVE:ALTHOUGH THE FOLLOWING DISCUSSIONS MAY SEEM EXCESS … BUT HOPEFULLY WILL HELP YOU TO MORE CLEARLY COMPREHEND IMPORTANT IDEAS … PERHAPS BECAUSE THESE IDEAS ARE PHRASED DIFFERENTLY OR PRESENTED IN DIFFERENT ORDER OF TOPICS.AT VERY LEAST, THE FOLLOWING READINGS, WILL BE A USEFUL REVIEW OF IDEAS.… NOTE: As You Read This Document, You Will Discover Long Wordy Phrases, => 1) Which seem clumsy and excessive. Plus 2) These same phrases are exactly repeated as explanation in other areas of This Document.
As Is Directly Observed => Our Problem Solving Brain, In Respond To Life’s Oncoming Problems, Automatically Spontaneously Generates, Constructs, Creates, Solutions (Answers) Which Have A Sense Of => Immediate, Clear, Whole, Understandable, MEANINGS, Which Then Immediately Mentally Arrive Into Our Consciousness, Along With Our Ongoing Experience Of Primary Consciousness.
… AND Although It Is Unknown (Even Inexplicable), How Our Brain Does It => Be Sure To Notice Very Well =>
1). Thlee-piecee bamboo, two-piecee puff-puff, walk-along inside, no-can-see.
2) South Sea Islander’s Experience => Pidgin English for a three-masted screw steamer * with two smoke stack funnels.
C) After you finished reading above 1) & 2) => Did you actually experience Owen Barfield’s “Felt change in consciousness? Please tell me of your experiences, in email to HenryG__USCA.edu
((The above 1) & 2) are Owen Barfield’s book “Poetic Diction” , page 43 & 46 To learn more, see 20 instances of > Top > Do > Edit > Find > … Poetic Diction ... .. .. A VERY LENGTHLY SIDE NOTE: RE THE GESTATION OF A VERY IMPORTANT SERIES OF IDEAS => Our Problem Solving Brain => Generates, Constructs, Creates, Our Sense Of => “Awareness Of Truth, Along With Arrival Of Pleasure In Reading Particularly Effective Lines Of Poetry. ” .
A) DATE-LINE January 27 2020 “Starting From A Small Incidental Observation, My Series of Conclusions Step By Step, Grows To A Very Important Realization, Concerning The Brain’s Creation Of Our Awareness Of Truth, Along With Arrival Of Pleasure In Reading Particularly Effective Lines Of Poetry. ” by Henry Gurr
”By happenstance, at the bottom of my computer screen, A Tiny Bit Of Color Draws My Attention. There my eye caught the following words on one of the System Tray Document Title Rectangle’s => ->a) “Connectives: New Poetic Insights ” At which point my mind (automatically) completes the whole phrase =>
b) “New Poetic Insights Are Pleasurable & These Go To Awareness Of Truth.”
At which point I say to self =>
d) “What is likely to happen next (as my life unfolds), and how my ideas of “How Our Mind Works”, help provide an effective guide, what to watch for.”
… Then from this thinking, I suddenly remember when I read word & its idea => “Connectives” . =>: For some peculiar reason, I remember, and then automatically comes to my mind” => e) “For each connective arriving in our conscious mind, our Problem Solving Brain, automatically spontaneously, will find Better Connectives: And each successive new connective =>, Will Be Even Better Yet !!”
… The Bottom Line => This was my first indication that Our Problem Solving Brain, can Generate, Construct, Create, A Sense, Sensation, & Awareness of “Not Only Connectives but Also Truth of These Connectives.”
=>Continued From The Above => The Following is A Very Lengthily Added Explanation => B) Effective DATE-LINE February 8, 2018 =>
IN EXHAUSTING DETAIL, THE FULL STORY, REALLY AN OBJECT LESSON, OF HOW DID IT HAPPEN =>
CONCERNING THE NATURE OF CREATIVE WRITING (AND CREATIVITY IN GENERAL), PLUS THE “VIRTUES” OF “QUIT & WAIT”: … The Following Table Shows => Henry Gurr’s Gradual Step-By-Step => What It Took To Evolve & Achieve (As Is Stated 14 Inches Above In The Bolded Title) =>
…AND all this is apparently accomplished with similar methods, as it makes => Mental Arrivals generally and/or, Normal Perception, Vision, Hearing, Taste, Smell, Sense of Touch. With all these, Imagination and Feelings generally present. … In addition, our brain (right along with those above), concurrently generates one the many-recognized Emotions, such as Happiness / Sadness, Fear, / Anger, Surprise / Disgust, which will be discussed more fully below. With “Feelings” also appropriately present.=> … In other words, The Evolutionary Established Property Of Our Brain, as is Directly Observed, => Can MAKE Clarity, Understanding, Meaning (plus rest of the list above), right along with Perception, Primary Consciousness, and Our Body Motions. => .. To get some idea just what “MEANING” does for us => … … A) You should Study Metaphor in Poetry. For example on a particularly effective line of poetry feel Owen Barfield’s “Felt change in consciousness.in his book “Poetic Diction” => … … B) For 2nd example => You should “Directly Experience The Sudden Making of Clarity, Understanding & Meaning”, which Will Happen by reading & noticing your puzzlement the few words of text next down THEN => Directly observing your sudden experience of Meaning Suddenly Is THERE **AHA**. as you finish the reading the words of 2nd text next down: => … (NOTE: These 2 Text are given below, where each “reading”, is spelled out how to do.) ||
********* CLOSURE FOR THE ABOVE TABLE, WHICH SHOWS HENRY GURR’S => Came To My Mind => “MY GRADUAL FULL REALIZATION OF A VERY IMPORTANT IDEA & FACT”.
A) If you look closely, you can discern the individual writing composition steps of, my Gradual Full Realization of “ The Very Important IDEA & FACT” concerning just how Problem Solving Brain Gives us “Meanings”:
B) In the Table, you see the exact words, each word practically a new Mental Arrival, would come to mind and guide & how I would type each of the new added words & word phrases you see.
For The Above A) & B) Writing Composition Steps, EACH Step Is A Good Example of Robert Pirsig’s “The birth of a new fact.” As Stated in His Book “Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance. (ZMM) =>
END OF => A VERY LENGTHLY SIDE NOTE: RE THE GESTATION OF A VERY IMPORTANT SERIES OF IDEAS.
DATE-LINE June 12 2023 by Henry Gurr “Above You Saw A Very Lengthily Report, Describing “How Did It Happen”, The It Was FINALLY Realized => “Our Problem Solving Brain Makes Meaning, Sense of Truth, Beauty, Recognition, Insight, Knowing, Comprehension, Sense of Clear Understanding, and Importance. And All This With Felt Certainty”.
1) You say: "All calculators about the same" Not so fast!! Some calculators are better than others, especially when it comes to brains / minds that are doing the “calculating” !!
2) I had MERELY asked what “does the work” of the providing the meaning of a sign, for example!! Or what does the “work” of analogy or metaphor?? BUT ... I'm delighted that you go WAY beyond me, and recognize that " the meaning is encompassed by calculation". Good for you!
3) But I would add: This "Meaning By Calculation", produces, generates, creates, builds, and YES CONSTRUCTS MEANING,! and then => This meaning is placed into this special "human mental presentation arena & theater stage" called => "consciousness", for the entire and whole special purpose => For us to have, face to face, the constructed meaning before-our-very-eyes!! Presto, its there, We "see" the meaning. Yes indeed there is a lot of calculating going on!
4) BUT => You managed to miss my big point: I was not worried about the "quality" of the calculator, I was VERY concerned that Philosophers and Semiotics Crowd, thought the meaning of the sign (the signified), did NOT have a calculator: It JUST was there!! Which means that the contributions of human brains were completely "Out of Mind", Out of Their Mind!
CLOSURE => Thus We See That The Vital Conclusion => Our Problem Solving Brain Makes Meaning =>
DATE-LINE June 14 2023 by Henry Gurr. More Discussion of => “Above You Saw A Very Lengthily Report, Describing “How Did It Happen”, The It Was FINALLY Realized => “Our Problem Solving Brain Makes Meaning, Sense of Truth, Beauty, Recognition, Insight, Knowing, Comprehension, Sense of Clear Understanding, and Importance. And All This With Felt Certainty”.
“You asked for a Barfield citation to where he says, something to the effect: "Words mean more than they say." ” “I do not have the cite, but I would point to Speaker's Meaning as a prolonged meditation on this idea. What "words mean" at any given moment is their lexical meaning or dictionary definition; the "more" will be invested in them by the speaker's meaning. Words may take on "the form of things unknown" in virtue of the creative energies of what Barfield is calling "the speaker." We might just as well call him "the poet." I think Owen would be quick to remind us that the tension between lexical meaning and speaker's meaning is not a contradiction but a polarity. And if ever there was a word that means more than it says it is the word "polarity" when spoken by Owen Barfield!” “Looked at from another angle, Barfield's "speaker" might be Peirce's "interpretant." The same creative energies are at work. Is it not the work of the interpretant that turns two-termed dyadic meaning into triadic meaning? Furthermore, we can think of Barfield's "lexical meaning" as the essence of dyadic meaning: The word-definition template stands as the very model of the signifier-signified dyad. It is opened up creatively as the interpreter "interprets." And we might for these purposes call the interpretant "the reader." ” “In neither process is creative freedom absolute. The poet can effectively exercise his creativity only if a reader accepts his metaphor as sufficiently true to entertain it at least provisionally. Although in the first instance that "reader" may be the poet (acting as reader), in order for words to come to "mean more than they say" a bunch of readers must agree to this acceptance, by, for instance, deeming a nascent metaphor to be true. It's not so different in science: The "more meaning" Einstein proposes to invest in "gravity" will bear fruit only if other folks are convinced it be true.” “To think more on this, go to "Whitehead" in the index Michael Polanyi's Personal Knowledge. In one of those cites you will find a footnote where Whitehead says something like: There is no statement that perfectly expresses its meaning (not even one plus one is two). In a way, this looks at "Words mean more than they say" pessimistically: Since words cannot perfectly state their meaning, we have to make up the difference. I think Polanyi (and Whitehead) are stating the optimistic side of this: Because words cannot perfectly state their meaning, we are free to invest them with the creative energies of our personal knowledge. Once again, this is not an assertion of absolute freedom; but perhaps our freedom is sufficient, if we would but use it. (Leonard Cohen sums it up this way: There is a crack in everything; that's how the light gets in.) ” “Hasta, Ken” “PS: 1. To speak of a line of poetry as a mental arrival is itself a helpful point of departure. Way too often structural analysis of poetry gets swamped in its own mechanistic presuppositions. To see "the line" as an arrival stresses its sufficiency of expression and its provisional stasis; to see it as a "successive mental arrival" stresses its organic continuity and expansive reach of meaning. It's refreshing to begin the discussion in this light.”
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib. except G) thru J).
A) At any one moment of time, there is just ONE Optimal (Best or Near Best) Solution presented, automatically, spontaneously, as a Mental Arrival, into our Conscious Mind!
… Although comparatively rare, Google Searches can find authors that state essentially the same conclusion. These include George Lakoff, Daniel Dennett, and others. After Supplement TWO, page comes up > Edit > Find > … (author you want, from list above.)… B) Once you think about it, finding “only-one-at-a-time”, Single Optimal (Best or Near Best) Answer / Solution, is the ONLY way to do it, both in fundamental brain theory and in brains dealing with a practical real world in practice.
C) Not only are these “only-one-at-a-time”, Single Optimal (Best or Near Best) Answer / Solution, remarkably good, for the situation at hand, they are ALSO Automatically “Tailored” to the ongoing immediate situation, AND “only-one-at-a-time”, Single Optimal is EXACTLY what is required for quick “single minded” decisions, and quick action for survival. In other words => One single (Best or Near Best), avoids the extra time to consider possible alternatives, and then even more time to choose which!
D) These Optimal (Best or Near Best) Problem Solutions, are found by automatic, spontaneous, UN-Conscious Brain Processes,
E) But it is Puzzling (Click Here) Why We Are Completely UN-Aware of the workings of our Conscious Mind: Click Here To Read Why We MUST Be Unaware Of What Our Problem Solving Brain Is Up-To in APPENDIX VII:
F) These Optimal (Best or Near Best) Problem Solutions, are found by automatic UN-conscious brain processes, A Minimum System Energy ANALOGY, may help your understanding of this “Automatic Process”: When finished reading, use your browser’s Upper Left Back Arrow, to return here. Click if you wish to Jump-Down to my System Energy Analogy.
G) These “only-one-at-a-time” solutions depend on massive memory of a lifetime of experiences, stored there for there for this very purpose of finding previous “Best And Near Best Solutions” being immediately available to be adapted to a new circumstance, and appropriately use again. . (AFTER This Document Comes Up => See 17 each > Edit > Find > … “only-one-at-a-time” … )
H) In other words => All Is Slide To => “Better & Better Partial Fit Problem Solution !
I) (Educated Guess =>) If any beginning Partial Fit (a small start), is allowed to survive, the newly formed activation may spread by finding increased coherence in other memories, and/or be amplified by its own positive feedback regeneration. A nascent Mental Arrival responds to its own positive feedback regeneration AND ability to spread AND become stronger, likely all the while supplying growing negative feedback (suppression), to the other less-coherence-supporting nascent Mental Arrival Solutions. We can suppose eventually there is a Winner-Take-All, because the stronger coherences, grow at the diminishing expense of the other weaker ones. It is likely that such positive feedback regeneration, would once started guarantees a growing (ever winning) Single Solution. And, as is observed, the final completed solution, is an integrated => One-At-A-Time, Unified, Whole & Complete, Coherent, No Parts Left Out, Holistic, All-At-Once Solution, apparently arising from and determined by our sensory inputs (9 senses).
... And starting from nascent, the developing Mental Arrival, will grow to saturation and thus can’t self-grow any more. In other words: The Positive Feedback Growth is Self-Limiting. This provides an answer, to how endless, UN-stable positive feedback, will not lead to disaster: And in which case (hypothesis), rather than disaster, the saturation is big enough to actually break thru into a full Mental Arrival into Consciousness! Thus Solving (By Removing), The Problem Of => “How Does Our Brain Set The ~Threshold For A Solution To Appear Into Consciousness! J) As explained 27 places in Page you are currently reading => Our Brain is thus effectively a “Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory.” .
K) This above G) is a VERY important italicized 11 word name & idea, as will also be further discussed, because our brain thus => Simultaneously Solves The On-Coming-Life-Problems, And In The Same Process, Act As A Memory Retrieval.
L) Thus, any and all Problem Solutions, that Mentally Arrive into our Conscious Mind, should be considered “Memory Retrievals”, despite the fact that we don’t ordinarily think of them as such.
M) As also will be discussed => How knowledge, experience, facts, and ideas must already be in your Brain’s Memory, available for our brain’s UN-Conscious problem solving processes, and from this your Problem Solving Brain is able to Generate, Construct, Create, a Solution that then Mentally Arrives into your Consciousness, whereupon you then “See” or “Perceive” or “Understand”: For example, to “get” the punchline of a joke, and fully suddenly "understand" the humor. Enough Knowledge must be in your brain’s memory; because problem solving requires memory, indeed massive amounts of brain’s memory!.
N) AND Be Sure to Note Well This Is =>An Optimizing Creative Memory Cycle =>, Which Achieves New Learning, Refinement Of Skills, Better Habits, Improved, Solidified, Updated Knowledge, And Many More Examples.
… This is A Cycle Of Regenerative Upward Spiral Of Compounded, Creative, Building-On-(And Beyond)-The-Previous, Ever Improved Problem Solutions, Then Stored In Memory. 1) The Cycle Steps Are => Original Memory > Memory ReAccesed > Provides Memory Base For Perception & Other What Do Next > Problem Solving Brain Mental Arrival to Consciousness With Future-Plans, Emotions & Feelings, Etc > Action > Success > Refine & Improve Solution Back Into Memory > Enhance & ReFurbish Memory. =>
2) Above Shortened To => A Regenerative Memory Cycle Of ReAccess & ReFurbish =>
3) Above Abbreviate To => ReAccess & ReFurbish Cycle.
4) Useful Acronym => RRC << For more related Discussion & Problem Solving Brain usages > See 18 Each > Edit > Find > …RRC …
…This cycle is also discussed in the Single and Double-Loop Learning, discussed and diagramed, half way down this Wikipedia Page. AND as stated in my MPPS Article => O) After any Mental Arrival, for example, => You will remember the problem solution, therefore you have new experience & new knowledge, which automatically will make newly refurbished brain memories. Thus we see that => Brain Memory is both required for problem solving, and (increased) memory, is the instantaneous result of problem solving, most especially if (and pretty much only if) Mentally Arrived into Consciousness!!
P) It is likely that the inter-neuron connections that were accessed, to achieve a Solution, were the self-same neurons, that are sub sequentially changed / up-dated, to effectively “hold” the new memories, as a result of the New Solution so created into Consciousness and at the same time saved into memory.
Q) There are important functional reasons why we are totally un-aware of our UN-conscious brain processes. Click here to go to Henry Gurr’s APPENDIX VII => Why Is It Necessary For The Workings Of Our Mind To Be Hidden From Us? .
R) Just how the above is at all possible (even indeed thinkable), for a physical biological brain, to accomplish the above , is factually and mathematically established by the Physics Theory of Princeton Physicist J J Hopfield.
S) An additional important Property of Mental Arrivals Is At > Top > Do > Edit > Find > …. (Even Inexplicable)
T) Although the Above Discussion Points A) thru P), are fairly compete, Please remember that => The various factors that effect What Our Problem Solving Brain Can & Will Make Available, As Mental Arrives, into Conscious Mind, is a whole lot more, than what is stated A) thru Q).
And We Must Remember => As Has Is Said In PROPOSITION 8b) Below =>
My First (& Continued) Systematic Study Of The Flash Of Insight Type Phenomenon And Other Similar Mental Arrivals. by Henry Gurr.
Continuing From Paul Wirtz’s Above-Mentioned Help, Most Of => Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”, Has Gradually Been Realized (Came To My Mind), During My ~30 Years Of => “ “Learning Ever More About Teaching, ” =>
NOTE1: TO READ MORE EXAMPLES OF => A) How I Came To This => Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”, AND
B) Instructive Examples Of My Sudden Realizations That “Came To My Mind” => In Process OF Writing This Document You Are Currently Reading. '''
To See These => Please THIRTY ONE TIMES => Do > Edit > Find > … came to my mind ... ( << This can usually be done by pressing the keyboard combination Ctrl + F (or) Edit + F depending on what your computer’s keys say.) After THIRTY ONE TIMES, will be returned back to here. NOTE2: My MPPS Article (4th Blue Link Above), Explains => C) Why & When => I Started Watching & Listening Closely To What Students Say. AFTER this Blue Link comes up => Please scroll down to, and start reading at => “Robert Fuller” Then continue reading to=> “I worked out a new system.”
… AND because I needed answers how to help students, of course I started to write-down-full-research-data-record of what did & did not help the student. This “write-down-full-research-data-record” has continued ever since, especially when I notice a Flash Of Insight, In myself and other people. D) How I First Discovered => The Flash of Insight as a Research Methodology, And Started Writing Full Research Paper Data Records, Is This => CONTINUING on above-mentioned Blue Link => Please scroll down to, and start reading at => “You will know when you have correctly found the case of a student's hang up ” Then continue reading to=> “I have (written) records of twenty four observations of hang-ups resolved by an insight jolt. I have helped students over some pretty big hurdles. I am reporting what happens based on this experience.”
Click Here => For my article “Discover And Resolve Tutoring ” (DART) This has more information about how to watch for the “Flash of Insight in Students”. AND Of Course, C) & D) Above, Are The Formative Steps How I Henry Gurr Came To Realize => What Is Stated Below (On This Document You Are Reading Now) => ******** o0OOO0o ******** PROPOSITION 16) The Overall Systematics (and Data) Of The Flash Of Insight Type Phenomenon => Illustrates The Research Uses Of => A Systematic Study of The Flash of Insight and similar Mental Arrivals. A) To Illustrate The “Workings Of” The Above PROPOSITIONS 1) Thru 15),
B) For A Quite Valuable Research Tool (and Probe) Into The Workings of Our Own Mind!
You may wish read more about My Technique For Study Of The Flash of Insight, where “I carefully wrote down all the relevant data. After you finish reading, click your Browsers Upper Left Back Arrow to return here. Please Notice & Think =>
SIDE NOTE: You can easily read brief selected passages for each above (or below), mentioned author, by > Top > Do > Edit > Find > … Each Author Above Listed Name ... ( This can usually be done by pressing the keyboard combination Ctrl + F (or) Edit + F depending on what your computer’s keys say.) (Click The Back Arrow, perhaps several times, Usually In The Upper Left Of Your Browser, To Return To Where You Were.) Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib. except for parts of i) History & ii) Flash of Insight. Except for parts of d) & e). What You Need To Know About The Flash of Insight.… Throughout History, The Flash Of Insight Is Widely Acknowledged To Be A Powerful Source Of Great Discoveries, And For This Reason => a) The Flash of Insight (and similar Mental Arrivals), have been extensively studied in Psychology, Research Referencing The Discovery Process, and featured in books and novels. In general, among many professions:
… Mathematicians, most especially, are most appreciative of the discovery power of the Flash Of Insight. They really DO understand how Insight & Flash of Insight have greatly contributed to the field of mathematics. This likely comes from their knowing the history of mathematical breakthroughs, most especially those of fellow & very famous Mathematician Henri Poincaré, who wrote up his own many wonderful (and highly productive of needed Math Break-Trough’s), Flash of Insight experiences, in great detail! For more about this, scroll down on This Document to “Tip Of An Iceberg”.
b) However => A lot of people (even experts), have a Mental BARRIER & saying =>
… “This is just too fantastic! It is NOT possible for a Brain to find Best (or near Best), as the single fundamental criterion, as a basis for sensory perception and/or guiding our lives.”
… However, I Henry Gurr believes this above mentioned MENTAL BARRIER is much of the reason that Flash of Insight Research Literature (such as Psychology, Brain Research, Neuroscience, Cognitive Science, and Philosophy), mostly does not show a discussion of An Optimum (Best or Near Best), As The Single Fundamental Criterion, For Brain Operation. c) Also in current day Western Culture, there is a partial “blind spot” to subjective qualities:
d) As a consequence of d), our Culture’s UN-questioned adoption of Scientific Materialism, where only material objects are deemed “real”. In this “scientific” proof-based mindset, subjective qualities, are treated as mere human subjective “testimony”, rather than being indisputable “reality”. Thus “subjective qualities”, such as => good, better, best, valuable, moral, honest, belief, truth, love, feelings, existing only in the human mind, and since not “material” such are deemed “not real”, and therefor => .
e) These subjective qualities are assumed to have “no objective reality”, meaning “NOT scientifically observable with physical instruments”, and thus have rather low credibility. And for this reason mostly ignored.
f) Moreover, for mental events, such as The Flash of Insight =>This low credibility is also comes from the trivializing conclusions such as =>
i) “It’s an events only in the mind”,.
ii) And especially so, since Flashes of Insight are “so crazy-out-of-the-blue, UN-Logical”.
iii) AND => This apparent “strange, puzzling origin of the Flash of Insight is so UN-logical” that it then =>
iv) The Flash of Insight Is thus => Deemed a side issue, and is thus mostly not directly applied to any theory (explanation) of how our brain or mind works.
g) This low status remains, despite facts that, The Flash of Insight & Similar Mind Events, have been the exact source of huge number of very important discoveries, in science, mathematics, industry, invention, and artistic creative works.
h) However, recent improvements in Electroencephalogram (EEG) and Functional Magnetic Resonance (FMRI), have made the Flash of Insight objectively observable, at least as “brain waves”.
… Now, Where-As => Many Insightful Authors Can Be Found, Which Partly Have An Implied “Theory How Our Mind Works”.
a) Gestalt Psychology, as is mentioned on This Document elsewhere.
b) Plenty of Discussion of Flash of Insight (As opposed to Research), are to be found in books, articles, encyclopedia, and internet: as is mentioned on This Document elsewhere..
c) My Nov 6, 2021, accidental discovery of An Excellent Research Report => “What Sudden Insights Look Like Inside The Brain.” Click Here. AFTER This Document comes up, you will read an excellent Interview Discussion of => “What your brain is doing when it has that "AHA moment.", reporting the Research of John Kounios, who leads “The Creativity Research Lab at Drexel University. [There he] uses electroencephalography (EEG) and other technology to record brain activity. The lab has been looking for something very specific: what goes on in the brain when a flash of insight hits.”
… "And an insight doesn't have to be related to a particular problem that you were thinking about. In real life, people have spontaneous insights all the time that have nothing to do with any problem that you've been working on. You could be walking down the street, and all of a sudden an idea pops into your head that solves a problem that you didn't even know you had. In that case, your brain may have been unconsciously processing ideas—for seconds, or for years. This is called incubation."
… And eventually, perhaps in our PostModern Times, these “low credibility” assumptions will eventually change, so the long spurned subjective mental phenomenae, will finally become “objective”, despite the fact that => They are not directly (external to mind, physical world), experience-able, as is perhaps demanded of most other scientific observations.
Not Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib. THE REQUIRED MAIN COMPONENTS => TO DEVISE A THEORY OF HOW OUR MIND WORKS: (THE BELOW IS ABSTRACTED FROM THE ABOVE (And Some Other In Places In This Document You Are Currently Reading.):The Building Of A Viable Proto-Theory (Explanation) Of How Our Mind Works MUST => A) Start with THIS fundamental theory foundation ((The absolutely most vital clue, as supplied by Princeton Theoretical Physicist J. J. Hopfield’s Neural Network Model: )) =>
… THE WAY, And As A Practical Matter, The ONLY LOGICAL WAY For A Brain To Operate At All Is => Find Single (singe-minded only one-at-a-time) Solutions (Answers ) Which Are Best (Or Near Best) Responses To Our Second By Second Sensory Input From Its Surrounding Environment. ….
1) ……PROPOSITION 3b) Concerning “Single Best Or Near Best” … Then continue
2) ……PROPOSITION 3c) All This Provides Very Strong Additional Support ,,,
B) Include real world observations from, a deep & expansive study of the Flash of Insight Mental Process, and similar Mental Arrivals into the Conscious Mind, and as well, incorporate both, a study of literature, and observational data from our own daily experience, and other persons.
C) Include the results of a deep & expansive study of Gestalt Psychology, since these researchers have extensively studied (and very, very, well understood the holistic nature of), Conscious Perception and Insight Problem Solving, They got it right! In fact the Literature of Gestalt Psychology, no doubt is a Tremendous Data Storehouse with which to validate this Henry Gurr Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation of How Our Mind Works”, …, and conversely!
… Building on Gestalt Psychology, French philosopher Merleau-Ponty (1908–1961), offers “original and influential work on embodiment, perception, and ontology”. (Just how Merleau-Ponty attempts to build further from the Gestaltist is discussed in Stanford Encyclopedia Of Philosophy Re Merleau-Ponty. Click Here.
D) Include The Absolutely Most Vital Clue, As Supplied By Princeton Theoretical Physicist J. J. Hopfield’s Neural Network Model: This is because Prof Hopfield has mathematically showed that Single, All At Once, Optimal (Best or Near Best) Solutions, To Complex Neural Network Input is indeed possible, indeed likely, for a biological brain.
D)cont: Hence a viable Theory of How Our Mind works, must include the ideas (and powerful results) of the research on => “Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory.”
E) Include How Memory Of Our Previous Optimal (Best or Near Best) Solutions, Is The Base For Our Newly Created Optimal (Best or Near Best) Solutions, Which In A Cycle , Are Ever Improved, regenerative upward spiral of ever improved memory. Accordingly all updates to memory are necessarily the successful product of ongoing optimized solutions, often novel, and quite creative. Thus brain memories continue to be improved, each memory re-visit, (retrieval re-activation,), because the new optimized solutions, and can creatively build upon and extend, the average of previous good solutions. These creatively improved memories in people, lead to learning, training, skills, insight, formation of habits, and expert performance.
1) The Cycle Steps Are => Original Memory > Memory ReAccesed > Provides Memory Base For Perception (& Other What Do Next) > Problem Solving Brain Mental Arrival to Consciousness With Future-Plans, Emotions & Feelings, Etc > Action > Success > Refine & Improve Solution Back Into Memory > Enhance & ReFurbish Memory. =>
2) Above Shortened To => A Regenerative Memory Cycle Of ReAccess & ReFurbish =>
3) Above Abbreviate To => ReAccess & ReFurbish Cycle.
4) Above Abbreviate To => Useful Acronym => RRC << For more related Discussion & Problem Solving Brain usages > See 18 Each > Edit > Find > …RRC …
…This cycle is also discussed in the Single and Double-Loop Learning, discussed and diagramed, half way down this Wikipedia Page. The Above Discussion Of Creative Problem Solutions, As Mental Arrivals (Such As Flash Of Insight) … Is Partly Confirmed In WebPage =>
1`) Illumination or insight (where the creative idea bursts forth from its preconscious processing into [ sudden] conscious awareness);
2) …in especially frontal lobe working memory control processes[, where creative and innovative thoughts arise. (Apparently, creative insight or the "AHA" experience is then triggered in the temporal lobe
3) In Their Title Lines => Two articles mentioned in the Notes of this Wikipedia page, show “Insight”, which means the article will discuss how “Insight is also called the “Sudden Illumination” mental event, also called “the Flash Of Insight”.
a) "Fixation, Incubation, And Insight In Memory And Creative Thinking".
b) "Incubation, Insight, And Creative Problem Solving: A Unified Theory And A Connectionist Model".
… NOTE: These mental events called “Insight” and “Illumination” are seen to be effectively Mental Arrivals, equivalent to above-mentioned => Our Problem Solving Brain’s Solutions which are sudden, automatic, spontaneous, Mental Arrivals Into Conscious Mind.] F) A Theory of How Our Mind Works => Must Have Good Fit To Our Own Direct Observations of Our Own Mind In Action, As Well Fit The important Theory Building Clues, Contained In The Huge Literature Of Psychology, Brain Research, Neuroscience, Cognitive Science, And Philosophy,
G) Be Consistent In Method & Procedure, With Other Natural Science Theories: “Methodological naturalism maintains that proper science requires strict adherence to empirical study and independent verification as a process for properly developing and evaluating explanations for observable phenomena … “
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Accurate Guiding of Real World Actions & Observations, Are The Purpose of Theory.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib. WHAT WILL BE ACCOMPLISHED BY USING => THE ABOVE MENTIONED “REQUIRED MAIN COMPONENTS => TO DEVISE A THEORY OF HOW OUR MIND WORKS”,… The Results Of Building Of THIS=> [[#HsgProtoTh | Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation of How Our Mind Works”, Will ACCOMPLISH THE FOLLOWING => A) Shows With Help Of Hopfield Neural Network Model, Just Why (As We Observe), It Is ONLY “ONE At A Time” AND ONLY The Higher Quality (Best or near Best0 Solutions That Automatically, Spontaneously, Mentally Arrive Into Our Conscious Minds.
B) Shows That Consciously Aware Ideas, Plans, & Actions, Typically Arise As Mental Arrival Solutions To Identifiable Problems, and for the most part there is no time that the brain is not working on some problem.
C) In Agreement With Professor John R. Searle => A Unique Explanation of => How Our Problem Solving Brain, Responding To Our Ever-Present Surroundings, Generates, Constructs, Creates => Our Everyday Conscious Mental Awareness =>
… Which Herein Will Be Called => Primary Consciousness, AND (As Observed) Is Automatically, Spontaneously “Just There”!
D) Professor John R. Searle’s Conclusions & Expectations => For “An Adequate Theory Of Consciousness. “ =>
… IS FULFILLED BY => Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” :
“When we get to the topic of evolution, we will see the centrality of unity in enabling Consciousness to perform its biological functions.”
… “The unified conscious field gives the organism vastly increased power.” … “The organism can coordinate an enormous number of simultaneous inputs within a single conscious field and can coordinate its behavior both in light of the sensory inputs and in light of its goals and the possible means for achieving its goals. It coordinates all of this in a way that simultaneously represents the past in the form of short-term and long-term memory and anticipates the future in the form of its plans, goals, and intentions. In the case of humans, consciousness also gives us the capacity for cooperating with con-specifics; and the specific form that human cooperation takes is the conscious use of language.”
… Professor Searle Continues => “The Conscious Mind Functions Causally In Producing Behavior, And In Conscious Perception, The Environment Is Causally Presented To The Consciousness Of The Agent.”
… “For example, in the presence of food, light reflected off the object will cause a conscious visual experience in the animal, and this experience will consciously motivate the animal to move toward the food.“
… ”intentionality is the way that the conscious organism has of relating to the environment.”
E) Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation of How Our Mind Works”, Provides A Unique Discussion Of Consciousness, Here In Called Primary Consciousness, Showing => “How Our Problem Solving Brain Automatically Generates => Clear, Whole, Understandable, MEANINGS, Which Then Immediately Mentally Arrive Into Our Consciousness, Along With Our Ongoing Experience Of Primary Consciousness.“ Click Here, For FULL Discussion of this topic.
F) Continued From E) => Of Course There Are Many Brain Actions, And/Or Solutions That Do NOT Arrive Into Our (Primary) Conscious Mind: These solutions are important in running the body, and refurbishing memory, etc. But about these we have minimal immediate awareness, simply because Nature has decided that => Our Conscious Mind, doesn’t need to know. It is mostly after the fact that we deduce the existence of these UN-conscious brain processes.
G) Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation of How Our Mind Works”, Provides A Unique Explanation Of Analogy/Metaphor/Rhyme/Poetry, which is superior to what is currently found in literature, where in it is seen that => Most current day discussion of Analogy/Metaphor/Rhyme/Poetry, are really not much better than hand-waving explanations.
… This fact, the discerning reader may see in Internet discussions, or (in Blue Link below) you can study my (Henry Gurr’s) collection of “How Various Authors Try To Say ‘How Metaphors Function’ “ . Where these Authors’ offer their “Understanding” of Human Metaphor Mental Action, Thru History.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
I) Discusses How => The Flash of Insight (and Other Similar Mental Arrivals), Are Seen To Be A Quite Valuable Research Tool (and Probe), Into Unconscious Workings of Our Own Mind! For Example =>
1) A Deep Study Of The Flash Of Insight, And Closely Observing It In Action, Shows What Our Problem Solving Brain Can Do, Spontaneously, Self-Organized, UN-Supervised, and On-Automatic.
2) The Overall Content (and Timing) Of A Flash Of Insight Or Other Mental Arrivals, May Be Used To Measure How WELL Our Perception System Is Working.
J) Henry Gurr’s Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation of How Our Mind Works”, Also => Has Important (even HUGE!), Implications For The Study of Mind, Artificial Intelligence, Ontology, Epistemology, Development of Language & Language Change, Functioning of Society, and Owen Barfield’s Evolution of Consciousness.
J) Thus I Believe The 23 PROPOSITIONS Discussion (Blue Link Below), Can Guide Us To Building A Proto-Theory (Explanation) of Mind and Consciousness , which I suspect will be as good a view as we will ever get!.
K) Other Henry Gurr Theory Accomplishments? Please send me an email with your thoughts & suggestions!
… Please well notice the above use of words “Problem Solving Brain Generated, Constructed, Created”: And these are a major consequence of Unconscious Brain Processes, which are in agreement with that described in =>Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” ... NOTE: As is discussed below => This above-mentioned Primary Consciousness created solution, is to be distinguished from other additional concurrent automatic, spontaneous, Problem Solution Mental Arrivals (as extensively discussed in This Document you are currently reading), which are much less a simulation of our external world.
This Section Is Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib. THIS ENTIRE SECTION SAYS => … WHAT THIS THEORY IS ABOUT, IS IT VALID, AND WHY YOU MIGHT WANT TO LEARN ABOUT IT. In Other Words => WHAT THIS OVERALL WEBPAGE IS TRYING TO COMMUNICATE?This Document you are currently reading, will tell you of A Striking New Theory Of How Our Mind Works. It Is “A Radically New Kind of Theory” (A New KIND Of “Philosophy of Mind” }, that will require you to read slowly, closely, & think a lot about!
Technically, for This Document you are currently reading: is => “A Philosophy Of Mind” , and should be clearly distinguished from what is officially called A Theory of Mind (ToM) ((This ToM name, although clear in context, is quite misleading! It really sould better be called A Specific Person’s Understanding (Theory), Of How Another Person’s Mind Works And It’s Contents. ))
… Wikipedia goes on to say a person’s ToM re another person’s mind is => “.. Limited to just a single person’s understanding of how other person’s mind “works”, including => “ .. attribute mental states—beliefs, intents, desires, emotions, knowledge, etc.—to oneself, and to others, without trying to say how those mental states might come about.” … “The intuitive assumption that others are minded is an apparent tendency we all share. We anthropomorphize non-human animals, inanimate objects, and even natural phenomena. Daniel Dennett referred to this tendency as taking an "intentional stance" toward things: we assume they have intentions, to help predict future behavior. However, there is an important distinction between taking an "intentional stance" toward something and entering a "shared world" with it. The intentional stance is a detached and functional theory we resort to during interpersonal interactions. A shared world is directly perceived and its existence structures reality itself for the perceiver. It is not just automatically applied to perception; it in many ways constitutes perception.”
WHAT IS A THEORY? ANY Theory (Explanation), Is A Clear, Well Organized, Compact, Summary Of Observations Of What Has Happened In This World. Good Theories Are Very Practical And Useful. Once you understand what the theory’s words mean, you will have an accurate & reliable guide (user’s manual), to get done what you want to do. This is because a good theory helps you see more clearly, think more completely, and guide you in efficient actions, with minimal waste. In other words, a good theory lets you understand what has happened, what is happening, predict what will happen, and guide your actions accordingly; HENCE THIS FOLLOWING CONCLUSION =>
A GOOD THEORY PROVIDES (ALL AT ONCE) => 1) A SUMMARY OF SCIENTIFIC OBSERVATIONS ABOUT A PARTICULAR PART OF THE UNIVERSE,
2) A WELL ORGANIZED EXPLANATION OF THESE OBSERVATIONS, WHICH TOGETHER TELL A “STORY” OF HOW THINGS (IN THIS PART OF UNIVERSE), HAVE WORKED IN THE PAST, ARE WORKING NOW, AND WILL WORK IN THE FUTURE.
3) A GOOD THEORY EFFICIENTLY GUIDES OUR ACTIONS, WORK, & FUTURE PLANS,.
WHAT ARE THE OBSERVATIONS THAT THIS PROTO-THEORY SUMMARIZES? This Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” summarizes the workings of your own mind, most especially the Flash of Insight **AHA** events that happen to you. To understand this, please read the next few lines below, marked by the a), and b). Please pay very close attention to how my descriptions of the Flash of Insight, fits your own direct experience!!!. AND as you read my PROPOSITIONS 1 -19, pay attention, how EACH Proposition Discussion fits your own direct experience!!!.
…This is a very good way to see-for-yourself, that my theory is valid, in actual real world practice! Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Thus the Purposes of Good Theories Are => a) Accurate Organizing of Observed Facts, b) Reliable Guiding of Real World Future Actions, c) Predicting Results, & d) Synchronizing (Making Sense Of) Required Observations. I’VE READ VARIOUS PLACES IN THIS DOCUMENT, & I HAPPEN TO BE READING THIS LINE HERE: --- WHAT SHOULD I START READING NEXT?
A) Be Very Sure You REALLY Understand The TOP 12 Inches Of This Document You Are Currently Reading, Including Reading The Mentioned MPPS Article. MPPS Article => “Memory, Perception, Insight, and Problem Solving – AHA---!!! => To increase your own understanding (as described in MPPS article), you should actively watch for your OWN => EIGHTEEN CHARACTERISTICS OF THE FLASH OF INSIGHT/ PROBLEM-SOLVING EVENT, and write notes as to
1) Date and Time:
2) What you were doing:
3) What caused (brought about) this Flash Of Insight: (Why did it happen?)
4) What Problem Was Solved:
5) Any earlier conditions that lead-up to this “Bolt-From-The-Blue”?
6) As your days pass => Any later thoughts on this event, or further Mental Arrivals or Insights, building on the first.
7) Make it a habit to always have pen and paper in your pocket, so you can immediately write the above.
8) You will discover that you must immediately scratch out preliminary written notes, or what happened will vanish from your memory of it. Permanently!
B) Actively Watching & Writing Down 1) thru 8) Above, Will Convince You Of The Power & Characteristics Of Your UN-Conscious Mind, and That There Really IS An UN- Conscious Mind, With A Will Of It’s Own!!! Your written note will effectively be a Flash of Insight, Mental Arrival Diary!
C) To Help You To Further Know What To Look For, Please Study My An Anatomy Of An Idea Come To Mind. AFTER This “Anatomy” Page Comes Up (For Easiest Reading), Please Scroll Down To, And Start Reading AT Where You See PHRASE => ….. (And It’s Included Links), Hopes To ……
D) In C) Above => What You Will Be Learning At First Hand, Will Help Convince You Of The Factual Truth Of The Twenty One PROPOSITIONS of This Document You Are Currently Reading.
… ALSO => The very process of => Writing notes of what you did & learned, will help solidify all this in your mind, increase understanding and help build memory of This “solidify into mind”, is amply demonstrated by a) Any person watching how they do remember, after writing notes. For myself, when I’ve written Paper Scratch Notes, that are for an idea to be typed into a document, I can mostly get the typing done without looking at the notes! b) This “solidify into mind”, is also amply demonstrated for students remembering their physic, when they make written Lab Reports. E) IN SUMMARY: You Will Be Building (In Your Mind), Your OWN Theory (Explanation) Of How Your OWN Mind Works. Ultimately, This Is The Best Kind Of Understanding:
… Altogether => You will see that “How Your Mind Works” is quite similar to The Mental Workings of other persons. Of course this is as expected, but is fun to watch anyway! F) To Be Introduced To The Basics Of This Proto-Theory, Beginners Should First Read => Just The First Paragraph Of Each PROPOSITION 1) To 19), below: This Will Help You As A Beginner To Get Oriented.
WEBPAGE NAVIGATION SUGGESTIONS:
G) As You Read This Proto-Theory’s 23 PROPOSITIONS About The Workings of Our Mind: You should pause, and for a while think about EACH … For example => Please check what I say against how well this FITS your OWN direct life experience! … In other words, you should first use you own mind (and intuition), to validate ANY theory, including mine! As was suggested in A) above, and write notes as to what you read and learned!
H) You will see that => After each the respective 23 PROPOSITIONS, I have written additional conclusions that a) Fit my own experience, and b) Also are widely & consistently corroborated in published literature. Of these you may have less experience, but hopefully these will at least reasonable to you, in light of what you already know. Some of my conclusions below, are stated as hypotheses, meaning more data and observations are needed to establish the creditability of what I say. I’ve tried to avoid making conjectures that are too speculative, or just my pure imaginative poetry!
I) When you are ready to do your first reading => Click Here To SKIP Introductory Discussions, And Go Directly To Start Of THE 23 PROPOSITIONS:
What Should I Do If I See Questionable Parts In Henry Gurr’s Theory? You may find parts of > This Proto-Theory quite questionable. That is perfectly fine, since it is, after all, a PROTO-theory! Thus, for the puzzling parts of my Theory => 1) Please Remember The Parts That Seem Wrong: And As Days Pass. Think On These, And Watch For Relevant Evidence. You might also use Google to search for more information. Eventually, after an AHA! Moment, you may suddenly see a new view that removes your doubt.
OR => 2) Please Remember The Parts That Seem Wrong: Temporarily Suspend Judgement, And Consider The Questionable Parts As A Hypothesis To Be Tested. Then Just Wait! While you wait, you could study the other “seemingly good” parts of => This Proto-Theory. As you do this, your overall conclusions may gradually move from Questionable > To Insight > To YES that’s right!
… Of course, like a good scientist, you should be always on the alert for relevant evidence and data, and keep score of what parts of => This Proto-Theory work and do not. Even after any theory is “accepted” there should be a continuous Back-Checking for validity, and close examination of what seems wrong or puzzling. 3) Reading This Proto-Theory, will thus require close reading & going slow, so the meaning and new views can sink in!! You will be doing what Robert Pirsig says, “re-arranging a lot of intellectual furniture” ,. As Immanuel Kant said “A Copernican Revolution” ,. Or doing as Thomas Kuhn said a “Paradigm Shift” .
4) I believe => Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” will help people more effectively use their own mind. The first examples of this “how to” are in the above 1) & 2) Paragraphs. The alert reader will find many more similar examples from Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” : These are in essence, contained in my suggestions, in the first 24 inches of This Document You Are Currently Reading, There-in I give similar “What-You-Should-Do” suggestions, which are likewise based on This Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”.
Please Notice & Think => You should be aware that Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” , ALSO (in part), wells agrees with the writings (and implied theory), of many insightful authors. They write quite perceptively about their own mode of discovery and their heart felt conclusions on how we all should best use our minds. Although not written with the idea of being a Philosophy of Mind, these works in their own way, many places essentially contain a Theory of How Our Mind Works!!
SIDE NOTE: You Can Easily Read Brief Selected Passages For Each Above (Or Below), Mentioned Author, By > Top > Do > Edit > Find > … Each Above Listed Name ...
HOW CAN I KNOW IF THIS PROTO-THEORY IS “TRUE”? What is important about ANY theory (explanation) is that it helps you achieve improved real-world actions, more efficient, and better results. With a good theory, you can achieve your goals & get what you want, easier and faster than with a poor one. And among the many ways to test (& know) the truth of ANY theory, is to carefully write down, the times you see the theory “work” successfully in your own life!)
Of Course, IF The Theory Is ALSO Found “True To Reality”, That Quite Significant AND Highly Desirable, But “True To Reality”, Is Not An Absolute Necessity for the theory to be quite practically useful, and thus accepted and widely used. This is in agreement with Wikipedia saying “ Instrumentalists argue that scientific theories should only be evaluated on whether they are useful. In their view, whether theories are true or not is beside the point, because the purpose of science is to make predictions and enable effective technology.” …. ” Realists often point to the success of recent scientific theories as evidence for the truth (or near truth) of current theories.”
NOTES: How The Writing This Document Came To My Mind: a) The ideas and conclusions stated in This Document You Are Currently Reading, are true to my own (Henry Gurr) direct experience & Observations. And I believe they are true to the mental workings of most other persons, and which in turn is corroborated by the relevant literature.
b) The expression “true to reality”, is a common expression understood by most readers, and sufficient for this discussion. However, both “truth” & “reality”, have uncertain meanings when philosophically examined, with careful analysis.
c) Concerning useful, but not necessarily philosophically “true” => See Heuristic on This Document You Are Currently Reading, at APPENDIX VI
… Moreover, I (Henry Gurr) strongly believe the ideas & conclusions presented hereby in This Document => Are valid, important, and provide and overall useful understanding, to guide my own and other person’s behavior. (In other words it’s a “Brain Owner’s User Manual.” ., as mentioned several other places on This Document You Are Currently Reading. (You may find a complete list of other > “Brain Owner’s User Manual.” > By > Do > Top > Edit > Find > …FOUR DIFFERENT )
HOW WILL THIS PROTO-THEORY HELP ME? Once You Understand This Proto-Theory You Will Become More Productive Towards Your Goals. But beyond this, you will have a far closer understanding of how your mind works, and how it can solve problems, in a Flash of Insight . You will understand just how new VERY GOOD ideas can mysteriously arrive “out of the blue”, and instantaneously pop into your mind (Plus what to do to make best use of these Flash of Insight occurrences, and your other skills) .
Because human the basic underlying functioning of the human mind a) Has been roughly the same for the last 100,000 years, and b) This functioning is about the same for all humans around the earth, you will have a very useful ability to more clearly ”see-into” those humans behavior and what they must have been thinking across time and culture.
…This Knowledge Will Help You Better Understand Your “Mind At Work” In The Creation Of => Your own (and other people’s), new Sudden, Automatic, Spontaneous, Mental Arrivals. This Knowledge will help your understand other person’s => realizations, motivations, and limits, and thus get along better with them and your society.
YOU WILL FIND THIS DOCUMENT YOU ARE CURRENTLY READING, OVERALL IS HARD READING …Reading this will likely be hard going, because Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” will be so unfamiliar, your reading of it below will require close reading & going slow so the meaning and new views will sink in!
…Much of the reading difficulty is because these ideas are so new and un familiar, it is hard to see what is meant: These ideas are so new because you have not been “exposed” to them. This is because such ideas are mostly NOT part of your culture. (This is fact, and that these ideas are mostly culturally missing, partly explains why these ideas fail to appear in my extensive literature research.)
END SECTION: What My Theory Is About & Why You Might Want To Learn About It. AN EMAIL LETTER TO FAMOUS NEW YORK TIMES AUTHOR, Sept 24, 2017.
Dear Mr J. G. You perhaps already know, that brain process such as the Flash of Insight, are a direct result of important, fundamental, and deeply built-in, automatic brain problem solving processes, deserving our closest attention. However, despite the fact that Flashes of Insight have led to many amazing discoveries, our culture, brain scientists, and especially academic philosophers, as a group, tend to ignore the Flash Of Insight (and subjective mental events related to the Flash Of Insight). This is because they (especially Philosophers), do not trust anything that just mysteriously ‘happens’, or totally illogically comes “out-of-the-blue.” However, the Flash of Insight can be an important starting point for a Theory of How Our Mind Works: Additionally the absolutely most vital clue for Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” , is supplied by Princeton Theoretical Physicist J. J. Hopfield’s Neural Network Model. The Hopfield Physics Theory, with its Mathematical Proof, tells us in broad brush strokes how a collection of interconnected neurons spontaneously, unsupervised, automatically, following its own rules, indeed might truly be able to find Optimal, (Best or Near Best) Solutions. AND indeed, be able to do so “suddenly” (came to my mind) as in The Flash of Insight!! In addition, Hopfield’s Physics & Mathematical Theory, with its Mathematical Proof, solidly establishes how a network of neurons will produce a good, but not perfect, result very quickly. For a biological organism, this is clearly an ecologically advantageous trade off (This is in contrast to the usual digital computer that will produce a perfect, highly accurate, result but may take a very long time on certain problems). In Building A Theory Of How Our Mind Works (ie A Philosophy Of Mind), The Properties Of Neural Networks (Of Which Hopfield’s Model Is An Example), Deserve Very Close Attention.
a) Biological Neural Networks form a very powerful computational mechanism, which can create an unsophisticated brute force, all purpose, general problem-solving biological device, that gets Optimal (Best or Near Best) Problem Solutions by massive parallel processing and massive in-depth memory! This mechanism, in other words, is a crude but effective, one size fits all, quite powerful sledge hammer. (These are the powerful consequences of what here in is called the “Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory.” , which in turn is a VERY important italicized 11 word name & idea, as emphasized in this paragraph, and the next 3 paragraphs below.) .
b) Constitute a general problem-solving mechanisms, where we can see the possibility that => The Neural Networks actions are AUTOMATICALLY & SPONTANEOUSLY. self-built, self-organized, UN-supervised, follows its own rules, and runs fully on-automatic: The only apparent non-self (internal) control, seemingly comes from the sensory organs, external and internal.
c) As Is Required For ANY Theory (Explanation) of How Out (Biological Based) Mind Works => Such Neural Networks and their spontaneous actions must be, compatible with biological evolutionary development (phylogeny), from the very beginning of moving animals on earth.
d) Also Such Neural Networks and their spontaneous actions must be, compatible with biological growth and development (ontogeny), of a single organism from gestation to adult.
THUS: Neural Networks, such as proposed by Prof Hopfield, 1) Well fit what can be built up by means of Darwinian Evolution, and 2) Well fit what can be created from fertilized egg, growing to an adult, dynamically learning, and developing. ... Also such Neural Networks, as proposed, well fit what we see in the obvious fine-tuned behavior of animals and ourselves, both mentally and in subsequently emerged physical real-world body actions. Such a system supports Darwinian Survival, and thus we are here to tell the story! From this I assert that: The cause and overall systematics of these Hopfield general solutions underlie and are the foundation of our mental life and resulting Consciousness. This conclusion, is the basis of Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” of How Our Mind Works. More Over => This Conclusion Strongly Supports Prof John R Searle’s Own Stated Conclusions => [with the] " … enormous powers that Consciousness gives us. The organism can coordinate an enormous number of simultaneous inputs within a single conscious field and can coordinate its behavior both in light of the sensory inputs and in light of its goals and the possible means for achieving its goals. It coordinates all of this in a way that simultaneously represents the past in the form of short-term and long-term memory and anticipates the future in the form of its plans, goals, and intentions. ”
Besides Prof Searle, a number of Brain Scientists, & Philosophers have an understanding of Human Mental Processes that in part, agree with Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” And Conversely. Significant support is seen in the thinking of the following Authors => Tom Cornsweet, J J Hopfield, Robert Pirsig, Owen Barfield, Michael Polanyi, B F Skinner, John K Sheriff, Charles Peirce, Bessel van der Kolk, Jeffrey W. Cooney & Michael S. Gazzaniga, Daniel Dennett, George Lakoff, and many, many others. (If you want more information, please email.)
You should know that I’m an unknown newcomer to this study of mind, and of course no match to the range of knowledge or experience of other Philosophy of Mind Researchers. However, I hope you can accept new theory ideas from a newcomer, since Often A Beginner’s Mind is a virtue when it comes to realizing a new kind of theory and/or breakthrough ideas. And based on my 30 years of searching, I believe This Proto-Theory Outlined Click Here will be quite different, at the frontier of science, from any point of view you have ever seen previously. Thus, this is likely to provide you with a considerably different Alternate Conception, for seeing into “How Our Mind Works”. Most of what is presented below comes from the Literature on Creativity, Mind, Brain Science, Vision, Psychology Especially Gestalt, Creative Problem Solving, Invention, Teaching, Learning, Writing, Philosophy, etc. Most of this is previously known, but scattered in confusing, unrelated pieces of information. As such, most of what I say is not new, and much or all of it may already be known to you. But I Believe What Deserves Your Attention Is This =>
As I’ve found in Electronic Troubleshooting => When puzzles are solved, and from this more & more ideas fit, and make sense => This means you are on the right track! (The “more-fit-sense-of-knowing-on-right-track”, needs more literature research.) However, in extensive literature research, this full panorama is NOT found, to good approximation. In other words, my Henry Gurr “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” (At Blue Link Above). will be so UN-familiar, your reading of it below will take some, as Robert Pirsig says, “re-arranging a lot of intellectual furniture”, As Immanuel Kant said “A Copernican Revolution”, Or as Thomas Kuhn said a “Paradigm Shift”.((Of course, it you know of any writing (or author) that seems to be even partly similar to mine, please let me know. Click on Contact Me below.)) I trust this letter will be a suitable introduction, and hope you will find interesting. I will gladly send more information and answer your questions. Especially so, because our brain and sensory organs are marvelously complex & intricate, there must be a whole lot more to the story! PS: It is a separate puzzle to me how this overall Proto-Theory (so very obvious in retrospect), can NOT be found in published literature. Sincerely Henry Gurr, Professor of Physics Emeritus,
SIDE NOTE1: For ~30 Years Now), I’ve Of Course Watched My OWN Mind At Work,
SIDE NOTE2: Please Be Aware That There Are Authors Who Are Especially Good At Observing Their Own Mind Creates Best Or Near Best Solutions (Answers). Automatically & Spontaneously. This includes => Robert Pirsig in his book “Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance” (ZMM) … Mr Pirsig offers many examples, which have resulted from watching their own mind, and we can learn much from what he does in actual practice.
At this point, it might be helpful for you dear reader, to take a break and think things over. Just make sure to return to here, when you are ready for more! Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Please, start with this Vantage Point and read my words with a “Beginners Mind”.
Then, excusing where I’m => Telling You What You Already Know
This Entire Section, Is A Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib. AN INTRODUCTORY OVERVIEW OF THE 23 PROPOSITIONS of Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”.… It Is Productine And Revealing To Consider That Everything The Brain Does Is General Problem Solving Which Finds A Single, Optimal (Best Or Near Best), Solutions To Life’s Oncoming Problems. … Only When A Single Solution Has Sufficient Quality Or Overall Coherence Does This Solution Appear In Conscious Mind, Concurrent With A Plan For Future Action (Our Intentions), Appropriate To The Situation.
For Reasons That Will Be Supported Below: => To Achieve These Optimal (Best or Near Best) Solutions, It Is Necessary For Our Problem Solving Brain, To Calculate” How Well Current 9 Senses Inputs Fit Relevant Memories, With Weight More Heavily On => How Recent In Time, Relative Importance, And Salience,. 1) Because there is no way to know in advance, exactly what specific part of memory is important, the brain has no other recourse, it then MUST use ALL existing memory in order to determine the meaning of ongoing sensory inputs, and from all available potentials, calculate what parts are most salient, and then =>
2) Make a balanced, logically complete, plan for future action (intention), the unity of which is established and guaranteed by the a) criterion of optimum, and b) the use of a massive lifetime of memories, which themselves have the stamp of success and validity, as was tested in the real world of action, and survival! This is because, with every successful solution, our brain ~goes-back to“ and automatically improves those self-same previous successful memories, which, were used for any creative solution, which Mentally Arrived into our Consciousness.
3) This is the only viable way an animal’s brain (and mind) can get ANY answer, let alone an optimal (best or near-best) result, in respond to life’s oncoming problems.
( Editor RPG Comment: Besides brains using memory for finding solutions, they may also incorporate instinct, a kind of genetic memory: For example, humans nearly ubiquitously have a fear of snakes on an instinctive level and perceive "threat" without previously encountering an actual snake, or even hearing about one.)
CONCERNING THE MEANING OF WORDS => “Best Or Near Best” – “Problem Solutions” => That Mentally Arrive into Our Conscious Mind =>
NOTE1: Our God Given Body & Mind Comes With The Ability To Automatically Know => A) “What Is Good”, B) “What Is ~Best”, C) “How To Work In The ~Best Ways , E) What is Quality, And F) What Is The Cutting Edge Of Reality. NOTE2: Above E) thru F) Are Major Topics So Very Well Explicated By Robert Pirsig, In His “Zen And The Art Of Motorcycle Maintenance” '' (ZMM).
NOTE3: As You Will Eventually Come To Realize => Mr. Pirsig’s Two Books, Are Close To Presenting => “A Theory of How Our Mind Works” , AND has Conclusions That Nicely Support => , Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”. , You Can Learn More About This These Links =>
4) Further explication is in Chap 10 of => Sarah Vinke Biography.
( Editor RPG Comment: In biological systems, this ~”Best”, isn’t necessarily always the superior ->–When going for “best:, there may be added resource consumption and requirements might not always pay off. Even in cognition itself, “best” doesn’t always pay off either, as in the class Ascidiacea [or sea squirt], which has a ganglia network in its larval stage, but loses it entirely when it matures! As far as I can tell, greater cognition is advantageous for rapid environmental change, whereas in constant environments it’s selected against. Human cognition may have reached its modern state due to a constantly shifting environment which evolution can’t program for quickly enough!)
CONCERNING THE MEANING OF => 47 Synonym Words, Related To Word => {+Optimum}+. These Are => apex, summit, top, crest, pinnacle, mountaintop, spire, heights, brow, crown, crest, peak, top, vertex, maximum, maximal, optimum, optimal, largest, greatest, tip, cap, vertex, zenith, high point, high spot, highlight, climax, culmination, consummation, epitome, ascendancy, crowning point, peak of perfection, best, near best, acme, apogee, prime, heyday, ne plus ultra, nonpareil, best part, perfection, top form, highest level, goes over the top, Plus similar listing for other languages! (A Glossary, is in preparation.)
… Also See In This Document You Are Currently Reading, The Topics Of: => a) “Generate” b) “Construct”, c) “Create”, d) “Primary Consciousness”, as well as => e) “The ‘Seven (Plus/Minus Two) Solutions”’ f) In Consciousness” g) “Constructivism”, h) “Constructivist Epistemology”,…. The START Of => The 23 PROPOSITIONS FOR A NEW KIND OF “PHILOSOPHY OF MIND”, Concerning =>Henry S Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation of How Our Mind Works” , Presented On The Page You Are Reading Right Now. Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
a) Human Memory Ability (herein s/b called Remember): What is the name of the Capital of Iowa?
b) Perception: From the colored light patterns, whose face is that?
c) Thinking: How can I best get all these suitcases into my car?
d) Visualizing, Imagining => Which sunset scene was the most glorious.
e) Engineering Problem => The amount of manpower, materials, and time it takes to build a pyramid.
f) In Writing and composition, typing or hand-writing, and suddenly finding the correct word, to achieve a communicative purpose.
g) Moment By Moment => Operate the controls, clutch, gear shift, and steering wheel of a car, to follow a path on a map, through city streets to get to a new job.
h) Sudden Danger Recognition > Body Motion Evasive Action > Then Speaking Language > When a person suddenly realizes an imminent accident, they start avoidance action and simultaneously emit emotional warning words, or sometimes as expletive two words, which you can guess.
i) Even the Problem Solution that suddenly arrives “out of the blue”, resulting in the Flash Of Insight and other similar phenomena herein called Mental Arrivals, whether arrive suddenly, out of the blue or otherwise un-noticed.
PROPOSITION 2b): BRAIN’S STORED MEMORIES OF PAST SUCCESSES, ARE USED TO GUIDE FUTURE BEHAVIOUR:
This Entire Interlude Section, Is A Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
A) FIRST PART Here Some Readers May Think =>
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
… The fact that a future plans are based on past successful behaviour, will also FORCE good logic and math completeness. This is because the solution (including future plans), was formed, in a large part, from previous innovative, Optimum (Best or Near Best), and long term successful actions as the result of some even earlier successful plan.
******** o0OOO0o ******** B) SECOND PART => MY ABOVE “DARWINIAN EVOLUTION” SENTENCE, IS WELL SUPPORTED IN THE FOLLOWING DISCUSSION OF => BEHAVIORIST RESEARCHER, B. F. SKINNER, IN HIS OWN ILLUMINATING WAY =>
Although Prof Skinner’s Article “Selection By Consequences “ May Seem Quaint & Too Simplistic, I Believe That =>
a) We find these Theoretical Models to be a useful, and productive, and helps us => Get- on-with our life, namely as a guide to how to best use our own mind / body! AND
b) We fully & always remember that we have adopted such Theoretical Model for this usefulness, and have provisionally set aside whether or not, certain of our Theoretical Models are literally factually true! AND
c) As we use such “Imaginary” Theoretical Models we will not worry too much because => Most (if not all), of what we know & believe are also of this “Imaginary” status! Eventually you may come to realize that this “Imaginary” status is ALSO true of major scientific ideas (really concepts), such as Chemical Bonds, The Biological Gene, The Force Of Gravity, The Particles As Waves In Quantum Mechanics, Elementary Particles In Physics even their Between Particle Forces, AND even our Own Money!! For All Of These And Many More => “Convenient Fiction” Is An Apt Term For Indicating Their Status in Our World Of Ideas & Concepts! NOTE: Concerning The Above Mentioned “Theoretical Mental Models”: For Such Models, & Indeed, ANY Major Scientific Idea OR Major Theory => These “Models” Can Be VERY Useful BUT We Must NEVER Forget => These Are Created By Humans, & Thus Have Provisional Status! AND Are Not Any Final Truth. Click here, and AFTER the new page comes up scroll down to THIS => A NECESSARY SIDE NOTE & INTERLUDE: A GOOD THEORY IS MAGIC !!.
END FIRST INTERLUDE FOR A VERY LENGTHILY EXPLANATION =>
… HOW PAST SUCCESS, SAVED INTO MEMORY, PROVIDES BASIS FOR FUTURE PLANS & RESULTANT BEHAVIOUR … … This INTERLUDE EXPLANATION => Was A Preparation for => PROPOSITIONS 3): THRU 5): NEXT FOLLOWING: => ******** o0OOO0o ******** Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
a) Physical => muscular actions like tool using, trail following, speaking or written communication, etc (Such as f) & h) above.)
b) Mental => memory, perception, thinking, ideas, etc. (Such as a) thru e) above.)
The Above PROPOSITION 3a): Statement MEANS =>
a) All the person’s current input from the 9 senses, responding to the real world.
b) Nearly all of a person’s past lifetime of experiences & thoughts retained in that person’s “Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory” << This may simply be called “Brain’s Memory” or “Memory”, in This Document you are currently reading:
CAUTION: This “Brain’s Memory” is NOT to be confused with “Personal Memories”, such as a Person Can Remember => Names, Numbers, Songs, Poems, Stories, Etc) c) And although we have little knowledge how our Problem Solving Brain really operates (on the inside), we do have some very vital clues of just how it is possible, to create these Solutions (Answers). These clues may be best understood by studying => The Neuronal Motel of Princeton Physicist J J Hopfield. After this WebPage comes up, please scroll ~half way down to => A NETWORK OF NEURONS: A BRIEF INTRODUCTION.
d) Similar to c) above => We absolutely do not know just how nature has created within us the Mental Experiences that are presented into our Conscious Mind. This most especially includes =>
… “Primary Consciousness” , An Automatically, Spontaneously, Generated (Constructed Created) As => i) A Mental Visual “Theater Stage”, A Mental Visual “Action Arena” or Platform Or “Performance Space”, INTO Which Can Then Appear =>
ii) The Other Herein Discussed Problem Solution Sudden Automatic Spontaneous, Mental Arrivals, That ADDITIONALLY Come Into Our Primary Consciousness Mind.
e) NOTE: During what we call Consciousness, we have such experiences as => Know, See, Be Aware Of, Think, Think About, Apprehend, Consider, Understand, Appreciate, Have Meaning, etc. And again, we absolutely do not know just how brain does this, or make us aware of other presentations into our Conscious Mind.
In The Above, Please Notice the Word “CREATIVE” => As Applied to => The Generation, Construction, Creation, of ANY Optimum Solution That Mentally Arrives Into Consciousness.
… AND Just How Our Brain Does This, Requires A Good Understanding Of This Document You Are Currently Reading => Especially Following Discussion Which Includes Concepts Such As These => a) “Trial & Error”,
b) “To Fill In”,
c) “Slide to Better & Better”,
d) “Spontaneous Brain Slide”,
e) Quality Measure”,
f) “Degree of Partial Fit”
g) “Greatest Fitness”, and
h) “What Is Really Happening”.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
i) The ACCESS to the various parts of the massive PREVIOUSLY saved memories of the 9 senses inputs from the surrounding world, are =>:
ii) Successively gradually “adjusted” for a slides to Better And Better Partial Fit to the existing present moments ongoing 9 senses inputs from the surrounding world.
… In other words => There is search in the brain’s memory for the previously saved 9 senses input patterns (ie previous Problem Solutions for a similar life’s problem coming at us in a similar physical circumstance), which have been previously saved into our massive associative memory bank, just on purpose, ready to be so used.
… In Other Words => There Is A Slide To A Better And Better Solution (Partial) Fit, Better Than Any Previous Optimum (Best or Near Best) Solution)
a) The Cycle Steps Are => Original Memory > Memory ReAccesed > Provides Memory Base For Perception & Other What Do Next > Problem Solving Brain Mental Arrival to Consciousness With Future-Plans, Emotions & Feelings, Etc > Action > Success > Refine & Improve Solution Back Into Memory > Enhance & ReFurbish Memory. =>
b) Above Shortened To => A Regenerative Memory Cycle Of ReAccess & ReFurbish =>
c) Above Abbreviates To => ReAccess & ReFurbish Cycle.
d) Above Abbreviates To => Useful Acronym => RRC << For more related Discussion & Problem Solving Brain usages > See 18 Each > Edit > Find > …RRC …
These Creatively Improved Memories In People, Lead To Learning, Training, Skills, Insight, Formation Of Better Habits, And Thus Expert Performance. These Genuine Creative Solutions, On Purpose, Keep On Building Up In Our Brain’s Memory, Our Whole Life!
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
A) How does our mind set the criterion, to even start the process of making a solution?
B) Or even set the threshold quality fitness criterion for the single solution to appear in Consciousness?
C) How do we understand the very important circumstance of “Partial Fit”, where the Problem Solving Brain, goes only “part way” finding a solution that would fully “fits” “Life’s Problems Coming At Us”. #SlideToB&B
PROPOSITION 3c): To Answer These Fundamental Questions => Below Is My Rather Long Hypothesis, For Brain Solution Mental Arrivals Of =>
1) If such a small (Nascent Mental Arrival) start is allowed to survive, the newly formed activation may spread by finding increased coherence in other memories (better partial fit), and/or be amplified by its own positive feedback regeneration.
2) In continued spreading and building, there might be mergers with other mutual-coherence-supporting activations (better partial fit). (In This Document you are currently reading, see also a related discussion expressed in terms of “Fitness” defined herein as => Quality Measure of Fitness.)
3) In other words, the nascent Mental Arrival responds to its own positive feedback regeneration AND ability to spread AND become stronger (better partial fit), likely all the while supplying ever growing suppression, to the other less-coherence-supporting nascent Mental Arrival Solutions.
4) We can suppose eventually there is a Winner-Take-All, because the stronger coherences, positive feedback, grow at the now diminishing expense of the other weaker ones.
5) It is likely that the above, are responses of positive feedback regeneration: This could have consequences such as =>
a) Once started, it guarantees a growing (ever winning, better & better partial fit ) Single Solution.
b) And starting from nascent, the developing Mental Arrival, will grow to saturation and thus can’t self-grow any more. In other words: The Positive Feedback Growth is Self-Limiting.
c) This provides an answer, to how endless, UN-stable positive feedback, will not lead to disaster:
d) And in which case (hypothesis), rather than disaster, the saturation is big enough to actually break thru into a full Mental Arrival into Consciousness!
e) This solves the problem of “How does our brain set the ~Threshold for a Solution To Appear Into Consciousness!
f) This also provides an answer to how, for example, our brain can respond so rapidly (~0.2 seconds) to sudden danger. And even how the Solution mental Arrival can Flash, Whole Complete, In An Instant, Into Our Awareness!
g) Once the Mental Arrival has thus reached the conscious level, this same positive feedback regeneration (along with continuous support from the senses and other solution coherences), will support this continuing Consciousness, until weakened by various means. =>
h) One such means, is called Neuron Synaptic Fatigue, or Short-Term Synaptic Depression. This gradually weakens the strength of any synapse connection. Upon sufficient overall weakening of the coherences mentioned above, this self-same positive feedback that once guaranteed growth (to saturation), will do the reverse. Once the weakening is started, the positive feedback will act to guarantee a continued weakening, until extinction.
i) Such extinction will happen, unless some other factors serve to keep the Mental Arrival present in Consciousness. These factors might be, changes in sensory input (motions in the visual field, or changes in person’s body posture), or maintenance if intrinsic interest by continues conscious active thinking or active imagination, even daydreaming: See list under Edit > Find > … Never Stays There …. This topic needs further study.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
A) You are actively watching one set of actions, this shuts out seeing any other action(s), and you entirely fail to see other concurrent very obvious actions.
B) Your mind has been recently primed to see certain things, and in finding these, are thus diverted and blocked from seeing others. Example: You were told to look for one item, and thus fail to see others. Only later you see the other thing, and only then realize what has happened.
C) This B) is “visual priming”: Similar can happen when you see the familiar, and overlook the unfamiliar.
D) Mental Blockage happens when dealing with Difficult Intellectual Territory => Students or researchers, when trying to understand a complex book or research topic), may be stalled. And then, finally break-thru’s, Mental Arrival Solutions, might suddenly automatically spontaneously, start to happen! But only after a long struggle, and possibly giving up temporarily.
E) Similar to C) happens to Professional Scientists. As mentioned above => Read Thomas Kuhn’s “Structure of Scientific Revolutions”.
F) ''' The Whole Topic Procrastination, Is Also Where Mental Blockages also happens =>: This boils down to a person’s brain steering them away from starting a big job, that their brain “knows” will be a painful project, despite the project’s ultimate importance!
….To read more on
G) In general you should be watching for any of your Sudden Mental Arrival Type Of New Discoveries, whether => New ideas, new thinking, new methods, new tools, etc, and be keeping a written diary of these…AND as you do this => Give special attention, when & how, the discovery changes & makes better what you been doing for a long time. You will realize the “Better Way”, has been there all along, but since the “Previous Way” was a habit, you were channeled, and this determined what you actually did! This diverted your attention & Future Plans, AWAY from any “Better Way”. In other words => Your old habits and ways, effectively Blocked, anything new or better. This is a blockage similar to A) & B) above.
… Hence The Following Rule => “Adequate Is The Enemy Of Better!” And You Will See This, If You Start Watching For It!
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
a) ONLY ONE is a necessary mathematical correlate of a Mathematical MAXIMUM, either Local or Absolute. AND
b) This is very much what is observed => Our brain’s general problem solving solutions, which Mentally Arrives Into Our Conscious Mind, are BOTH => Single AND Near Optimum (Best or Near Best.).
c) The a) & b) above are well established by common observation and careful scientific studies, such as Gestalt Psychology, which extensively studied Conscious Perception and Flash of Insight Problem Solving. They got it right!
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
A) Do In Fact Seek Best Or Near Best Solution To The Problem At Hand.
B) Moreover This Fits Logical & Real World Conditions =>
a) Where this Brain’s Single Solution, is a direct inescapable corollary to a condition a Mathematical Maximum => There can be ~”only-one-at-a-time”.
b) And we clearly see in this case => Best (Near Best, Optimum) Solution, must be taken as The Fundamental Criterion For Brain Operation. AND
c) As stated above => The fact that this is exactly what observed, most of the time gives very strong support for the veracity of Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” .
d) And this in turn points to the general applicability of the Hopfield Model}, as the basis for a Theory of How Our Mind Works.
e) And if the Hopfield Model is found lacking, then some other similar theory should be sought, perhaps some similar form of, Optimizing Biological Brain Neural Network, on this WebPage called => “'Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory.”
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
a) These Solutions (Answers) Are Single One-At-A-Time AND Best Or Near Best, Having Near Optimal Mental Coherence.
b) Seeking the Best or Near Best Solution to the problem at hand, is practically (and theoretically), the ONLY way to define and achieve any practical real-world solution.
c) Both a) & b) are solidly supported by what we actually observe, namely. => Automatic, Spontaneous, Mental Arrivals are (pretty much) all at once, single, optimal (maximum or near maximum) solutions to the problem at hand. And are coherent, holistic, unified, logical, mathematically complete, no inconsistencies, and similar ways of saying it.
d) ATTENTION: The observed characteristic listed in a) & b), are necessary, in order for us to be effective in our own real-world, which is logically & mathematically itself, this way!! Please see additional discussion at Top > Edit > Find quick "single minded" .
e) HOWEVER, THIS RAISES THE QUESTION => What is it that, can guide (or cause), the unstructured mass called our brain, to be shaped & constrained to be this => logical mathematical way!!!
f) ANSWERE => As already implied => The “shaping & constraint” is provided by our having to successfully complete plans and actions in a world that is itself logical & mathematical! AND these conditions are thus subsequently stored in memory, where upon future solutions must of necessity meet the same conditions to become a solution.
g) Thus, as mentioned previously, any solution must include, logical and mathematical validity. AND as said previously “Only when a single solution has sufficient quality or overall coherence, will it appear in Consciousness, concurrent with a plan for future action (intentions), appropriate to the situation.” These conditions are thus constrained into any solution, by dynamic interaction with the physical world, which itself is that way!
h) IN SUMMARY;=> The Optimal (Best or Near Best) Problem Solutions (and concomitant Plans + Emotions), in response to Logical & Mathematically based sensory input, having accessed (and utilized) all relevant memories, which then are subsequently updated, thus are improved and solidified:
i) Thus the brain basis for all learning and formation of ever more functional habits, or ever improvement of skilled human performances, will come out to be Logically and Mathematically Consistent!! In other words we are trained to be able to “see” and “comprehend” a world that makes sense!
… Again this comes from => An Optimizing Creative Memory Cycle =>, Which Creatively Achieves => New Learning, Refinement Of Skills, Better Habits, Improved, Solidified, Updated Knowledge, For more related Discussion & Problem Solving Brain usages > See 18 Each > Edit > Find > …RRC … Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib. except possibly A) B) F) & G).
A) SIMULTANEOUSLY CREATIVELY SOLVE THE PRESENT EXISTING PROBLEM, and
B) IN THE SAME PROCESS, ACT AS A MEMORY RETRIEVAL.
C) Please Note Well => Such Brain Actions, Function Automatically (when Finding Optimal (Best or Near Best) Solutions), and do so with NO external control NOR any supervision / guidance. This is the reason, in This Document you are currently reading, it says “Spontaneous & Automatic” so often! … Thus the results of this type of Memory, are Creative, Innovative, and Autonomous, in every sense of these words. (Please study these words in a dictionary, and remember!)
… Thus whenever you herein see either Spontaneous or Automatic, you may more properly (& best), think the word => Autonomous! D) Notice in B), the assertion that all Problem Solutions, that Mentally Arrive into our Conscious Mind, Are Memory Retrievals, despite the fact that we don’t ordinarily think of them as such.
E) Just how Biological Problem Solving Brain actually funcrions, may be best understood by studying the Neural Model of Princeton Physicist J J Hopfield. After this WebPage comes up, please scroll ~half way down to => A NETWORK OF NEURONS: A BRIEF INTRODUCTION
E) The Above, A) & B) Are VERY Important Ideas: Please Remember These Characteristic Of What We Can Now Name => The ‘‘ “Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory”. ''
F) Other experts call this “Associative Computation”, OR ‘Auto-Associative Memory” OR Optimizing Problem Solving Accessed, Content Addressable, Associative Memory (That Can Self-Up-Date Memory Contents In Response To Experience & Learning), OR Hopfield Model of Neural Network.
G) In This Document you are currently reading, the special use of the term =. “Associative Memory” , is an extension of what Wikipedia says => “Associative Memory (psychology), is the ability to learn and remember the relationship between UN-related items. [In Computers, this may be called “Associative Storage”, or “Content-Addressable Memory”:
H) Our Brain’s “Memory” is used to hold facts, ideas, knowledge, instructions, images, etc for later use. This, in function, is similar to => TWO types of computer hardware “memory” that used in our typical digital computer => .
1) The computer’s Hard Drive (or Solid State Drive) with typically 500 to 2000 GB capacity.
2) The computer’s form of “memory” often called “Random Access Memory’ (RAM) with typically 1 to 8 GB capacity. RAM memory is similar in turn to the “Memory Chips” you likely use daily => a) “Secure Digital” (SD), and b) “USB memory sticks”. ]
H) Because our Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory”. '' can learn relationship between UN-Related items”, “ANYTHING, CAN MEAN ANYTHING!!” It’s totally arbitrary! Here are some examples =>
1) This scrap of paper I have just placed on my driveway, means I must be sure to close car trunk prior to rain.
2) This pile of salvaged lumber, means, watch out for rusty nails sticking up.
3) The color of blood means it has iron in it’s hemoglobin.
4) The color of Mars, means it has iron-rich dust, AND is the color of blood made by Mars, the God Of War. .
5) Because of its -red color in the night sky, associated with blood by the Ancient Romans, thus they named the planet Mars, for The God of War & Bloodshed. For further reading: After this WebPage comes up, please scroll down to | With Our Human Sign System :
**********
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib. & Emphasis.
ABOVE YOU HAVE BEEN INTRODUCED TO IDEA =>
PROPOSITION 4a): FOR THE SPECIAL CASE OF =>
Concerning The Formation Or, And What Mentally Appears In PRIMARY CONSCIOUSNESS => We Can Say The Following Equivalent, As Expressed In Human Understandable Words =>
SUMMARY: For The problem Solving Brain => A Partial Fit Problem Solution, Is Used To Start A Process, That By Spreading Activation, Builds To A Better & Better Partial Fit Problem Solutions: Of Course => ALL The While This Still Is A Partial Fit Problem Solution, Just Better And Better. Examples Of This Are Discussed And Demonstrated With Camouflage Photos, Click Here & AFTER This WebPage Comes Up, Scroll Down To => TAKING UP THE TOPIC OF => ANIMAL CAMOUFLAGE Concerning Our Perceiving Of The EXTERNAL World => When Any On-Coming Partial Fit Problem Solution, Is Of Sufficient Quality, It Mentally Arrives Into Our Conscious Mind (Called herein Primary Consciousness), And Subsequently We Perceive A Glorious 3D World In Full Color Around Us!
AND: Once We Fully Understand The Above Creative “Partial Fit Problem Solution + Pattern Match + Partial Fit + Trial Fill In” Process, And Its Continued Optimizing, With Additional, “Trial And Error Fill-In”, We Can Advance To => PROPOSITION 4b): => PROPOSITION 4b): From The Above => AND Consistent With What Is Observed => NOW We Can GENERALIZE =>
Wikipedia, Contributes To These Ideas With Added Information Concerning Mental Models, That Are Mental Arrival Into Our Conscious Mind =>
Ditto For Most Of The Remainder Of This Wikipedia Page, Saying For Examples =>
NOTE1: Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” , Discussed On This Document You Are Currently Reading, Is Related To Other Fields Of Inquiry, Such As =>
NOTE2: This Document You Are Currently Reading, Discusses Sudden, Automatic, Spontaneous, Mental Arrivals Into Our Conscious Mind Of =>
1) The sentence ~9 inches /\ABOVE/\ that has in it name Kenneth Craik . And
2) The 60 inches\/BELOW\/ At Section saying => PROPOSITION 7a .
PROPOSITION 4c): Consequences Of Further GENERALIZE =>
FIRST by ClickDrag way-way-up to essentially straight overhead. then
SECOND by ClickDrag way-way-up to essentially straight down.
THIRD by ClickDrag way-way-to-the-right (or left), and continue to 360 degree full circle.
FOURTH you can ClickOn the LowerRight (Plus Or Minus) Icons to Zoom In or Zoom Out.
At any time you may ClickOn the road ahead, to move the GSV Camera Location to approximately that road location. Repeated “ClickOn the road ahead”, will gradually move the GSV more and more ahead. This Henry Gurr calls “GSV Drive” on down the road.
… NOTE: The Discussion ABOVE => The Problem Solving Brain’s => “Continued Improvements (Better & Better)” => Might Be Titled => “Dynamic Quality” = “The Leading Edge Of Perception!” , Which Robert Pirsig Calls “The Cutting Edge Of Reality” !
PROPOSITION 4d): AND Consistent With What Is Observed => We Can Further Hypothesize, In Human Understandable Terms That =>
PROPOSITION 4e): Once We Understand, The Above “Problem Solution, Better & Better, Partial Fill-In Of (And At) The Leading Edge Of Perception!”,
PROPOSITION 4f): This Document You Are Currently Reading, Has An Earlier Stated Conclusion (Consistent With What Is Observed) => Which Is NOW AMENDED (UP-DATED) To The following=>
… This is A Cycle Of Regenerative Upward Spiral Of Compounded, Creative, Building-On-(And Beyond)-The-Previous, Ever Improved Problem Solutions, Then Stored In Memory. a) The Cycle Steps Are => Original Memory > Memory ReAccesed > Provides Memory Base For Perception & Other What Do Next > Problem Solving Brain Mental Arrival to Consciousness With Future-Plans, Emotions & Feelings, Etc > Action > Success > Refine & Improve Solution Back Into Memory > Enhance & ReFurbish Memory. =>
b) Above Shortened To => A Regenerative Memory Cycle Of ReAccess & ReFurbish =>
c) Above Abbreviate To => ReAccess & ReFurbish Cycle.
d) Above Abbreviate To => Useful Acronym => RRC << For more related Discussion & Problem Solving Brain usages > See 18 Each > Edit > Find > …RRC …
PROPOSITION 4g): Implied In The Above, Is The Idea That Even A “Partial Fit” Can Be A Useful Solution.
… For Further Reading => Robert Pirsig Extensive & Powerful Use Of Metaphor and Analogy... AFTER This Page Comes Up => Scroll Down To The FIRST => Robert Pirsig Use … For Further Confirmation => Click Here For Article “The Importance of Perception”. This Article Well Summarizes What I Have Stated Above By Saying => “ …Our Perceptions, Depends On The Brain's Ability To Pattern Match To Innate And Learned Knowledge. The Inborn Patterns -- Templates -- Are So Fundamental That No Reality Can Exist Without Nature Presetting Them Into Organisms In The First Place.”
… Please Remember => The ABOVE Important Many, Many, Points Above Concerning “The Problem Solving Brain Generates, Constructs, Creates, Mental Arrivals, WHERE => “All Is Slide To Better & Better Partial Fit Problem Solution! ” Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
A) Future Plans (Intentions) Which Includes Attendant Coordination Of The Planed Physical Body Motion To Accomplish This Plan,
B) While Being Open To The Ongoing Sensory Input From The External Environment Or Various Internal Body Self-Activated Processes. These Body Physical Adjustments, In Preparation For Appropriate Action(s), Which Are Accompanied By =>
D) Feelings & Emotions, With Emotional Face Expressions, Which Are Also Brain / Mind Preparation Signals To Our Body For Action & Movement.
E) Along With The Above => A Final Brain Mind Decision => “Go – No-Go”, Along With On Going Accompanying Emotions.
F) Along With The Above => The Just Emerged Future Plan, Starts Guiding Optimal (Best or Near Best) Action.
… To read about “it actually happened to me” examples of “Future Plans (Intentions) Plus Actions To Accomplish Plan => Click Here, And AFTER this page comes up > Do ( ~6 each) > Top > Edit > Find > intention
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
a) “This is very good work!”, and mention a) As many positive examples as could (look hard) be found, but b) carefully avoid mention any negatives. OR
b) “This is very un-satisfactory work!”, and a) Mention as many negative examples as can be found, but c) Carefully avoids mention of any positive examples! More on Emotion & Feedback To Student=> Discover & Resolve Tutoring. (DART), Click Here.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
PROPOSITION 5c): ADDING TO 5a) & 5b): =>These Problem Solving Brain Solutions (Answers) Plus Concurrent Created Future Plans, ARE IN ESSENCE INTENTIONS! And ONCE THIS ABOVE “PROPOSITION 5b): ADDING TO 5a): “ STATEMENT, IS THUS UNDERSTOOD AS FOLLOWS =>
a) Strongly supports John R Searle’s statements re consciousness, quoted elsewhere in This Document You Are Currently Reading, AND
b) This is in agreement with, Prof Searle discussed “co-created” & “attendant future plans”, in 1983, labeling these respectively as “intention-in-action” and “ prior intention.” (Quotations from John R Searle, as given by Wikipedia.)
c) This will lead us to finally realize that ANY “On The ‘Inside Of Brain” answer to “The Hard Problem Of Consciousness:” OR “The Problem Of Phenomenal Experience”, Is basically UN-Knowable. And we should => UN-Ask The Question.
From This, Readers Of This Document, Now Currently Reading => Should See TWO Contrasts Concerning => “The Long Standing Philosophical Problem of Intention: “ A) Explanation of Intention as being integral part of how our brain functions, every moment by moment of our day. From our Darwinian Heritage => All Problem Solutions (That Mentally Arrive into Consciousness0, Automatically and Always Include Future Plans, Each and Every Such Mentally Arrived Future Plan IS The Explanation of Human Intention.
B) Problematic Explanations of Intention, using word & logic based, philosophic discussions, as exemplified in, (for example) Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, fully discussed Next Below =>
Indeed, We Don’t Have To Look Far, To See That => Among Various Philosophers, There Seems NOT To Be Any Convergence Toward Any Common Agreement, About Where INTENTIONS Come From, As Is Shown Next => . Here Are Some Problematic Examples Re “Intention”, From A Top Ranking Academic Philosophy WebSite, link below => 1)” Philosophical perplexity about intention begins with its appearance in three disguises: [such as] intention for the future, as when I intend to complete this task … “ ...
2) “Acknowledging these problems, some philosophers turn back to Davidson and the project of reducing intention to desire and means-end belief … ““
3) “Some are convinced that the problem is hopeless. … “
4) “ .. the theory of intending as being embarked on intentional action remains incomplete.”
5) “The force of this objection is unclear. … “
6) “While there is something wrong with an account of what it is to ‘that appeals to being or doing’, it is not so obviously problematic to appeal to mental states that represent something as being or doing.”;.
7) “Along with such matters of detail, two problems of principle can be raised against the present approach.” [to intention.]”
8) “A deeper problem for the teleological approach is how to complete this construction with an account of prospective intention in terms of intention-with-which.”
Now: In Order To See For Yourself, Other Examples Like 1) Thru 8), Above,> Please Go To > BLUE LINK Above > Do > Top Of Browser > Edit > Find > Problem FURTHER Support For The Above Quotes 1) Thru 8), Are In Professor Jeff Speaks’ Article => “A Guide To Anscombe’s Intention” September 8, 2004 =>
“A fourth possibility which (for understandable historical reasons) Anscombe does not consider is that acts of intending are events of agents coming to be in certain brain states which, by virtue of their relations to external events and other brain states, qualify as intentions with a certain content.
…This is a view taken by many contemporary philosophers. There is a substantial body of literature devoted to the question of how, on this conception of mental states, we could have immediate knowledge of what we intend. See especially Sydney Shoemaker, ‘Self-Knowledge and “Inner Sense”: Lecture III: The Phenomenal Character of Experience’, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 54:2 (1994). “
Thus Ends The Discussion Of => The Current Status of => “The Long Standing Philosophical Problem of Intention: “ Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
A) Stanford Encyclopedia Of Philosophy Quotes AND
B) Professor Jeff Speaks’ Article,
… This Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”
All Problem Solving Brain Solutions (That Mentally Arrive into Consciousness), Automatically Include Future Plans, Which in all respects ARE in fact Intentions For Action, Along With Needed Body Physical Adjustments, To Actually Accomplish These Future Plans:
… Accordingly, These Future Plans, are a full Preparation For =>The Next (Future) Appropriate Body & Mental Action(s) To Be Accomplished => And in nearly all respects fit the meaning of word Intention.
PROPOSITION 5d): During Perception, In Response To Our Sensory Inputs (9 Senses), From Our Ever-Present Surroundings =>
NOTE: Our Brain’s General Problem Solving Response To Sensory Input From Our External Environment, Has Various Official Names, Assigned By Various Workers, Such As =>
1) Perception Is A Human Ability, In which UN-Conscious Brain Processes automatically, responding to the 9 Senses, Generates, Constructs, Creates => What is called a Mental Model of The Exterior World, that then Mentally Arrive into Conscious Mind, which in This Document, is called Primary Consciousness
2) Related to Perception is what Owen Barfield calls ”Figuration” .
3). A Sub Category Of Perception Is Called (by various workers), Pattern Recognition..
4) HOWEVER: FOR VERY IMPORTANT REASONS => In This Document You Are Currently Reading, Pattern Recognition Is Called A More General (More Inclusive) Term => “Partial Fit Problem Solution, In Response To The Problems Coming At Us. “ .
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
In This Document You Are Currently Reading, you will see much discussion of “Perception”, and its two sub-categories => 1) Called by other worker => “Pattern Recognition” and
2) For important reasons “Perception”, and “Pattern Recognition” are herein called by HSG => “Partial Fit Problem Solution”.
Both “Perception”, and “Pattern Recognition”, Are Of Course, Official Names Of Topics Discussed in a huge literature of psychology, brain research, neuroscience, cognitive science, and philosophy. And accordingly => This Document You Are Currently Reading, ALSO uses these concepts, with their standard meaning:
PROPOSITION 5f): As Implied Above => Our Brain’s Pattern Recognition, And Indeed All Of Perception, Is An Automatic Process:
“Out of Sight, Out of Mind”! .
AND it’s reverse is thus also true => “Out of Mind, is Out of Sight” :
… This means, of course => That which is not readily available to your mind, is more difficult to see (observe, perceive), OR it is NOT seen at all! This is of course why “We Must Learn To See”, Out next topic below => Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
a) The Cycle Steps Are => Original Memory > Memory ReAccesed > Provides Memory Base For Perception & Other What Do Next > Problem Solving Brain Mental Arrival to Consciousness With Future-Plans, Emotions & Feelings, Etc > Action > Success > Refine & Improve Solution Back Into Memory > Enhance & ReFurbish Memory. =>
b) Above Shortened To => A Regenerative Memory Cycle Of ReAccess & ReFurbish =>
c) Above Abbreviate To => ReAccess & ReFurbish Cycle.
d) Above Abbreviate To => Useful Acronym => RRC << For more related Discussion & Problem Solving Brain usages > See 18 Each > Edit > Find > …RRC …
…This cycle is also discussed in the Single and Double-Loop Learning, discussed and diagramed, half way down this Wikipedia Page. CONCLUSION FROM THE ABOVE =>
As Scientist-Philosopher Michael Polanyi Well Recognized => The Confusions That Can Come From The Above-Mentioned “Chicken & Egg Impasses”.
“.. being aware of a bit of particular bits [then our mind automatically, spontaneously, moves] to grasping how they hang together, what is their joint meaning, the real whole of which they are parts or to which they are dues. Sometimes when we have got used to this operation, it is so easy that it is not noticed; Sometimes when we are applying it to something new, it is very difficult and [when we have the [suddenly] illuminating “come-together” to full understanding this typically, constitutes discovery. It is done by shifting [automatically, spontaneously], our attention from the particular to the whole, the joint meaning, and when we do this it changes the way we are aware of the particulars -(as we see in the picture puzzle when the lines that we first thought were branches look quite different once we have seen them as features of a face).
… The theories of Gestalt psychology, as Polanyi used them, showed not just that there is tacit knowledge, such as your recognition of your child's face -- and explicit knowledge, such the school record of his height and weight -- but that there is throughout the whole range of knowledge, tacit and explicit, this same structure -- scattered meaningless particulars; being converted into parts of a meaningful whole, by a change of focus. [This was automatically, spontaneously, accomplished in a Mental Arrival, wherein => ] You stop attending to them [the parts] and start attending from them to a whole or a joint it renaming, which at first you only vaguely sense. But when the whole, the joint meaning, takes over, [and suddenly, automatically, spontaneously,] the particular bits have sunk into a subsidiary space in your attention and don’t appear the same.”
… These Professor Polanyi conclusions not only tell us how individual people achieve understanding of wholes formed from the parts. And, as he shows => This is also the basis of ANY new perception, and integral to any persons gradual steps of learning, especially students. He nicely gives us a powerful view into, the inside steps, of the process.
1) The Whole Field of Gestalt Psychology AND
2) The Genetic Psychology of Jean Piaget:
And Attention =>There Is No Doubt Gestalt Psychology Research And The Research Of Jean Piaget), Considerably Illuminated Following Authors => A) As mentioned above => Michael Polanyi’s conclusions, some of which appear above discussion by Drusilla Scott.
B) Similarly for Prof Thomas Kuhn, in his book “Structure Of Scientific Revolutions”.
C) Myself, Henry Gurr, who was helped in his teaching by Gestalt Psychology & Piaget Genetic Psychology. And this teaching experience then morphed into discoveries in :”How Our Mind Works”, that you are currently reading about on This Document!.
D) Similarly For Prof Richard Langton Gregory’s book “The Intelligent Eye” which has many useful insights, and especially has abundant line drawings & diagrams that had their origin in Gestalt Psychology Research. See continued =>
SIDE NOTE: From This R. L. Gregory’s Book “The Intelligent Eye” => Strongly Support The Theory Presented On This Webpage =>
a) Page 36 “We are lead at once to a fundamental way of thinking about perception. Perception is a matter of selecting the most likely object [an ‘object-hypothesis’]. But what are the plausible objects selected from? Not from the actual world of objects. Retinal images evidently serve to select from a stored repertoire of objects represented symbolically in the “visual” brain. Perception, it seems, must be a matter of seeing the present with [brain’s memory of] stored objects from the past”.
b) Page 61 “We have argued that to see correctly, is [for our Problem Solving Brain beforehand] to select an ‘object-hypothesis’, which not only fits the current facts [in a person’s combined sensory fields] but also is predictive. To describe perception as selection of ‘object-hypothesis’ is no vague analogy, to the use of the word ‘hypothesis’ in science. A scientific hypotheses must be capable of predicting future events if it is to have any power. The same should be true for perceptual ‘object-hypothesis’; Prediction makes possible to plan action before events.”
END SIDE NOTE: The Above Is Michael Polanyi Conclusions About How Our Brain “Zeros-In-On” The Correct (Whole) Perception =>
1) Imprinting: Newly hatched ducklings don’t know their own mother. By instinct they merely have the program to follow anything that moves. With good luck, this movement is Mother Duck, and ever so gradually, the ducklings learn to see and recognize their mother as distinguished from other parts of their surroundings, stationary or moving. After a suitable time (several days), this stage of imprinting tapers off, and other learning, accommodation, and adaption can take over.
2) Perception Of Vertical Stripes: Within a certain several minute time period of a young kitten’s life, they must be exposed to vertical objects. If not, then they can’t see vertical objects the rest of their life!
3) Speaking with the accent of your native tongue (language): If a person older than say, age 10, moves to where a different language is spoken, they will retain pronunciation of their mother tongue, and not much if ever adopt that of their new language . This will persist for the rest of their life, showing how well they have originally been so precisely adapted to their mother tongue.
4) Most Newborn Mammals Have A Built Ability (Again Instinct), To Move To And Latch Onto Their Mother’s Nipple, Which Prompts Subsequent Sucking. This sucking of a newborn is a reflex that is applied to anything that touches the babies face. Similar to duckling imprinting, the sucking instinctual responses, start the general foundation exploration steps, that lay down pathways, which gradually expand memory of what’s there, and thus is a learning-memory-perception cycle, expanding into a learning of skilled performance and thus formation of skilled habit. Thus are laid down the memories, essential for all perception, and ready available skills: This is of course, a creative developmental upward spiral, where the learned abilities become the scaffold, from which make possible the needed perceptions and make possible the learning of skills, which when accessed in turn, make it possible to achieve the NEXT layer of learned abilities.
… AND TO REPEAT => Be Sure to Note Well => This Is Of Course =>An Optimizing Creative Memory Cycle =>, Which Achieves New Learning, Refinement Of Skills, Better Habits, Improved, Solidified, Updated Knowledge, And Many More Examples.
a) The Cycle Steps Are => Original Memory > Memory ReAccesed > Provides Memory Base For Perception & Other What Do Next > Problem Solving Brain Mental Arrival to Consciousness With Future-Plans. Emotions & Feelings, Etc > Action > Success > Refine & Improve Solution Back Into Memory > Enhance & ReFurbish Memory. =>
b) Above Shortened To => A Regenerative Memory Cycle Of ReAccess & ReFurbish =>
c) Above Abbreviate To => ReAccess & ReFurbish Cycle.
d) Above Abbreviate To => Useful Acronym => RRC << For more related Discussion & Problem Solving Brain usages > See 18 Each > Edit > Find > …RRC …
…This cycle is also discussed in the Single and Double-Loop Learning, discussed and diagramed, half way down this Wikipedia Page. 5) Cont From Above: Instincts Are Evidently Another Form Of Memory, That Are Survival Selected (A Form Of Learning), Over Eons Of Time. The information content is in the genetic material that is transferred from generation to generation, by parents to child, at time of conception. By the evidence we may deduce that => Instinct successfully provides to the Problem Solving Brain The “what’s needed”, when other means of needed learning (or compensation, or accommodation, or adaption), may not (or did not) suffice. Instinct provides what’s needed (in a form of genetic memory), essentially immediately, when there is not sufficient available time, nor available needed encounter, with real world experiences, to provide the learning-memory-perception cycle, to happen, as discussed above. It also provides a starting point, a sort of “substrate” to begin building on.
…And although instinct comes from genetic memory, this is again the learning-memory-perception cycle, a regenerative upward spiral of ever improved memory, in this case the Genetic Memory that carries forward instinct, as we see it.) 6) Early Preparation Is Required => This Above Drusilla Scott mentioned, Learning To “See”, Involves All Modes (9 Senses) Of Perception, To Complete The Required Extensive On-Location Learning, To Build Up The Required Memory Base, Which In Turn Is Required For Some Future Partial Fit Problem Solution.
…To Repeat: It’s the learning-memory-perception cycle, in an ever building, ever improving, refurbishment of Brain’s Memory, with each memory re-visit, (=retrieval = re-activation = refurbished & improved memory), because the new optimized solutions, can creatively build upon and extend, upon the average of previous good solutions. These creatively improved memories in people, are the base for, and lead to => learning, training, skill building, insight, formation of habits, and formation of expert performance.
a) The Cycle Steps Are => Original Memory > Memory ReAccesed > Provides Memory Base For Perception & Other What Do Next > Problem Solving Brain Mental Arrival to Consciousness With Future-Plans & Emotions Etc > Action > Success > Refine & Improve Solution Back Into Memory > Enhance & ReFurbish Memory. =>
b) Above Shortened To => A Regenerative Memory Cycle Of ReAccess & ReFurbish =>
c) Above Abbreviate To => ReAccess & ReFurbish Cycle.
d) Above Abbreviate To => Useful Acronym => RRC << For more related Discussion & Problem Solving Brain usages > See 18 Each > Edit > Find > …RRC …
…This cycle is also discussed in the Single and Double-Loop Learning, discussed and diagramed, half way down this Wikipedia Page. 7) Early Preparation Is Required => Example Of Learning To See From Oliver Sacks’ Book:
…Mr Sacks describes some 5 examples of adults who are blind because of opaque eye cataracts, but have otherwise good vision facilities. These people were expected to have good vision upon surgical replacement of their opaque cataracts with clear lenses. However, at first they could only see a blur, and it took a very long time to learn how to see usefully, and even then they never had fully comfortable vision, that they enjoyed using! Like the holdover of early youth speaking accent, these people never fully adapted. 8) Early Preparation Is Required => “Learning To See” Is Essentially Happening When A Student Completes Preliminary Reading of Assignment Early, and Comes Back Later For Continued Study.
As I’ve tried to Emphasize to My Students => Study your school assignment several days early. There will be those parts you can understand, but other parts will be very confusing: For those confusing parts, it’s ok to just quick-read (scan) through, without worrying that you have low comprehension. A day later, when you return to reading the same assignment, you will practically always find that the previously confused parts, are now quite clear. And you will wonder what your earlier difficulty was!
…PLEASE NOTE WELL => A person’s existing Mental Blockage, Perceptual-Blindness, Confusion, Or Doubt, often is Automatically & Spontaneously => Cleared up by the Problem Solving Brain, by simply 1) Early preparation, 2) Struggle, and 3) Then Quit & Wait!
9) The Manifest Virtues of Early Preparation Are ALSO Seen At => Speaker’s Podium, On Theater Stage, Music Concert performers, Athletic Field, or Typing Keyboard=>
… “Practice, Practice, Practice!!” … “Practice Makes Perfect!!!”
8) My WebPage => “BRAIN OWNER’S USERS MANUAL Part 2” Variously Discusses Some Eight Examples Of How Our Problem Solving Brain Effectively Uses Preparation.!
AFTER this WebPage comes up scroll down to, and START READING AT => “Known To The Ancient Greeks and Romans …”, and CONTINUE READING down to => “The Phenomenon of “FLOW”. As you do this note especially => 1) thru 6) AND a) thru d).
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
A) What Is “Out There”: (Located External Of The Person’s Body And/Or Even In To The Person’s Body).
B) And “What Is To Be Done Next”.
… To see just how Memory is actually used, you may want to review the above => PROPOSITION 3c): Which Is “My Rather Long Hypothesis”, For Brain Solution Mental Arrivals Of => “All Is Slide To Better & Better Partial Fit Problem Solution! “
PLEASE BE SURE TO REMEMBER THESE MAIN PRINCIPLES => A) Our Problem Solving Brain’s Massive Computational Power + Massive Memory => Generates, Constructs, Creates, Achieves => Single Best Or Near Best Optimal Solutions, To Guide Behaviour. .
B) These Solutions, If Successful, Are In Turn Automatically Added Back Into & Refurbishes Memory, Thus Laying Down Creatively Ever Improved Brain’s Memories.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib. and Emphasis.
A) Created Perception, of “what is there” , appearing in Consciousness, as a Mental Arrival of a Mental Model into Primary Consciousness PLUS.
B) Created Optimal (Best or Near Best) Solutions to Life’s Oncoming Problem (with concomitant Future plans + feelings + emotions).
… This is most especially powerful, because each successful access of a previous creative innovative optimal Mental Model, necessarily optimal, re-constructs it again, to a new better & better optimum fit to current sensory input. This can result in a selectively refocused, more solidified Mental Models, stashed back into Newly Improved Memory.
This Is Again => The Upward Spiral Corollary: The More You Learn, The Better You Are Able To Learn: In Essence “The Prepared Mind, Stands On The Shoulders Of Giants”, And Can See Farther And Better!
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
SIDE NOTE1: Here Please Notice => The Word ”Remember”, Has In It “RE-Member”: So When We “Remember”, The Following Is Literally (And Figuratively), What Our Problem Solving Brain Is Doing!!That 1) “RE” means literally, to put “The Pieces’ back together again, the MEMBERS (ie the Parts). And Google finds this history =>
2) AND Please Notice => When We “Remember”, Our Problem Solving Brain Is Re-Creating History of Words => Literally (And Figuratively), Remembering Is " Bringing To Mind," What Is “Memorable” That Which Is Worth It!!
3) “memorable (adj.) mid-15c., from Middle French mémorable, from Latin memorabilis "that may be told; worthy of being remembered, remarkable," from memorare "to bring to mind," from memor "mindful of" (from PIE root *mer- "to remember"). Related: Memorably. (see memory).”
…Please notice how this fits the constructivist discussion above, where the brain brings back and RE-assembles the Members (Parts), that which were previously memorable, and thus stashed back into memory!
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
For “Brain State” Wikipedia Offers Other More Esoteric Names, As In These Statements => a) A mental representation (or cognitive representation), (in philosophy of mind, cognitive psychology, neuroscience, and cognitive science), is a hypothetical internal cognitive symbol that represents external reality, or else a mental process that makes use of such a symbol: "a formal system for making explicit certain entities or types of information, together with a specification of how the system does this".
b) Mental representation is the mental imagery of things that are not actually present to the senses.
c) Mental representations also allow people to experience things right in front of them—though the process of how the brain interprets the representational content is debated.
d) Representationalism (also known as indirect realism) is the view that representations are the main way we access external reality
e) As mentioned above, the word “symbol“, is way to “capture” the idea of a ~”brain state”.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
a) As a tentative hypothesis, any single solution, may be a concurrent composite of “Seven (Plus/Minus Two)”, solutions, willfully accessible to a person’s Consciousness.
b) The human ability to hold in mind at the same time, a capacity of “Seven (Plus/Minus Two)” is a long-standing scientific research result. For example:
1) A person can hold in conscious mind ten digits of a phone number (Editor RPG Comment: : Though usually, the first three digits of the phone number are an area code, and therefore relatively consistent, while the others change. This lets one offload the first 3 digits as one “chunk” and thus store & recall, six more digits..
2) For example => As I type, I can keep in mind this intended 8 word sentence.
c) These are our observed abilities (hold in mind a concurrent composite of “Seven (Plus/Minus Two)”, solutions), being willfully accessible to a person’s Consciousness, and are easily done while other tasks are not forgotten, and all the while the functioning of the above mentioned Primary Consciousnessis still “there”, and will return (came back to my mind), just as soon as I look up from my keyboard!
d) "The Magical Number Seven (Plus/Minus Two) Sets Some Limits on Our Capacity for Processing Information" is one of the most highly cited papers in psychology. It was published in 1956 in Psychological Review by the cognitive psychologist George A. Miller of Harvard University's Department of Psychology. Originally published: March 1956.”
But How Can The Seven Plus/Minus Two Solutions Coexist, And Not Interfere With Each-Other?
A) To fully act & be effective, irrespective of any other active Mental Arrivals. And
B) To make itself impervious, with no cross integrations to or from, any other similarly endowed Mental Arrivals.
But, of course, it is quite difficult to imagine how the neuron substrate of these solutions, might do this. You Can See How A) & B) Above Fit This Explanation Of Superposition =>
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
… AND This Properly Understood, Will Lead Us To Finally Realize That Any “On The ‘Inside Of Brain” Answer To “The Hard Problem Of Consciousness:” OR “The Problem Of Phenomenal Experience”, Is Basically UN-Knowable.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
D) (PROPOSITION 9b) In Fact We Can Even Observe, A FIRST Quick Mental Arrival Solution, Which Secondarily (Doesn’t Stay There, But Perhaps Right Away),
… Moves To A SECOND Mental Arrival, In What Must Have Been A “Slide”, To An Even Better Partial Fit Solution (Or Merely Different Solution).
E) In The Process Of Writing Composition, It Is Instructive To Watch Creativity In Action! => These Sudden New Arrivals, as they Pop Into One’s Mind, and you should especially take the time to notice them. Once you know what to watch for:=> These Sudden Mental Arrivals (into your consciousness), are FUN TO WATCH, as they happen =>
e) For example=> While typing, you may notice a scrambled sentence, but can’t think of a good way to fix it. Or suddenly become stuck for lack of what word to type next. A pause to take a sip of water, briefly relax & look out the window (or even a “Quit & Wait & Come Back Later) => AND SUDDENLY: WHEN YOU LEAST EXPECT IT => … VOLA !! What’s exactly needed => Will come sliding into Mind! …
f) Absolutely Wonderful!, Especially if New & Super Creative!!
g) As mentioned in c) above =An example of “the needed comes sliding into mind” is => my typing 2 lines above, The word VOLA, This was an => “on-automatic” ’out of the blue came to my mind’ . “ dynamically, just as was the word ‘dynamic, typed even earlier (In fact just now, I’ve competed MAJOR revisions to this g) much as described in b) above!)
F) In A Word Processor, The Edit > Find Becomes => A Useful Way To Check An Existing Document For Needed Editing Improvements.
…Only gradually did I come to realize this technique => When I am using a word processor for writing composition of a document, and I happen use the Edit > Find, AND have finished my original purpose of finding a certain word (or phrase) => I continue this “finding” for the entire document!! It is surprising how often errors, ill-formed sentences, or bad grammar can be found this way! And this technique seems to go beyond normal proof reading! I think this is because, the Edit > Find just drops me as a reader “into to the middle of the action”, without knowing the previous sentences. This gives a sufficiently different “angle of view”, that needed fixes and creative improvements, not otherwise noticed => just suddenly pop into Mind! … In retrospect, I realize these improvements would not be “realized” in any other way!
G) My WebPage => “BRAIN OWNER’S USERS MANUAL Part 2” Variously Discusses How Your Can Use Your Problem Solving Brain Most Effectively & Creatively => In Your Writing Composition, Where => Your Problem Solving Brain Is Always Automatically Moving To Better & Better Partial Fit!
… Your Big Document Will Write Itself. AFTER this WebPage comes up, scroll down to, and start reading at => If your computer (or dog) “eats” your 2 hours of typing… , and continue reading down to … “the Phenomenon of FLOW”.
… AND As You Do This => Also Please ESPECIALLY NOTICE discussion at => Ray Bradbury says “The book writes itself”
H) As Can Be Directly Observed => From The Above, A NEW REALIZATION =>
… The Problem Solving Brain, Shows Many Facets Of Our Human Creativity. And =>
This above NEW conclusion about Creativity in Writing Composition, came to my mind in a sudden automatic spontaneous Flash of Insight.
This then lead almost instantly, to a second to automatic spontaneous Flash of Insight => Mental Arrivals in general (which may be easily seen, in The Processes of Writing Composition,) are very similar to the automatic spontaneous Mental Arrival Problem Solutions that are no doubt happening more generally throughout human society over most of recorded human history. Such specifically Illustrates AND supports the below statement of PROPOSITION 10d) which says =>
… The Human Problem Solving, Brain Is The Factual & Practical, Origin For The Creative & Innovative Force Behind ALL SOCIAL--CULTURAL CREATIVITY & INNOVATION => Be It Technological, Scientific, Mathematical, Literary, Theatrical, Musical, Or Sports!
I) Moment(s) of Consciousness UN-Occupied (McU):
… Even when we are NOT trying to do anything, our Conscious Mind will still never stay where it is: Even in our quietest moments, our Brain, on-automatic, generates, constructs, & creates, a continuous flow of conscious thoughts, such as UN-done projects, memories of lost opportunities, even long periods of daydreaming / reverie.
… Even a spontaneous “mental record player” in our head, of a favorite music CD, recently and repetitively listened to. This is proof enough, that “chunks of information”, continue to “circulate” in our mind, for days, even weeks, after the original event(s), that created the memory. (For more on this topic > Do > Top > Edit > Find > … McU …
… Of course, in addition to the above “Our Conscious Mind” always being active, our un-conscious brain processes never cease, as long as we are alive.
FOR FURTHER READING IN TOPIC => HOW WE GET SPONTANEOUS & REPEATED REMINDERS (MENTAL ARRIVAL INTO CONSCIOUSNESS), OF UN-FINISHED BUSINESS:
A) Things We Planned To Do, But Not Done Yet, Are Discussed At Length Here => :
… It is Noteworthy & Quite Amazing That => Our Problem Solving Brain Will Automatically Usually & Repeatedly Bring-Back To Our Minds, Important UN-Finished Business, Loose-Ends, or Other UN-Done Needful Actions That Must Be Done! Click Here To Read More In APPENDIX II: B) And Even More Amazingly, These Reminders Will NOT Continue Once Satisfactory Completion (or Problem Resolution), Is Done! Click Here AND Read More In APPENDIX II:
C) Always Moving To => Better & Better Partial Fit Problem Solution, Is Discussed In In A New WebPage, Currently Here =>
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib. and Emphasis.
PROPOSITION 10a)Continued => We Can Hypothesize That The Very Act Of Accessing Memories, Connects To The Very Exact Synapse Connections That Are To Be Updated, Then The Up-Dated Version Saved, Back To The Same Connections.
PLEASE WELL REMEMBER !
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib. and Emphasis.
… Thus Ever BETTER NEW Creative, Innovative Problem Solutions, Are In Turn Automatically Saved Back Into A Refurbished Brain Memory.
… SUMMARY: The Problem Solving Brain’s Creative NEW Solutions, Being Always Best or Near Best, (For The Combined Stored Creative Solutions, Fit To Life’s On-Coming Problems), Nearly Always Will Creatively Go Well Beyond The Previous Solutions Saved To Brain’s Memory.
1) The Cycle Steps Are => Original Memory > Memory ReAccesed > Provides Memory Base For Perception & Other What Do Next > Problem Solving Brain Mental Arrival to Consciousness With Future-Plans, Emotions & Feelings, Etc > Action > Success > Refine & Improve Solution Back Into Memory > Enhance & ReFurbish Memory. =>
2) Above Shortened To => A Regenerative Memory Cycle Of ReAccess & ReFurbish =>
3) Above Abbreviate To => ReAccess & ReFurbish Cycle
4) Above Abbreviate To => Useful Acronym => RRC << For more related Discussion & Problem Solving Brain usages > See 18 Each > Edit > Find > …RRC …
…This cycle is also discussed in the Single and Double-Loop Learning, discussed and diagramed, half way down this Wikipedia Page.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib. and Emphasis (Came to my mind Dec 27 2021.).
… … … …
1) Run by Humans, which are run by their Brains,
2) AND in total, each human actions, depends of Flash Of Insight type Mental Arrivals, then
3) It automatically, literally follows that the Human Mind is truly & inescapably The Total Well Spring of ALL Creativity & Innovation.
4) And for these reasons, useful & effective guidance for achievement of SOCIAL--CULTURAL CREATIVITY & INNOVATION, is => Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” , which in turn is “A Brain Owner’s Users Manual.”
… … … … A) Confirmation Of => The Above “PROPOSITION 10d): Statement Re => The Problem Solving Brain’s Creative NEW Solutions, Being Always Best or Near Best => IS THE WELL SPRING (BOTH SOURCE & MECHANISM OF) OF ALL SOCIAL--CULTURAL CREATIVITY & INNOVATION, Both Current Day AND Historical: => “… ” Is Partly Confirmed In WebPage => National Advisory Committee on Creative and Cultural Education: All Our Futures: Creativity, Culture and Education Report to the Secretary of State for Education and Employment. Click Here.
B) The Ideas In Above “PROPOSITION 10d):… Are Partly Confirmed In The Many Very Insightful Books of Poet, Linguist, & Philosopher Owen Barfield: These Owen Barfield Ideas Are Pointed Out & Discussed In APPENDIX XVIII: Click Here. … (From Above Continued => Educated Guess =>)
NOTE1: The Term Memory (Or Brain’s Memory), As Used In This Document You Are Currently Reading, Officially Technically Means => “Problem Solving Accessed, Content Addressable, Associative Memory”. . These characteristics of biological memory are VERY important, (and in This Document you are reading now) will be more properly called => Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving Accessed, Content Addressable, Associative Memory.” << PLEASE WELL REMEMBER ! NOTE2: Also The Entire Above PROPOSITIONS 10): 10a), 10b), 10c) & 10d), ARE FULL OF VERY, VERY, IMPORTANT IDEAS: PLEASE STUDY AND BE SURE YOU FULLY UNDERSTAND: … THEN WELL REMEMBER ! PROPOSITION 11a): For Our Problem Solving Brain, There Are Two Similar “Actions”, Which Must Keep Distinct =>
HOWEVER: Since A) & B) Are Different Consciousness Results, These A) & B) Need Clearly Distinguishable Names, AND Readers Should Learn Their Distinguishing Features and Actions, As Follows => A) is this always present when we are “Conscious”: The Problem Solving Brain is creating (An internal, To Our Mind’s Eye) => A simulation of our external world, where we consciously visualize ourselves to be situated in that world. (In other words => This is a mind created ”theater”.) AND into our Primary Consciousness can =>
B) Appear, our Other Sudden Automatic Spontaneous Mental Arrivals, as described throughout This Document You Are Currently Reading.
PROPOSITION 11a) Explanation): Primary Consciousness, As Discussed Above, Is Pretty Much The Same Mental Phenomenon, Which Is Simply Called Consciousness, By Most Authors, Including Philosophy Prof John R Searle, And Various Other Authors & Publications On This Subject. (To learn more Do > Edit > Find 9 each > … Types of Consciousness … .
a) We all experience situations where we will fall asleep or go into daydreaming. => Long boredom, reading while tired or driving a car with fatigue, and other low stimulation situations.
b) Another situation where UN-Stimulated, a person’s Consciousness drifts away into a very pleasant but seeming non-functional “awake-dreaming”. Persons while in these popular “Flotation Tanks”, for an hour or so of “Sensory Deprivation”, report gradually going into a state of consciousness, which is very relaxing, quite enjoyable, and from the testimonies, curative of stress and chronic pain. However good the Sensory Deprived Experience, it is a mindless state of mind, called “FLOAT”, where no productive efforts can be done … Not even compose a paragraph or a sentence, do future planning, think of a new work of art, or piece of music. More here => https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-35521560
… PROPOSITION 11a): SUMMARY:
FOR THE CONVENIENC OF THE READER A DUPLICATE OF Above PROPOSITION 11a): FOLLOWS => BUT WITH ADDITIONAL DISCUSSION =>
… Since A) & B) Are Different Consciousness Results, These A) & B) Need Clearly Distinguishable Names, AND Readers Should Learn Their Distinguishing Features and Actions, As Follows => ADDITIONAL DISCUSSION =>
A) Our Primary Consciousness , AND the
B) The Other Problem Solutions,-that appears as a sudden, automatic, spontaneous, Mental Arrival, into our Awareness & Conscious Mind, which is herein called Primary Consciousness .
… Thus it is that our brain AND our sense organs, stimulated, and prompted by our ever present surrounding environment (and combining optimal partial fit with memory) => Constructs, what John R Searle calls a “unitary field”, somehow making us aware, and A) Gives us our A) Primary Consciousness An Ever Present ~”Theater Stage”, A “Visual Theater”, INTO WHICH APPEAR =>
B) The Other Herein Discussed Problem Solution Sudden, Automatic, Spontaneous, Mental Arrivals That Also Appear Into Our Conscious Mind..
…This above A) is an, always present, internal simulation of our external world … where we consciously visualize ourselves to be situated in that world …. AND, INTO WHICH APPEAR =>
PROPOSITION 11a): SUMMARY; The Above Describes Two Types ( A) & B) ) Of Conscious “Actions”, That Can Be Expressed In Human Words, To Report, And Make Sense Of What We Consciously Experience.
A CHART WHICH COMPARES VARIOUS AUTHORS OWN DISCUSSED TYPES OF CONSCIOUSNESS.
The Below Chart Illustrates This Above-Mentioned Consciousness Comparison.
***** START A SECOND INTERLUDE CONCERNING CONSCIOUSNESS.***** A SECOND LENGTHILY INTERLUDE: TO HELP YOU UNDERSTAND THE ABOVE MENTIONED AUTHORS’ RESPECTIVE CONCLUSIONS RE CONSCIOUSNESS => … Below Is An Excerpt From The Wikipedia (Link Above), Which Fills In Needed Details.
Above Wikipedia Link Also Mentions => 1) “Philosophers have used the term 'consciousness' for four main topics: knowledge in general, intentionality, introspection (and the knowledge it specifically generates) and phenomenal experience.”
2) “ at least eight clearly distinct types of consciousness can be identified (organism consciousness; control consciousness; consciousness of; state/event consciousness; reportability; introspective consciousness; subjective consciousness; self-consciousness)—and that even this list omits several more obscure forms. ”
HSG NOTE1: From common usage, and as in Wikipedia passages above, we see that the single word “consciousness”, should NOT be applied to any ONE type of mental awareness, but rather should be seen as an umbrella term, that covers many different types mental phenomena. Left out of the Wikipedia discussion are => Self-Consciousness = State of total engrossed involvement in one’s self, such that we lose all awareness of other persons. Also a person’s involvement in “self’, may include extreme Joy / Elation / Flow (of Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi ). Or perhaps go the other way, to ~complete un-awareness of self … like Zen’s “No-Mind”.
Consciousness On-Off Switch Discovered Deep In Brain. NewScientist.com, 2 July 2014.
Additional Discussion of Primary Consciousness.
The Neat & Absolutely Astounding & Wonderful Properties Of Primary Conscious Are That =>
a) What is in our surrounding environment,
b) Needed Future Plans & Actions, and
c) Appropriate Feelings & Emotions.
d) A full sense of Meaning, Sense of Truth, Beauty, Recognition, Insight, Knowing, Comprehension, Sense, Clear Understanding, and Importance. And All This With Felt Certainty
NOTE1: Because This Document You Are Currently Reading, can’t keep endlessly repeating this (or other) important ideas => Please remember the above,
SUMMARY OF THE ABOVE:
A) Primary Consciousness is stimulated by and fitted to our external 3D world, and mostly visual, and shifts with 3D World around us.
B) Most Other Solutions are called Mental Arrivals into Our Conscious Mind (Suddenly Automatically Spontaneously), which by contrast to above A), are mostly not visual, not present nearly all the time, and have less content re the external world. These Other Mental Arrivals are for examples such as new => Ideas, facts, thoughts, realizations, answers, conclusions, decisions, body motions, considerations, individual items of awareness, remembrances, reminisces, remember a name, etc. Depending on circumstances, Sudden, Automatic, Spontaneous, Mental Arrivals, might be includes the meaning of practically any word or concept, the understanding of a sentence, conceiving a way to do something, etc.
Some Added Thoughts About => Our Problem Solving Brain’s Entirely Generated, Constructed, Created => “Mental Model” Of Our External “Real World” Surroundings, Nearly Always Available As Primary Consciousness (Also On This Document Called Consciousness or Conscious Mind), Is Mostly Experienced As Vision.
From Wikipedia: Principles Of Mental Models.
******** o0OOO0o ******** Concerning Our Problem Solving Brain’s Entirely Generated, Constructed, Created => “Mental Model” Of Our External “Real World” Surroundings, That Is Mostly Experienced As Vision, And Nearly Always Available As Primary Consciousness. … This is important for ALL of us to understand how => Our normal ongoing perception of the world around us, our brain is (automatically) forming memory traces of everything we see and think.
This Same Conclusion, Is Also Implied In All Of Robert Pirsig’s Book “Zen And The Art Of Motorcycle Maintenance” (ZMM), Where Dynamic Quality Is The Cutting Edge Of Reality’, And Even Makes Our Reality! =>
a) “"Quality is the parent, the source of all subjects and objects." - “
b) “The birth of a new fact is always a wonderful thing to experience. It’s dualistically called a "discovery" because of the presumption that it has an existence independent of anyone’s awareness of it. When it comes along, it always has, at first, a low value. Then, depending on the value-looseness of the observer and the potential quality of the fact, its value increases, either slowly or rapidly, or the value wanes and the fact disappears. ”
c) “ The Quality which creates the world emerges as a relationship between man and his experience. He is a participant in the creation of all things. The measure of all things—it fits..”
d) “Quality is the continuing stimulus which our environment puts upon us to create the world in which we live. All of it. Every last bit of it.”
… This above phrase d) is asserted TWO times in ZMM, and “ All of it. Every last bit of it .” is asserted FOUR times, so Pirsig surely must really, really, mean it !.
A) Is the general foundational undergirding of ZMM.
B) This A) is most apparent when Pirsig uses the word ‘construct’, specifically with this meaning, NINE times in ZMM, quoting Albert Einstein and Henri’ Poincare’, along the way.
C) And I believe Pirsig’s “create the world in which we live .” applies (at most) to the part of the universe that is Problem Solving Brain Generated, Constructed, Created … in our own mind … which is all we can ever know.
D) This Generated, constructed, created, again is Pirsig’s Dynamic Quality, together building ALL of our knowledge the universe … in our mind is … which in turn Pirsig calls Static Quality.
E) In ZMM, Robert Pirsig summarizes how important this Problem Solving Brain Generated, Constructed, Created, is => “ ‘The sun of quality,’ he wrote, ‘does not revolve around the subjects and objects of our existence. It does not just passively illuminate them. It is not subordinate to them in any way. It has created them. They are subordinate to it!” …And at that point, when he wrote that, he knew he had reached some kind of culmination of thought he had been unconsciously striving for over a long period of time. .”
NOTICE THE ABOVE TWO WORDS CREATES & QUALITY => THESE IS ARE CENTRAL TO THE TOPIC OFDYNAMIC QUALITY, IN ROBERT PIRSIG’S TWO BOOKS! . By Henry Gurr copied from The Sarah Vinke Biography titled => “A Woman Of Quality.”
To Help Explain Just What He Means By “Quality’, Robert Pirsig Introduces His Railroad Freight Train Analogy, Which You Can Read In The Following ZMM Passage: … “In my mind now is an image of a huge, long railroad train, one of those 120-boxcar jobs that cross the prairies all the time with lumber and vegetables going east and with automobiles and other manufactured goods going west. I want to call this railroad train "knowledge" and subdivide in into two parts: Classic Knowledge and Romantic Knowledge.
SUMMARY: => QUALITY, IS ROBERT PIRSIG’S NAME FOR =>
***** CONTINUE SECOND INTERLUDE CONCERNING CONSCIOUSNESS.***** For Further Reading Concerning Consciousness: B) Collected Into One Webpage, Are ALL Of The Various Discussions On The Topic Of CONSCIOUSNESS, That Henry Gurr Could Find In His Documents & Emails.
… By reading this below summary overview WebPage => 1) You will prepare your mind for future easier reading about Our Human Experience of Consciousness
2) Also by reading this page, you will become more familiar with => The Properties & Characteristics Of Consciousness as they happen in Any & All Mental Arrivals.
3) Overall, reading the below will help you to better see “The Big Picture”, as you happen to read any of Henry Gurr’s 8 WebPages (Top Main Menu At Left), “How Our Mind Works”.
Be Forewarned: This Blue Link Below is a NEW WebPage, and temporarily there are parts that still need further editing attention.
END SECOND INTERLUDE CONCERNING CONSCIOUSNESS.
***** START A THIRD INTERLUDE CONCERNING CONSTRUCTIVISM ***** A Supplementary WebPage On Which Are Presented Three Side Issues That The Enthusiast In The Study Of Mind May Want To Eventually Understand These => ISSUE1: The Conclusions of A) “Dual Process Theories” Very Well Support => B) | Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works.” ]] ISSUE2: How A) & B) Relate to C) Robert Pirsig’s “ Dynamic Quality” And In Turn Relate To => ISSUE3: The Huge Field Of Study Called “Constructivism (Constructivist Epistemology) ” ******** o0OOO0o ******** Continuing From The Above-Mentioned “Three ISSUE WebPage” =>
******** o0OOO0o ******** On This Document You are Currently Reading, You have Repeatedly Seen Statements. Equivalent To CONSTRUCTIVIST EPISTEMOLOGY, Such As =>
A) “Mental Modes” Of Our External “Real World” Surroundings, That Is Mostly Experienced As Vision, And Nearly Always Available As Primary Consciousness.
B) Solutions To The “Problems of Life Coming At Us”, Which Suddenly, Automatically, Spontaneously, Mentally Arrival Into Primary Conscious Mind.
Further Support For Constructivist Epistemology, Is Seen In The Following Article & Discussion. Such As => = … =] “Our Problem Solving Brain => With Unconscious Brain Processes, Automatically, Spontaneously, Generates, Constructs, Creates => ‘A Mental Model’, That Is Our Primary Consciousness A) This Wikipedia Page Called “Consciousness or Conscious Mind”, Points To =>
B) This Wikipedia Page Called “Imagination”, Points To => The Fact That Human IMAGINATION ABILITY, IS SIMILAR TO MEMORY, AND IS CONSTRUCTIVE!
Bottom Lines For Our Problem Solving Brains “Generates, Constructs, Creates” =>
A) SIMULTANEOUSLY SOLVE THE PRESENT EXISTING PROBLEM, and
B) IN SAME PROCESS, ACT AS A CREATIVE / INNOVATIVE MEMORY RETRIEVAL.
C) AND, IN THE PROCESS (OF EITHER PERSONAL MEMORIES OR IMAGINATION), ALL IS RE-CONSTRUCTIVE, SINCE THE SOURCE OF THE SOLUTIONS, ARE PREVIOUS SUCCESSFUL SOLUTIONS, STORED IN BRAIN MEMORY..
As Robert Pirsig summarizes this by saying => “Quality is the continuing stimulus which our environment puts upon us to create the world in which we live. All of it. Every last bit of it.” D) AND Of Course ALL Of The Above, Is Made Possible & Comes From Our ' ‘‘ “Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory. ” '' .
THUS A BOTTOM LINE SUMMARY FOR OUR PROBLEM SOLVING BRAIN =>
ALL IS GENERATED, CONSTRUCTED, CREATED, INCLUDING PRIMARY CONSCIOUSNESS, WHICH SHOWS INTO CONSCIOUS MIND, A MENTAL MODEL OF “WHAT IS OUT THERE” =>
A) Primary Consciousness, Is The Visual & Mental Theater, Presented To Our Conscious Mind, In Which We Perceive, Apprehend, Discern, Comprehend, Reason, Know, Intuit, Insight, Visualize, Imagine, Understand, Have Meaning, Cognition, and Be Aware Of Our Surroundings!
… This Primary Consciousness, Is An Ever Present Mental Model (~”Theater Stage”), INTO WHICH APPEAR => B) The Other Herein Discussed Problem Solution Mental Arrivals, That Also Suddenly, Automatically, Spontaneously, Come Into Our Primary Consciousness. Mind. (Also On This Document Called Consciousness or Conscious Mind),
… The Above B) Is => An Entirely Brain Generated, Constructed, Created => “Mental Model” of our external “real world” surroundings (“What’s Out Ther”), And Is Mostly Experienced As Vision, And Nearly Always Available.
All This Above Is In Agreement With => The More General Statement Given Near The Start Of This Document, You Are Currently Reading, and Duplicated Here => Thoughts, Ideas, Future Plans, Actions, That Become Consciousness In Our Mind, Are Each => A Single, Coherent, Holistic, Unified View Of The World, Generated, Constructed, Created, As A Solution To The Problem Of How To Best Respond To Our Second By Second Sensory Input From Our Surrounding Environment.
However, As Has Been Said Several Places On This Document =>
FOR THE CONVENIENC OF THE READER A RESTATEMENT OF Above PROPOSITIONS 10). 10a), & 10b FOLLOWS => BUT WITH ADDITIONAL DISCUSSION CONCERNING “MEANING” => Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
1) Guide And Achieve A Near-Optimum (Best or Near Best) Real-World Bodily Actions
(AND Repeating An Above Discussion) 2) AT THE SAME TIME PRESENT US WITH =>
A) A Coherent Primary Consciousness, A Mind’s Eye, Which Has All The Important & Wonderful Characteristics, discussed in Above PROPOSITION 11, Plus Providing a “Mental Stage”, A “Theater”, Into Which =>
B) Secondarily appear, Our Other Normal Problem Solving Brain Sudden, Automatic, Spontaneous, Mental Arrivals, That => Report, Organize, And Make Sense Of What We Consciously Experience.
[[230517:1223 HSG in studying how to properly introduce “THE MAKING OF MEANING” (P which is presently next below (as currently Posted), but hardly is a good “fit” at there :-(( ) S> study all of the following PROPOSITIONs 12 thru 22 and see no gd place for “meaning” except to put at last & make PROPOSITION 23. PROPOSITION 12a): All The While: Relevant Brain’s Memories Are Accessed, Used To Make Creative, Innovative, Improved, NEW Solutions, Which Mentally Arrive Into Consciousness, The Brain’s SELF-SAME MEMORIES ARE CORRESPONDINGLY REFURBISHED & UPDATED.
SUMMARY: AND TO REPEAT => Be Sure to Note Well => This Is Again Of Course =>An Optimizing Creative Memory Cycle =>, Which Achieves New Learning, Refinement Of Skills, Better Habits, Improved, Solidified, Updated Knowledge, And Many More Examples.
1) The Cycle Steps Are => Original Memory > Memory ReAccesed > Provides Memory Base For Perception & Other What Do Next > Problem Solving Brain Mental Arrival to Consciousness With Future-Plans, Emotions & Feelings, Etc > Action > Success > Refine & Improve Solution Back Into Memory > Enhance & ReFurbish Memory. =>
2) Above Shortened To => A Regenerative Memory Cycle Of ReAccess & ReFurbish =>
3) Above Abbreviate To => ReAccess & ReFurbish Cycle.
4) Above Abbreviate To => Useful Acronym => RRC << For more related Discussion & Problem Solving Brain usages > See 18 Each > Edit > Find > …RRC …
…This cycle is also discussed in the Single and Double-Loop Learning, discussed and diagramed, half way down this Wikipedia Page.. Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
PROPOSITION 12d): As Is Observed, When A Person Is Drowsy Or Unconscious Or There Is => IN-Sufficient Attention (Or Distracted, Or Multi-Tasking, Etc), Our Brains Memory Of its Solution Mental Arrivals, Will Be Reduced, Weak, Or Not At All. SUMMARY: YES INDEED => Normal Brain’s Memory, Will Be Typically Formed For Those Problem Solution To Life’s Problems Coming At Us).=> But This is When & Mostly Only, When We Are Paying Attention.
… Although ALL our Perceptions & Behaviour, most likely, contribute to our Learning-Memory-Perception Cycle (A Regenerative Upward Spiral Of Ever Improved Brain Memory), typically, the problem solution that CAN Mentally Arrival into Our Consciousness, are ONLY those, that previously received a fair amount of the person’s Conscious Attention, while their Brain’s Memories were originally being formed.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
A) May Be Used To Illustrate The “Workings Of” The Above PROPOSITIONS 1) Thru 15), And Attendant Assertions.
B) But ALSO The Flash of Insight (and similar Mental Arrivals), Are Seen To Be A Quite Valuable Research Tool (and Probe), Into The Workings of Our Own Mind!
To See Just How This Is True, And Learn A Whole Lot More About The Workings Of The Flash Of Insight => Click Here & AFTER New WebPage Pops-Into-Place => Read (~20 Inches of) Instructions Down To Where You See Blue Link Words => “Memory, Perception, Insight … THEN Click On It To Go To My Article => “Memory Perception Insight And Problem Solving. AHA!!!”
A) The Flash of Insight mental event results in instant and permanent learning, thus providing an example of the inside steps of how we construct skills, habits, ideas, knowledge, in our mind:
B) The Flash Of Insight, Is ONE OF MANY OTHER Similar Phenomena, Herein Called Problem Solving Brain Solutions, As Mental Arrivals Into Our Primary Consciousness Mind. A partial list of Mental Arrivals include => Eureka, AHA, Illumination, The Light Cam On, Light-Bulb (as in cartoons), Epiphany, Bolt from the blue, It dawned on me, Etc More here => Please Go To => An Anatomy of An Idea Come To Mind, For A FULL Discussion Mental Arrivals & Other State(s) of Mind.
C) A Deep Study Of Mental Arrivals, Such As The Flash Of Insight, And Closely Observing These In Action, Shows What Our Problem Solving Brain Can Do, Suddenly, Spontaneously, Self-Organized, UN-Supervised, and On-Automatic. You will see, consistent with requirements of Darwinian Evolution, that our brain rapidly, reliably, and accurately, comes up with amazing solutions to problems! But it is puzzling why we are completely UN-Aware to our Conscious Mind.
… Mental Arrivals, such as The Flash of Insight (and similar), are part of a much larger class of similar observed mental phenomena, which surely arise from the same mental processes, and should be similarly studied. =>
D) Our General Problem Solving Brain’s Answers (Solutions), Become Known Into our Conscious Mind => ONLY-“One-At-A-Time”, At The Time Of The Flash Of Insight or Other Sudden, Automatic, Spontaneous, Mental Arrival, at which time, the Full, Complete, Whole All-At-Once Solution Mentally Arrives => With joy, Satisfaction, Achievement, Even Laughter. And as the book "Inside Jokes" so well points out, this sensation of joy is a huge reward (like a food reward), so we as a biological organism will pursue similar such problem solving efforts in the future.
E) Here Again We Must Note Well => The ONLY Reason We Are Aware AT ALL Of The Flash Of Insight (Or Other Mental Arrivals), Is Because Our Brain Has Previously Just Suddenly Come To A Halt :Stuck At A Place Where It Can NOT Satisfactorily Achieve A Needed Problem Solution.. ,
f) AND, importantly for survival, we are Immediately Consciously Aware & Know That => We are stuck, with no answer, and realize we have no good immediately available way forward to get an answer.
g) And since we know we have no direct way to get a good answer (solution), we know to Study The Problem, Actively Seek Solutions a) By trying every thing we can think of, b) Read books c) Ask Google & d) Ask our friends THEN ~Quit & Wait. for an answer to Suddenly Automatically Spontaneously Mentally Arrive, “Out of the Blue”, such as Flash of Insight.
h) OR alternatively => “Quit & Begin” => To seek other ways to move toward, toward what we originally wanted.
i) But most often the better method is -> Just Quit & Wait! For Complete Explanation Click Here To Go To => APPENDIX XI: QUIT & WAIT !!
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
2) When you have finished 1) above, scroll down and read the passages concerning Henri Poincare’
3) In Robert Pirsig’s Book Zen and the Art Of Motorcycle Maintenance , Closely study the several pages about Henri Poincare’s “Crystallizations”.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib
A) Can Be Used As A Research Tool and In Written Documents Use To Illustrate The “Workings Of Your Mind”
B) And This PROPOSITION 16c:) Here ADDS This Idea => Mental Arrivals Such As The Flash Of Insight, And Other Similar => Can Be Used To Tell HOW WELL Your Perception System Is Working, As In The Following Examples =>
a) You are at a building construction site, and your eyes automatically “spot”, and lock-onto, a rusty nail sticking up out of an odd piece of lumber. If such happens quickly & easily, then you know your mind is alert and running well !
b) You happen to be near berry bushes (or looking into fruit bearing trees), and although you have no thought of fruit existence, your eyes “lay-on-to”, some fruit color, Suddenly Automatically Spontaneously, with no effort.. If such happens quickly & easily, then you know your mind is alert and running well !
c) You are outdoors, enjoying summer day, with nary a care in the world: Suddenly your eyes automatically swing to and “fixate” on a biting insect, or “lock-onto” a blood sucking tick: When these so called “Deer Ticks”, get on your body, they will eventually dig-in, and such your blood. From such tick “bites”, you can get dangerous disease, Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever. If you discover ticks quickly & easily, then you know your mind is alert and running well !
d) You are on a carefree walk on a forest trail, with no thought of danger: Until suddenly you stop, and just as suddenly your wondering why? A half second later, you realize you are looking a patch or Poison Ivy, or as happened to me, I was about to put my foot down on a 5 foot black snake. If such happens quickly & easily, then you know your mind is alert and running well !
Ditto for the following =>
… This are clear demonstrations of “before and after” my being “primed”. Up till age 40, I was perceptually blind. And because of this => Such wonderful Steller Views, were NOT a part of my life.
… Such attention “jump-to’s” may be wrong or disappointing, yes, but still useful for seeing how much (or if), your mind & memory are “primed for action”, literally and figuratively!
… Of course the reverse, would be far more likely, but not as funny to children. (To see other poem examples => AFTER the Lewis Carroll Page comes up > Do > Edit > Find > … He thought he saw … ) PROPOSITION 16d) Building From The Above, We Can ALSO ADD This Idea =>You Can Find (IN RETROSPECT), HOW WELL Your Mind Is WAS ALREADY Functioning, Fit And Ready, With Needed Alertness. Such As =>
a) At practically any moment your mind typically is telling you => How well was your mind ALREADY primed and “on the look-out” and ready for efficient action! .
b) Also you can tell if this “priming”, is ALREADY solidly implanted in your mind, OR
c) Deduce whether any of these happened because of recent exposure, conscious training, conscious practice, or another person “pointing out” one if these examples. Even recent listening of your favorite music, may spontaneously come into your “mental record player”!
d) And even more so, it any of the above examples, are first “caught your attention” from “the side of your eye” (peripheral vision), AND even more so, notice that these spontaneously happen even without these recently being in your experience! If such happens quickly & easily, then you know your mind is alert and running well !
… In This Document You Are Currently Reading => A) For more on how our Primary Consciousness: Is “our mind” which is fit” and “ready for action” > Do > Top > Do > Edit > Find > … gumption … )
B) (For more on Quality of “Total Mental Solution Fitness”~=> 19 each > Top > Do > Edit > Find > … fitness … )
… A SOMEWHAT COMPLEX NAVIGATION NOTE => You will notice that => WHEN the above-mentioned “Anatomy” Page” , cams up in your Browser Page => You will see there appeared => a NEW ADDED TAB, which, as you may notice, along the top.. … Now, AFTER you finish reading => At top you will need to => Click on the TAB that is to the LEFT, and then click the Browser’s Back Arrow at Upper Left => To return HERE, where you are currently reading,.) Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
1) EVERY thought, every perception, every plan, every person’s body motion, is found by the same (or similar) brain “machinery & methods”, as for the Flash of Insight, and other similar mental actions.
2) For our normal conscious thoughts and perception about to happen, just like the Flash or Insight => We have no awareness of the operation of this mental machinery, which cause our thoughts and perceptions, hence name “UN-Conscious Brain Processes”. Indeed, for nearly all the time => We just don’t have any feeling, or knowing, that we even have “Mental Processes!
3) Our first hint of awareness is a HALT, in our thinking or active work, stuck, WAITING for a Sudden, Automatic, Spontaneous, Mental Arrival:
a) Here We Must (As In Above PROPOSITION 16a) Item e), Note Well => The ONLY Reason We Are Aware AT ALL, That We Even Have “UN-Conscious Brain Processes”, Is Because Of =>
… Our Problem Solving Brain Has Just Suddenly Automatically Spontaneously Come To A HALT', STUCK At A Place Where It Can’t Satisfactorily Achieve A (Consciously Aware), Needed Problem Solution.
4) Thus (after the HALT STUCK), the sudden Flash of Insight (or other Mental Arrival into our Conscious Mind), is ONLY way we know => There 'must be UN-Conscious Problem Solving Brain Processes, running in our brain, with minimal clue of their presence, except when there is a Sudden, Automatic, Spontaneous, Mental Arrival.
5) In other words => Our brains are constantly, producing our mental awareness of ongoing perceptions into “Primary Conscious”, but we have absolutely NO awareness that our brains are doing this!
6) And We Don’t Know This, Most Of The Time, Simply Because Our Brain Is Continuously (and Unconsciously) Successfully Handling “Life’s Problems Coming At Us”, And NOT HIT A STICKING POINT, And Come To A Halt !
7) And It Is ONLY Because We Have Become Stuck At A Halt, That We Know That We MUST HAVE HAD Previous Unconscious Brain Processes, That Produced The Halt, And AT That Time, As Is Observed, We Know What Were The Reason For The Halt.
8) From the above, it is apparent that Nature, doesn’t want us to know about, or even be aware of, our brain workings. This is discussed next below.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
This general lack of our awareness of the high-powered activity of our General Problem Solving Brain, happens (hypothesis), for VERY important reasons. Click here to read APPENDIX VII: “The Reason Why Our Conscious Mind Is NOT, The Least Bit, Aware Of Our UN-conscious Mental Processes!“
This Fact That We Do Not Know What Our UN- Conscious Mind Is Doing (Or Mostly Don’t Have Even The Slightest Hint About It), Is Of Course What Makes Such Mental Arrivals As The Flash Of Insight, So Mysterious, And So Unbelievable .
Of Course, If There Is No Halt At A Sticking Point, Then The On-Going Solutions Simply Come Into Our Conscious Mind As Ongoing UN-Apparent Mental Arrivals, Otherwise Known As Our Natural Conscious Perceptions, Herein More Generally Called Primary Consciousness.
Closure For PROPOSITION 16a): Continuing With Item e) => e) Here we must note well that => Concerning Practically ANY Automatic Spontaneous Sudden Mental Arrival => The ONLY Reason We Are Aware AT ALL => Is Because Our Brain Has Just Suddenly Come To A Halt & Stuck , at a place where it can’t satisfactorily achieve a (consciously aware), needed Problem Solution.
f) AND, importantly for survival, we are Immediately Consciously Aware & Know That => We are stuck, with no answer, and realize we have no good way forward to get an answer.
g) AND we know we have no direct way to get the needed good answer (solution), except to ~Quit & Wait. … OR alternatively => We pretty soon, figure out to “Quit & Begin” seeking a alternate way to move toward, what we originally wanted.
n) Or just Quit & Wait for an answer to Mentally Arrive, “Out of the Blue”, such as Flash of Insight. For Complete Explanation Click Here To Go To => APPENDIX XI: QUIT & WAIT !!
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
NOTE1: The Above PROPOSITIONS 1): Thru 18), Concerning Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” Once Fully Understood, Are Ultimately Seen To Be Basically Simple, Even Obvious, Once A Person Understands This Theory & Knows What to Look For. But despite this, it is only relatively recently, that I have been able to find literature, some portions of which, somewhat parallel my Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” … These include the works of Daniel Dennett, Matthew Hurley, Reginald Adams, Douglas Hofstadter, Victor A F Lamme, Artem Tsvetkov, Robert Pirsig, Donald D. Hoffman, Stephen Grossberg John Searle, George Lakoff, and others.
Readers Should Be Aware That There Are TWO Other Continuation Pages Of “Supplementary Information” Here =>
SUMMARY OF PROPOSITIONS 17): & 18): =>
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
a) We who, second-by-second, are the users of this marvelous surrounding world awareness provided by Consciousness, can readily list what these advantages might be => i) Consciousness, helps us better “see”, what our perception puts before our “mind’s eye”, ii) Consciousness awareness automatically swing our attention an imminent danger, and iii) If danger is “seen”, quickly form of a plan of action, in which escape routs are “seen”, must surely enhance biological fitness and therefore survival.
b) We may reasonably assume that => Nature has given us our observed Consciousness, so that humans (and probably most animals and birds), will have increased mental efficiency and resultant body performance (as mentioned a( above), and thus improved general abilities, but most specifically for increased survival. All this is well understood by Professor John R Searle, and illustrated in his passages, duplicated in This Document You Are Currently Reading.
c) In Darwinian Evolutionary Biology, there is a general rule => When Nature finds a “need”, Nature finds a way. And especially => For “How Consciousness ‘Works’ Inside The Brain”, we should be content with what Nature has provided, and NOT Inquire further into the details of the brain’s mechanism for producing Consciousness.
… And Although We All Know What Is Meant By This “Nature “ (Or “Mother Nature“ ) Manner Of Speaking, We Should Better Say The Following Concerning The Status Of Current Biological (Natural) Theory =>
SIDE NOTE: The Above “When Nature Finds A “Need”, Nature Finds A Way“ => Is Of Course A Quite Anthropomorphic Way To Speak Of Nature, As If. She Were An Active Agent, With A Mind & Wil & Purpose, Similar To That Of A Human.
(RPG Comment: The idea that Consciousness is all to the good, isn’t necessarily always true – the added resource consumption and requirements might not always pay off. See the following: https://www.britannica.com/animal/sea-squirt an animal which degenerates its brain when it becomes an adult. The male anglerfish also brain degenerates when it’s found a mate, and turns into a parasitic appendage on a female anglerfish).
Thesis Panorama Hsg Contrib.
A) Be A Way, To Be Sure=> ~GUARANTEE That Any Future Plan Actually Proceeds Toward Full Completion:
B) And, there MUST Be A Way “check-off” when a Future Plan, Has Been Fully Completed, As Intended.
C) Hence (Hypothesis), again expressed in Human Terms =>There MUST Be A “Mental Intention List” of => ~”Items-Yet-To-Be-Done List”!
This means (Hypothesis2), AND when any Item IS actually done => There must be a “way” to “REMOVE” such now completed Intentions, from the equivalent of => ~”Items-Yet-To-Be-Done List”, = A “Mental Intention List”. Thesis Panorama Hsg Contrib
1) You should notice in your own life => Your Problem Solving Brain Will (Usually & Repeatedly) Bring To your Mind Important UN-Finished Projects, Jobs Need Done, Jobs Poorly Done, UN-Finished Plans & Intentions, Etc!
2) To understand this fully, you should notice => The relative occurrence of these, in your own life. All this has close relevance to Pirsig’s “Peace of Mind” and how to achieve it..
3) And SUPER AMAZINGLY, The Reminders {+Will NOT Continue} Once Satisfactory Completion (or Problem Resolution), Is Fully Completed !!!
4) The actual observations (came to my mind) that support 1) & 2), I (HSG) have been keenly aware of for over ~10 years, but only yesterday (March 5, 2019) (Came To My Mind) =>, did I get to thinking just how could a brain actually do this? I realized that this is the opposite of ordinary habit formation, which is one of our most usual way to establish & build new behavior, rather than remove it!
5) As yet I have no answer, but if trying to write out what could be said about this conundrum, did the full force of this below PROPOSITION 19), came to my mind… ((Also see PROPOSITION 9) )) … Suddenly with full force! AHA! As Continued Next =>
AFTER The Above PROPOSITIONS 20a) & 20b) Came To My Mind!… AHA!! A New Mental Arrival, Came To My Mind!, As Is This Next =>
a) Future Plans (Intentions), along with their completion, are being Generated, Constructed, & Created, moment by moment (second by second), as we (or an animal), go about our daily lives.
b) Correspondingly the (equivalent of the above hypothesized) “Mental Intention List”, on a nearly continuous basis, is constantly being added to (and on a continuing basis mostly removed by completion).
c) Even in the event of a sudden danger, that immediately requires action, the other items in the Mental Intention List, should mostly be retained, so we (or an animal), can resume life after the danger, has been dealt with, For example, from the Mental Intention List “Food in that berry bush, I saw an hour ago.”
… Of Course The Above Discussion Of “Mental Intention List”, Are Ideas Expressed In Human Understandable Words, However, we must always realize and remember => What is really happening is widely distributed tiny synapsis adjustments in our => ' Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory.” Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib
A) We Are “Stuck” With No Solutions / Answers For Our On-Going Life, and
B) We Know Why We Are “Stuck”, In Terms of What Is Lacking Or Not Available!
******
And Here Note Well => The ONLY Reason We Are Aware AT ALL Of The Flash Of Insight … (Or Other Mental Arrivals A) thru H). ) … Is Because Our Problem Solving Brain Has Just Suddenly Come To A Halt. … And Is Stuck At A Place Where It Can NOT Satisfactorily Achieve A Needed Problem Solution.
…15)cont AND we become aware we are “stuck”, and also know we have NO way to consciously “go directly after” an answer, except to quit &wait, and hope a Mental Arrival Solution (Answer), will come “out of the blue”! ….But of course & sooner or later our Problem Solving Brain will automatically spontaneously Generate, Construct, Create => A Best Or Near Best Solution (Answer).
…1) AND, importantly for survival, we are Consciously Aware & Know We Are Stuck, With No Answer. We also instantly know pretty much what the problems is, and instantly know we have NO direct way to “move ahead” to an answer or solution:
…2) Thus, at first, we know we have no direct way to get a good answer (solution), except to ~”Quit & Wait”. for a Mental Arrival Solution (Answer), to Suddenly, Automatically Spontaneously, Mentally, Arrive, “Out of the Blue”, such as Flash of Insight.
…3) OR alternatively => “Quit & Begin” =>. To seek other ways to move toward, toward what we originally wanted, as follows in below 19) =>
…4) Given How Our Problem Solving Brain Operates, We Need To Remember: The Clear Advantages Of =>
…a) When Halted, Stuck, & Blocked With No Available Mental Arrival Solution (Answer) => We Must Prepare, Study, And Struggle For A Solution, THEN QUIT & WAIT! Or
…b) Alternatively, When Out Of Gumption, We Should Quit & Wait. And Only After Gumption Returns, Is It Possible To Continue Work.
…5) Thus most often the better method is => The virtues of this ”Quit & Wait”, as are fully discussed in => For Complete Explanation Click Here To Go To => APPENDIX XI: Virtues of QUIT & WAIT In Creative Problem Solving.
…6) Additionally, I Henry Gurr, believe that => “Some important discoveries can ONLY be found this “Quit & Wait” way! … AND this technique seems to go way beyond normal problem solving procedures. … I think this is because, after you “Go as far as you can, THEN COME BACK LATER”, effectively “drops the reader into to the middle of the action”, without the mind, much remembering any previous work. This gives a sufficiently DIFFERENT “PERSPECTIVE”, that new & newly needed fixes and creative improvements, will suddenly, automatically, spontaneously “just appear” into conscious mind => The needed “better ways to do it; just suddenly pop into Mind!” …..
….. But, A Better Way To Say This Is => In your work, when “The Creative Well Goes Dry”, and you are “Out of Gumption”, THEN => Quit And Come Back At A Later Time => Hours, days, months. Only then, you will see your work flowing more easily & productively!.
… For Example => Now, only here in my typing just now, do I suddenly “Mental Arrival” see” in retrospect, the importance of above-mentioned words these => Some much needed important improvements would NOT be “realized” in any other way!
…7) Thus, from a) The above example of ”Quit & Wait” and b) By the clear evidence seen, in the discussion (In this Blue Link >> Where I Ever So Gradually, Finally Fully Achieved A Full Realization, Of A VERY Important Idea (Concerning MEANING),
…Only then did I, finally and fully “see”. AND, please note well => This important “achievement” ''Mentally Arrived => ONLY after completion of very long series of writing & typing additions of many individual words (and word phrases), spread out over two years, and 6 different Save-As Files, each of which was accomplished by several writing sessions:
PROPOSITION 22): The Overall Content (and Timing) Of Mental Arrivals, Such As Flash Of Insight Or Others, May Be Used To Not Only Measure How WELL Your Perception System Is Working, But ALSO SHOWS WE CONSTANTLY HAVE AN AUTOMATIC, SPONTANEOUS, ABILITY TO IMMEDIATELY COME TO ATTENTION => WHEN SOMETHING NEW, IMPORTANT, PLEASURABLE, PECULIAR, ODD, DIFFERENT, OUT-OF-PLACE, IS COMING INTO OUR NINE SENSES!
a) You are at a building construction site, and your eyes automatically “spot”, and lock-onto, a rusty nail sticking up out of an odd piece of lumber. If such happens to you quickly, easily, & reliably, then you know your mind is alert and running well !
b) You happen to be near berry bushes (or looking into fruit bearing trees), and although you have no thought of fruit existence, your eyes “lay-on-to”, some fruit color, Suddenly Automatically Spontaneously, with no effort.. If such happens quickly, easily, & reliably, then you know your mind is alert and running well !
c) You are outdoors, enjoying summer day, with nary a care in the world: Suddenly your eyes automatically swing to and “fixate” on a biting insect, or “lock-onto” a blood sucking tick: When these so called “Deer Ticks”, get on your body, they will eventually dig-in, and such your blood. From such tick “bites”, you can get dangerous disease, Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever. If you discover ticks quickly, easily,& reliably, then you know your mind is alert and running well !
d) You are on a carefree walk on a forest trail, with no thought of danger: Until suddenly you stop, and just as suddenly your wondering why? A half second later, you realize you are looking a patch or Poison Ivy, or as happened to me, I was about to put my foot down on a 5 foot black snake. If such happens quickly, easily, & reliably, then you know your mind is alert and running well !
Ditto for the following => e) You’ve been talking to a person about a difficult problem, with no thought of a swing in mood. Suddenly you become aware the person is getting very angry, even before they realize this!
f) You are walking to your car, on a pleasant sunny October afternoon. with a few streaks of Cirrus Clouds paint-brush, the otherwise light blue sky. You are thinking about your future plans, but in the corner of your eye. By reflex, your eyes, jump to the brilliant blue + orange of a Sun Dog!
g) In the winter night sky, even though partly obscured by pine trees, my eye’s side-view automatically pick out, and latch onto, the major stars of the Constellation of Orion,
h) The examples a) thru h), have been a regular part of my life, showing my mind is “primed” for then. But up to about age 40, examples e) thru g) never happened to me, until after I learned about these from other persons, and started to include these in my teaching.
This are clear demonstrations of “before and after” my being “primed”. Up till age 40, I was perceptually blind. And because of this => Such wonderful Steller Views, were NOT a part of my life. i) Similar to h), I can now regularly hear about 6 different night time “calls” from 6 different species of frogs. Up till about age 60, these were likewise not part of my life!
j) By contrast to the above examples => You can also study your mind at work, with ~Near Miss Mental Arrivals. You may notice your attention “jump-to” what our originally thought were any of the a) thru g) above. BUT when you get a good look, you realize it was something else, not important at all.
Such attention “jump-to’s” may be wrong or disappointing, yes, but still useful for seeing how much (or if), your mind & memory are “primed for action”, literally and figuratively! k) The idea of g), does in fact happen to us, which is nicely captured in Lewis Carroll's Sylvie and Bruno => Poem => “He thought he saw a Banker's Clerk Descending from the bus, He looked again and saw it was A hippopotamus.”
… Of course the reverse, would be far more likely, but not as funny to children. (To see other poem examples => AFTER the Lewis Carroll Page comes up > Do > Edit > Find > … He thought he saw … )
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib
Here ENDS => The 23 PROPOSITIONS FOR A NEW KIND OF “PHILOSOPHY OF MIND”, by Henry Gurr. Obviously, There Are Lots Of Incomplete Parts Of My Thinking. For Example, Just How Is It Our Conscious Mind Is Able To Keep Track Of All Our Other, On-Going Perceptions, While A Flash Of Insight (or Other Mental Arrival), Is Happening? This Conceivably Might Be Answered By The Following Hypothesis:
AND Remember That In ALL Circumstances & Instants Of Time => What is really happening in our , ‘‘ “Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory,” '' Is Invisible Tiny Changes Of Widely Spaced Inter-Neuron Synapsis Connection Strengths: To See This “Synapsis” Idea => Click Here AND AFTER This Comes Up => Scroll Down Princeton Theoretical Physicist J. J. Hopfield’s Neural Network Model. … To learn more about => Deeply Submerged And Widely Dispersed In Tiny Invisible Adjustments in our Brain’s interconnections called Synapses > Do > Top > Edit > Find > …. PROPOSITION 8b) The Brain’s ~Mechanism For Creation Of Consciousness. (Editor RPG Comment: The layering of cycle of improvements in memory, while it can make it more accurate & easily accessible, also occasionally makes it less reliable, depending on circumstances! Each access edits it, making it less like the original event. For example, this can be what is happening when there is implant of false memories, of even the most clear past events.
A Continued Discussion of “Our Ability To See, Perceive, & Pattern Recognize, Is Taken Up In A NEW Page Called => “Partial Fit Problem Solutions Can Be Very Valuable!” =>
APPENDIX I thru XVII: => COVER MORE DISCUSSION & REAL LIFE APPLICATIONS OF THIS HENRY GURR’S THEORY OF HOW OUR MIND WORKS.
A) A continuation & amplification, of that already stated in above PROPOSITIONS 5) & 6), plus more about =>
B) The inter-related topics of Perception, Pattern Recognition, Partial Fit Problem Solution, which are =>
C) Topics in turn, which are so well identified & discussed by Michael Polanyi, in his own considerably different language & terms.
APPENDIX 0: We Share All Of Our General Problem Solving Brain Features & Abilities With The Animal Kingdom! :
Some Observations From Henry Gurr Family That Report The Problems Solving Ability Of Animals: These Are Consistent With Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” .
… Also See My MPPS Article => “Memory, Perception, Insight, and Problem Solving – AHA---!!! AFTER This MPPS WebPage Comes Up, Please Scroll Down To & Read How => Cows & Dogs have Flash Of Insights!!
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
a) Co-created future plans, feelings, and emotions.
b) A general sensation as to How Good (Valid, Veridical) The Solution Is.
c) A general sensation as to How Well Your Perception Body-Mind System Is Working”
d) The formation of a memory cycle => Cycle of Regenerative Upward Spiral Compounded, Ever Improved Brain Memory. Abbreviated as RRC.
SIDE NOTE: The remainder if this “APPENDIX I: The Role Of The General Problem Solving Brain In Feelings & Emotions” , is illustrated using the writings of Poet, Linguist, & Philosopher Owen Barfield: Click Here To See An Extensive INTRODUCTION TO OWEN BARFIELD, At The Start of “APPENDIX XVIII: How The Ideas Of Poet, Linguist, & Philosopher Owen Barfield Partly Support The Discussion Of => PROPOSITION 10c). ” : 2) The Mental Arrivals Of Feelings, Interplayed With Feelings & Emotions, Are Well Stated By Owen Barfield, In His Book Poetic Diction: =>
… You will find that all of Prof Richard Patterson’s discussion is illuminating, but you should give special attention to the excerpts (in italic ~10 inches below), that Richard Patterson has chosen (for our attention), from Owen Barfield’s book Poetic Diction” : The Perceptive Reader can see( in book Poetic Diction” ), that Mr. Barfield very well helps us “see” the interplay of feelings & emotions, in the reading of Poetry!
a) “A 'felt change of consciousness” .
b) “Appreciation takes place at the actual moment of change.”
c) “But the actual moment of the pleasure of appreciation depends upon something rarer and more transitory. It depends on the change itself..“
d) “Kindled by the passage from one plane of consciousness to another.”
e) “It [the meaning] lives during that moment of transition and then dies “
f) “and if it is to be repeated, some means must be found of renewing the transition itself.”
g) “It is the movement which is the apprehension of meaning and not the recognition of a codified relationship of a word to an overall linguistic system.”
h) “Language is the storehouse of imagination; it cannot continue to be itself without performing its function.”
i) “But its function is, to mediate transition from the UN-Individualized [the un-aware], … to the individualized human spirit,” [Which has suddenly, automatically, spontaneously, become aware.]
All these Barfield phrases (and many, many more from his book “Poetic Diction” ). is showing us how our mind works: AND these, in-turn supports my Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” '', and conversely! Excerpts, That Richard Patterson Has Chosen (For Our Attention), From Owen Barfield’s Book “Poetic Diction” : ”An appreciation of poetry involves a ‘felt change of consciousness” … ”[A]n introspective analysis of my experience obliges me to say that appreciation of poetry involves a ‘felt change of consciousness’. The phrase must be taken with some exactness. Appreciation takes place at the actual moment of the change.” [ie at the exact moment of the Mental Arrival into Consciousness.] “It is not simply that the poet enables me to see with his eyes, and so to apprehend a larger and fuller world. He may indeed do this, as we shall see later; but the actual moment of the pleasure of appreciation depends upon something rarer and more transitory. It depends on the change itself.” '… “[T]he poetic mood, which, like the dreams to which it has so often been compared, is kindled by the passage from one plane of consciousness to another. It [the meaning] lives during that moment of transition and then dies, and if it is to be repeated, some means must be found of renewing the transition itself. It is the movement which is the apprehension of meaning and not the recognition of a codified relationship of a word to an overall linguistic system. ”
[Based On This Insight Into The Nature Of Poetic Diction, Barfield Develops A Theory Of Language And The Role Of Discursive Thought: Barfield’s Poetic Diction: Continues => ] ”New meaning is introduced into language by means of poetic diction, but it is immediately transformed into an element of discursive thought. The Meaning of life is continually being dried up, as it were, and left for dead in the human mind by the operation of a purely discursive intellectual activity, of which language – built, as it is, on the impact of sense perceptions – is the necessary tool. This discursive activity is inseparable from human self-consciousness, out of which it would kill, alike the given Meanings of which language, at its early stages, still retains an echo, and the meanings which individual poets have inserted into it later by their creative activity in metaphor. ‘Language’, wrote Emerson, in a flash of insight which covers practically all that has been written in these pages, ‘is fossil poetry.’ Living poetry, on the other hand – the present stir of aesthetic imagination – lights up only when the normal continuum of this process is interrupted in such a manner that a kind of gap is created, and an earlier impinges directly upon a later – a more living upon a more conscious.”
Mr. Richard Patterson Adds: ”As much as self-consciousness seems to appear here as a disease of the mind, Barfield is never advocating a complete return to primitive consciousness or an abandonment of discursive thought. This is perhaps one of the areas in which Steiner offered him a solution. Barfield’s theory of language has implicit in it a theory of the evolution of consciousness from a pre-logical, un-self-conscious direct experience of meaning through the development of reason and self-consciousness towards an ultimate goal in which full self-consciousness is able to coexist with a direct participation in meaning. This evolutionary development is not seen as inevitable, and in fact the extent to which reason and logic have replaced poetry implies a vulnerability in the process.”
Mr. Peterson’s Selections From Owen Barfield’s Poetic Diction: Continues ”Language is the storehouse of imagination; it cannot continue to be itself without performing its function. But its function is, to mediate transition from the un-individualized, dreaming spirit that carried the infancy of the world to the individualized human spirit, which has the future in its charge. If therefore they succeed in expunging from language all the substance of its past, in which it is naturally so rich, and finally converting it into the species of algebra that is best adapted to the uses of indoctrination and empirical science, a long and important step forward will have been taken in the selfless cause of the liquidation of the human spirit. (23) He later formulated the evolution of consciousness in terms of a distinction between “original participation” and “final participation.”
For The Perceptive Reader, Richard Patterns Whole Article Shows, In Essence, Owen Barfield ’s Thinking, AND Especially How Barfield’s Thinking In Turn, Is Carefully Showing Us How Our Mind Works With Words And Poetry, Wherein The Important End Products Are Feelings & Emotions!
a) “A 'felt change of consciousness” .
b) “Appreciation takes place at the actual moment of change.”
c) “But the actual moment of the pleasure of appreciation depends upon something rarer and more transitory. It depends on the change itself..“
d) “Kindled by the passage from one plane of consciousness to another.”
e) “It [the meaning] lives during that moment of transition and then dies “
f) “and if it is to be repeated, some means must be found of renewing the transition itself.”
g) “It is the movement which is the apprehension of meaning and not the recognition of a codified relationship of a word to an overall linguistic system.”
h) “Language is the storehouse of imagination; it cannot continue to be itself without performing its function.”
i) “But its function is, to mediate transition from the un-individualized [the un-aware], … to the individualized human spirit,” [Which has suddenly, automatically, spontaneously, become aware.], '
All these Barfield phrases (and many, many more from his book “Poetic Diction” ). is showing us how our mind works: AND these, in-turn supports my Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” '', and conversely! Information About Owen Barfield’s Book “Poetic Diction”
NOTE1: You May Read Alternate Discussion Of Owen Barfield’s Book “Poetic Diction” > By > Edit > Find > … Insightful Books Of Poet, Linguist, & Philosopher ….. NOTE2: You May Read ~6 Pages Additional Discussion Of Owen Barfield’s Book “Poetic Diction” > By Continuing Read At “Bobby Matherne”, Next Below. ….. . UPDATE: An Email 26 May 2019, From Bobby Matherne, Announced His Just Completed. Review of Owen Barfield’s Book Poetic Diction” '': Below is a Very LONG C&P from Bobby Mathern’s discussion and examples of Barfield’s words (in italic): These show “Barfield’s “Workings of Our Mind, And Especially How Our Mind Works With Words":
' ******** Start Bobby Matherne ******** Excerpts From Bobby Matherne Review of Owen Barfield’s Poetic Diction” Which Say -> ' “Mr. Barfield Closes Out His Chapter On Poetic Diction Strangeness This Way:”
[page 179] 'Language', wrote Emerson, in a flash of insight which covers practically all that has been written in these pages, 'is fossil poetry'. … Living poetry, on the other hand — the present stir of aesthetic imagination — lights up only when the normal continuum of this process is interrupted in such a manner that a kind of gap is created, and an earlier impinges directly upon a later — a more living upon a more conscious. “Emerson's insights shared in his Essays poured an endless supply of insight into my still teenage brain which never left me.” …. Next Barfield refers the reader of Poetic Diction to the voluminous writings of Rudolf Steiner. As for myself as a reader of over 237 books of Rudolf Steiner, I can attest to an endless flood of insights I have acquired from Herr Steiner.” [page 207] And here the reader is once more referred to the voluminous writings of Rudolf Steiner, who brought to bear upon precisely this ancient consciousness an amazing wealth of intuition, inspiration, and imagination, illuminating it out of an inexhaustible fertility in metaphor with a brilliant flood of poetic light. “What better way of completing my review than a quote from Barfield's concluding paragraph, elaborating on what constitutes great poetry, in which he gives us a living creation to hold memorably in our hand.” [page 181] Great poetry is the progressive incarnation of life in consciousness. Hence the absolute value of aesthetic pleasure as a criterion; for before we can feel it, we must have become aware in some degree of the actual progress — not merely of its results. Over the perpetual evolution of human consciousness, which is stamping itself upon the transformation of language, the spirit of poetry hovers, forever unable to alight. It is only when we are lifted above that transformation, so that we behold it as present movement, that our startled souls feel the little pat and the throbbing, feathery warmth, which tell us that she has perched. It is only when we have risen from beholding the creature into beholding creation that our mortality catches for a moment the music of the turning spheres. ”So rare: an academic book that leaves me breathless, saying under my breath, WOW!” ******** END Bobby Matherne Review Excerpts ******** To Mr Matherne’s Words, I Henry Gurr, Can Only Fully Agree!! WOW!!! WOW!!!!
A) The Problem Solving Brain Will Automatically Usually & Repeatedly Bring-Back To Our Minds, Important UN-Finished Business, Regrets We Wish Would Not Have Happened, Loose-Ends, or Other Needful Actions That Must Be Done! For Example1 => The many Minor Residual Problems, That Somehow Remain “A-Problem” For Us. Such as =>
1) Various UN-Wanted events of our life such as => “regrets”, or “losses”, or “griefs”, or “accidents past” “grievances”, or “annoyances”, botherations”, “something we wish never had happened” or =>
For Example2 => Various Situations That Haven’t Been Properly Been Finished-With (Or Can’t Be) =>
1) UN-Properly dealt with and/or
2) IN-Adequately resolved and/or
3) Somehow never laid to rest and/or
4) UN-Properly “buried”, or somehow never forgotten enough to move on with life.
B) And Just As Amazingly, These Above Mentioned Reminders Will STOP Once Satisfactory Completion (or Problem Resolution), Has Been Properly Fulfilled !
… So … Pay Attention … You Will Be Amazed … Indeed You Will Observe That => Automatically These Spontaneous & Repeated Reminders, Will Mentally Arrival Into Consciousness, Such As => Reminders of : 1) UN-Finished Business, UN-Resolved Loses, Griefs, or Grievances, (as discussed above),
2) Un-resolved puzzles (or peculiarities), you’ve encountered, OR
3) Un-completed projects, you’ve decided to do, but remain UN-done. Such as => Clean out the car, start house repair, build a new storage shed, lawn mower maintenance, write email to a friend, or write ideas for a book or article. And although these may have been, very long time, UN-done projects, the Reminders will still continue! .
3) Actions you have completed or planned, but still may have leftover worries or doubts =>You still will automatically get to worrying => What will happen, as other people finally see (or will see), your “not-so-good” finished work, that has some error (or embarrassing feature), you’ve just suddenly realized, has to be there. (See EXAMPLE1, EXAMPLE2, below.)
4) In such circumstances, at odd moments, you may have sudden twinges of small mental alarms, which remind you of these un-resolved parts of your life:
5) At odd moments Mental Arrivals will come => ”Oops”, Oh no”, “That is wrong”, I have to fix that quickly, etc! …
… So. Automatically & spontaneously your Problem Solving Brain will remind you of these major (or minor) UN-correct situations, “A-Problem Requiring Attention”: And the Reminders will automatically be there, by Mental Arrivals.
6) And even for already completed tasks (such as writing composition of This Document You Are Currently Reading, or an email), that you thought were, long ago, completely done with: Despite this, your mind will find (often Out Of The Blue) sudden Mental Arrivals, and will automatically, spontaneously, bring to your attention, the existence of various imperfections, factual errors, missing words, missing ideas, wrong text, & other needful fixes, & corrections, or other important needed ideas to add!
… Although this is quite functional, and just what you want, this is still an amazing property of our Problem Solving Brain. (For more on this topic > a) Do > Top > Edit > Find > … steps happen in writing composition …
b) Do > Top > Edit > Find > … In Your Writing Composition … )
7) Similarly, in some event (or thinking about your life generally), you may get =>
a) Close to the physical scene of a long ago bad accident, at which point “what happened” will automatically come back, and you will prompted to start preventative watching, so it doesn’t happen again. ~”near-to-
b) Or, similarly, you have an experience (or happen to be thinking about) ideas ~Close to a along ago:: At which point, your mind (functioning as an associative memory retrieval) will Suddenly Automatically Spontaneously jump to this forgotten old memory, and it will come back fully.
b) Or, similarly, you suddenly have a feeling of having already experienced the present situation. Like walking into a restaurant and seeing or smelling a certain food. This is an experience called dé jà vu (or déjà vu), and again is an ability of our associative memory retrieval.
8) Or even with no evident prompting =>You will notice, at odd moments, you may remember (Mental Arrival), twinges of regret, loss / shame / sadness, etc, which remind you of these Un-Resolved Parts Of Your Life, Or Great Losses you wish never would have happened. And similarly, possibly your Mind, slides to some UN-Resolved Grievous Losses, Bad Debt, Big Frustration, Big Negatives, Bad Error In A Public Speaking Event, ,etc.
9) Other reminders will be prompted by seeing (or experiencing), something on a related topics, weighted by salience, how recent, relative importance, physical closeness, or idea similarity. Other examples include, automatic remembering of =>
a) When you catch sight of (or even think about) a person whom there was serious dispute, serious argument, serious fight or
b) You catch sight of an approach to a particular road intersection, because of a near-miss accident that happened there previously, etc.
10) In some cases, you had no idea these regrets even possibly existed, but just the same, they Spontaneously Come Automatically To Mind, most typically in Quiet Moments Consciousness Un-Occupied (McU) !
11) The existence of these UN-Finished, UN-Resolved Items, will over the day, weeks, years, spontaneously & repeatedly pop into your mind: Some of these, will remained just as intense, and their frequency of arrival not diminish, despite many years later.
Here Are Some Examples Where It Is Noticed A Person’s Mind Automatically, Goes To The Most Important Of The Needed Actions, Among Those That Needed Attention: EXAMPLE1: A NASA Engineer’s Perception Instantly Finds An Serious Error, When Attention Slightly Begins To Go In That Direction: Of course Engineers are always looking for errors, and as true for all of us => Sometimes all that is needed is a redirection of attention. … I remember the following story told by Richard Feynman, as he was investigating the Challenger Spacecraft Accident: … A NASA Engineer was showing Feynman an electronic diagram of the spacecraft: Feynman saw a symbol on the diagram he did not know the meaning and started to point at it: Instantly the engineer saw (near by, un related), a grievous error, previously UN-recognized. He said ~”My God Dr Feynman, you are a genius!! This is serious, I have to tell management immediately!!”
EXAMPLE2: I Woke Up In The Middle Of The Night, In A Sweat, With Sudden Realization That, My Heavy Loading Job Could NOT Be Continued As Already Planned.
… EXPLANATION: I had already experienced some 4 instances of cracked steel roller-bearing from my loading of ~3 tons of lead. Of course, while I was loading lead, my mind was totally fixated on a difficult job, which was all new to me. Thus I was NOT in any way thinking, that if I continued as I had already planned, would result in more & more cracked rollers, and eventually my rollers, would be stuck, where even a repair, would be impossible. A disaster! Obviously =>
… But, I HAD to first realize, that my loading lead must be stopped, despite delays & expense of a fix-up of the cracked rollers: Obviously, I had to STOP, or an even bigger expenses and delay would otherwise surely result. But this reality took over 16 hours, to Suddenly Automatically Spontaneously Mental Arrive!, to realize, out of the blue, wake up, in the middle of the night!!
EXAMPLE3: As Is Typical For Lots Of Spontaneous Memories => Some Of These Reminders, Will Mentally Arrive In Quiet Moments When Your Conscious Mind Is UN-Occupied. In My Own Quiet Moments of Consciousness UN-Occupied (McU), Recent Stimulating Events Ideas, or Even Music, Will Spontaneously “Come-Back”, for “Re-Play!
… My experience => I so much enjoy my G F Handel’s Messiah Music CD, that I will repeat play it till I’ve practically memorized the music: Following this, in a Moment of Consciousness UN-occupied (McU), my mind will spontaneous start a “mental record player” in my head, of this music! This mental music spontaneously happens at odd moments, many times per day, getting fewer per day, for up to 10 days later. We might conclude from this observation, that this is ~proof / support for a hypothesis => Ideas circulate as packages in our mind, waiting to be used, or paid attention to, for durations measured in days!. (For more on this topic > Do > Top > Edit > Find > … McU … )
EXAMPLE4: Archie Bunker on TV Program, Where Much Of The Humor, Was Based On His Automatic Knee-Jerk, Burst Of Stereotype Words, Triggered By Just As Stereotyped, Off-Hand Statements, Of His Friends. Archie" Bunker 1970s American television sitcom, In All in the Family got many of its laughs by playing on Archie's bigotry, which most always Mentally Arrived, from his UN resolved frustrations!, END Wikipedia on Archie Bunker.
13) Above mentioned in 1) thru 12) are cases where remembering was successful. However unfortunately there are (perhaps 2% of cases) of when we => Totally and completely forget! And some of these, the “Totally Forget” can result in quite a disaster!
APPENDIX II SUMMARY: It is Noteworthy & Quite Amazing => A) The Problem Solving Brain Will (Usually & Repeatedly) Bring To Our Minds Important {+UN-Finished Business!
B) And SUPER AMAZINGLY, The Reminders Will NOT Continue Once Satisfactory Completion (or Problem Resolution), Is Fully Completed !!!
C) These A) & B) stand to repeated observation, and are a quite amazing, and functional property of our own Problem Solving Brain!
D) These abilities of our Problem Solving Brain, must have been well established quite early in our animal evolutionary history, and thus are quite functional, well refined, integrated, balanced, and indeed intelligent!
E) The Problem Solving Brain Will (Usually & Repeatedly) Bring To Our Minds Important UN-Finished Projects, and this has close relevance to how you know you’ve completed Important tasks: AND if you’ve done the task with Quality; The net result is => Robert Pirsig’s “Peace of Mind” And How To Achieve It..
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Because It Is a Property of Your Problem Solving Brain: L-I-A-U-S Applies To ANYTHING You Do: Work, Writing Composition, Sports, Music, Travel, Etc, As I’ve Tried to Emphasize to My Students => “This Is The Learning / Interest / Attention / Upward / Spiral” (L-I-A-U-S) => Get interested, because the more you are interested,
The more you pay attention, & the more you learn.
The more you learn, the more you know.
The more you know, the more your lessons will make sense.
The more sense your lessons make, the more you will overall understand.
The more you will understand your lessons, the more you can get interested.
The more get interested in your lessons, the more they will have meaning.
With more meaning, your lessons will be less pain & a whole lot more fun.
Less of a pain & a whole lot more fun, there will automatically be an increases your interest!
Which goes back to the beginning of the learning Cycle! With More Interest => The Cycle Repeats => But NOW You Are At A Much Higher Place On The Learning / Interest / Attention / Upward / Spiral !! UP HERE THE VISTA IS GRAND!!!
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
The more you see, the more you are capable of seeing!
The more you know, the more you are capable of knowing!
The more you learn, the more you are capable of learning!
The more you are interested, the more you are capable of more interest, & thus more learning!
The more you do, the more you are capable of doing!
The more you manage the more you are capable of managing!
The more you experiment, the more you are capable of good experiments!
The more you practice any skill, sport, musical instrument etc, the more you are capable of these!
This IS How Our Problem Solving Bain Automatically Operates! –Guaranteed!! Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
1) Nature does not want the “Johnny-Come-Lately” facility we call Consciousness, to mess up, an existing Problem Solving Brain “solution in process”, which is already being accomplished by our UN- Conscious Mind.
2) It is clear to me, that UN-Conscious Brain Process, will be fastest, most reliable, and accurate, if allowed to go to completion, without outside interference, or other form of disturbance, until AFTER stable full completion of the then emerging Mental Arrival Solution.
3) The basic reasons (for this “not knowing”), being this => If our Conscious Mind knew about an impending solution in process, it might try to “listen in”, anticipate the results, or stop or shift the “solution” or change other on-going behavior: This in-turn, might affect what the UN- Conscious Mind is doing.
4) Thus the less powerful, less competent, Consciousness Mind, might disturb or misdirect, the processes of the UN-Conscious Problem Solution, WHILE already in process.
5) We must assume there are NOT other good ways to prevent this interference, such as “barrier walls” or “isolation boxes”, to prevent what is otherwise massive brain inter-connectivity of ALL brain parts!
6) If the Conscious Mind was allowed to have some effect on the UN- Conscious Mind, this might set up a positive feed-back loop, which could hard to control.
7) But => AFTER the Problem Solution is fully presented as a Mental Arrival (into Conscious Mind), this fully formed Optimal (Best or Near Best) Solution, is of course, itself un-changeable. And subsequent Conscious Mind activity can’t alter this, what has already come into Consciousness. What is done, is done:
8) And, AFTER is fully presented to our Conscious Mind, this same Conscious Mind has plenty of time to STOP, or CHANGE the course of any subsequent body actions or thinking conclusions, such as => Change, or even stop, the newly emerged Problem Solution. In other words, Conscious Mind can greatly change => The newly emerged Problem Solution, with its Future Planed or even Set In Body Motion, from previous original UN- Conscious Mind Solution.
SUMMARY: => After the Problem Solution is fully presented as a Sudden, Automatic, Spontaneous, Mental Arrival, the fully formed Solution itself is UN-Changeable), But subsequent Conscious Mind activity can actually alter, stop, improve, and/or redirect the Future Plans (or Body Motion), that came with the Original Solution. In fact, these TWO “Systems” work in parallel, and potentially one of the “Systems” can improve upon (or even go beyond), the other is highly functional, and just what we want ! . 9) All this of course indicates that our Conscious Mind. does have some power of its own. Such power may additionally include => Language, Thinking-With-Language-&-Logic, Symbolic Meaning, etc. (Or merely seem that way.) (This may be related to the somewhat independent powers of the Right Brain, versus the Left Brain?)
10) This Consciousness-System Power or ability thus seems to run in parallel to the UN-Conscious General Problem Solver Brain System: Both “Systems” seems to have its OWN memory, and seem to have independent solutions of their own: These characteristics are in full agreement with the Dual Process Theories, discussed elsewhere in This Document You Are Currently Reading.
11) Thus I conclude that our Conscious Mind System CAN have solutions different from the UN-Conscious (General Problem Solver Brain) System, and Conscious Mind System (perhaps using Language, Thinking-With-Language-&-Logic, Symbolic Meaning, etc), develop answers / conclusions (not un-like my writing composition conclusions I’m doing now), and such conclusions might trigger a new even better solution, from the, “UN-Conscious Mind System.”
12) Moreover, these two “Systems”, working in parallel, can alternately, “leap-frog” jump ahead of each other, especially if one of the two, is blocked or stuck or is suffering “perceptual blindness”. … It’s interesting to observe how this works. Here we notice these two systems, are mostly a) Running on automatic, AND b) Both certainly seem autonomous, (For more Do > Edit > Find > … autonomous … )
((NOTE: These above are speculative & tentative conclusions, which (came to my mind), as I’ve been reminded of, regularly over the last say 5 years. Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
13) The operation of Consciousness Mind “System” Problem Solutions (perhaps having added power by using Language, Thinking-With-Language-&-Logic, Symbolic Meaning, etc), necessarily come from the operation of our UN-Conscious Mind:
14) And (as stated above) if our Conscious Mind “System”, “knows”, what our UN-Conscious “System” is up to …, thus it would be a circular dependence … a form of self-reference … wrong to start with: This is because Conscious Awareness DEPENDS of the workings of the UN-Conscious Brain Processes!,
15) Either way, this could possibly create an un-wanted run-away positive feedback regeneration!
16) So nature apparently prevents such circular dependence, by allowing us absolutely no conscious awareness, even the slightest hint, of any ongoing processes in our UN-Conscious Problem Solving Brain, until well AFTER (as said above), the problem solution is fully presented as a Mental Arrival, into Consciousness.
17) It is conceivable that this happens by default of the Hypothesis (stated elsewhere in This Document You Are Currently Reading), that there is no Mental Arrival into Conscious, until there is growth to saturation: And combined with the Hypothesis, that each nascent Mental Arrival, excludes other similar of the 7 plus/minus 2, Nascent Mental Arrivals: (These Hypothesis are discussed elsewhere in This Document, which you are now reading: )
18) The fact that the operations of our UN-Conscious Mind are “totally out of mind”, leaves us with few ways to know of its existence, despite it’s extreme importance! This is largely responsible for people in our culture to not know anything about it. This, strange to say, includes philosophers, scientists, & other experts, who ought to know better!
… Are these persons showing an extreme case of perceptual blindness? And typical of most perceptual blindness, such is only cured by these persons own careful watching for the results, of their brain’s otherwise invisible processes!
From The Above Conclusions That => The “Conscious Mind & The UN- Conscious Mind Are TWO “Systems” Work In Parallel, Whereby Potentially, One Of The “Systems” Can Improve Upon (Or Even Go Beyond), The Other, Is Highly Functional, =>
19) “We have to remember that The Purpose of Consciousness, is primarily, to show us what the UN-Conscious Mind, has already decided upon. And as is observed =>
a) Consciousness makes us aware of just completed Problem Solutions, such as: sensory perceptions, spatial orientation, plans for action, ideas, answers, etc.:
b) As discussed by various authors =>It appears that Consciousness, first (and it’s evolutionary original main purpose), is to just show us, what our UN- Conscious Mind, has already come up with.
c) Originally (in Darwinian Evolution), Conscious in animals was mostly not for doing anything, beyond a “display”, of what already been decided, by their Problem Solving Brain. (This is “just for display”, is analogous to a Computer Monitor Screen.)
d) But in addition to “make us aware”, also available in Consciousness, are some linguistic thinking abilities : And as mentioned above, by using this ability we, AFTER the fact of a Mental Arrival, can Consciously ALTER OUR SUBSEQUENT ACTIONS:
e) In other words => AFTER the presentation of a Mental Arrivals, from the UN-Conscious Mind, we can ~with language based thinking ability, make alternate decisions & plans, which clearly (and amazingly), get back into and influence, even re-direct, our UN-Conscious Brain Processes, for the NEXT Mental Arrivals & Actions!
f) From all this => We must realize that our Consciousness System(s) has it’s own … Nature & Ways … Purposes & limitations … including fact we are totally UN-aware of what “constructs” it, which we have to learn about, and effectively use.
g) The fact that the workings of UN- Conscious Mind are hidden from us is widely known, and is very well experimentally verified:.
h) As stated previously => We may reasonably assume that => Nature has given us our observed Consciousness, so that humans (and probably most animals and birds), will have increased mental efficiency and resultant body performance, and thus improved general abilities, but most specifically for increased survival. AND We who, second-by-second, are the users of this marvelous awareness provided by Consciousness, can readily list what these advantages might be => a) Consciousness, helps us better “see”, what our perception puts before our “mind’s eye”, b) Consciousness awareness automatically swing our attention an imminent danger, and c) Prompting the formulation of a plan of action, which must surely enhance biological fitness and therefore survival.
i) It appears that our Human Conscious System, evolutionarily augmented the Conscious System inherited from mammal predecessors, and integrating this, along with the development of Human Linguistic ability, perhaps having added power by using Language, Thinking-With-Language-&-Logic, Symbolic Meaning, etc
j) As discussed by various authors =>, the Human Conscious System seems to have developed relatively recently, and is an Evolutionary add-on to our brain, that are not so well refined. And as indicated elsewhere in This Document you are currently reading, our Consciousness “System”, has a much smaller computational power of its own, compared to the UN-Conscious General Problem Solver Brain System.
k) As a consequence, our Consciousness ‘System”, is (& must be), as secondary, less powerful, servant of our UN-Conscious Brain Processes.
HOWEVER, Google Can NOT Find => Any Discussions Of The REASONS WHY =>
… A Google Search For The Above, Found This Revealing Comment By “Keith Payne June 11, 2013, About Our Conscious Mind, Not Aware Of Un- Conscious Mind Doings” =>
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
And The Whole Drive Of Our Western Civilization, And Specifically Western Philosophy, Came Down To A Demand For Very Clear, Explicit Objective (I.E. Scientific) Answers To Everything.
NOTE: Robert Pirsig, In His “Zen And The Art Of Motorcycle Maintenance” (ZMM), Shows Why & How Subjective Qualities Are Important, Indeed VERY Important !!
Thus, Robert Pirsig In His Book “Zen And The Art Of Motorcycle Maintenance” (ZMM), Has Much To Teach Us About This Very ‘ILL-Logical’ Flash Of Insight, Which He Calles “Crystallization” (And Which Owen Barfield Calls “Inspiration”.)
… And This Brings To Mind Thomas Kuhn’s Book “Structure Of Scientific Revolutions”, which does a very good job at explaining the in’s and out’s of how and why, at first the majority of practicing scientists, as a matter of multiply demonstrated facts, reject and ignore new important major scientific discoveries & related new theories. It took me a long time to realize that what Dr Kuhn was saying, ALSO applied to why Pirsig, Barfield, and Polanyi get ignored. … Now We Are Back To What I Said Above About Western Readers Not See (Ie Blind To), The Virtues Of Eastern Thought, Because They See ONLY Their Own Western Scientific Paradigm: My Self here starts to generate answers, in a series of thoughts, came to my mind ~=>
A) Trained into us is ONLY a particular brand of Scientific Thinking, which is word based, logical, mathematical, etc. In other words :”scientific thinking”, all done in conscious mind: AND =>
B)“Systematically trained OUT of us, any thinking that is not being scientific!” Thus => ”This automatically leaves us blind (Kuhn again.), to, not only Eastern Thought & Ways, but also the UN-conscious workings of our mind, and it’s primarily indicators, the Flash of Insight, and other Mental Arrivals. Consequently we have mostly no way to know how best to use our Problem Solving Brain, which most of the time uses UN-Conscious Brain Processes, to reveal to us => The above mentioned “Subjective Qualities”, that indeed “real”, just as real as your own hand!.
… Thus again => “High recommendations for, the works of Owen Barfield, Michael Polanyi, Robert Pirsig, Morris Berman, and others, who discuss => Just how IN-Sufficient is this “Scientific” turn of Western Culture is, and offer us very constructive ways for us to do Better!. I Have Rather Of A Backwards Proof Of The Above Mentioned “Trained OUT Of Us”
1) How to study & observe the Flash of Insight, as a means to understand the workings of Our UN-Conscious Mind. AND
2) How the Flash of Insight (and other similar Mental Arrivals), in turn, relate to how our Consciousness thoughts may be Created, entirely due to UN-conscious Brain Processes, AND
3) The fact that the workings of UN-Conscious Mind are seemingly on purpose, hidden from us.
4) And how => By means of above 1), 2), & 3) => We Have Strong Support (And Explanation), For “Our Problem Solving Brain, Unconscious Processes, Automatically. Spontaneously, Generates, Constructs, Creates => ‘A Mental Model’ Of Our Universe Around Us” AND How This “Generates, Constructs, Creates” Is Approximately Equal To Robert Pirsig’s Dynamic Quality. Click Here For Extensive Reading.
The Facts That The Above 1) Thru 4), Mostly Are NOT Found In The Literature …Means That … The Main Ideas Of Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”. In This Document You Are Currently Reading, Are Not Much Found In => a) In Research Literature, nor
b) “There” in our society, or
c) I’m looking in the wrong place.
This Lack Of Our Awareness Of The High-Powered Activity Of Our UN-Conscious General Problem Solving Brain Processes, Happens For Additional Important Reasons, Discussed Here. => AFTER This WebPage Comes Up, Scroll Down To Phrase => “The reason why our conscious mind 5%… “ ]] SIDE NOTE1: This APPENDIX IX (Which You Are Currently Reading), Contains Knowledge, Realizations, Questions, & Conclusions, I Have Been Long Been Aware Of. But these topics never connected enough, for me to write up: It was only when I was composing related topics, in an email to Gerald Rudolph, that my mind got close enough, that a series of realizations (Came To My Mind), tumbling nearly automatically into place, and thus achieve a new higher level coherence! With subsequent editing, you see the above final composition of Appendix IX. SIDE NOTE2: You Can Easily Read Brief Selected Passages For Any Of The Herein Mentioned Authors, By => Edit > Find Each Name. (This can usually be done by pressing the keyboard combination Ctrl + F (or) Edit + F depending on what your computer’s keys say.) APPENDIX X: This WebPage You Are Currently Reading, In Agreement With Professor Hopfield’s Conclusions For A Neuron Network Model =>
1) Mental (perception, memory, ideas, thinking, etc.) or
2) Physical-muscular-actions (speaking, tool using, trail following, etc.).
These Solutions (Answers) Very Closely Fit Robert Pirsig’s => “You know what is Best!” (ie “What Is Good”; What Is “Quality”): “You can just see it !!” Thus Worthy Of Your Attention Is => Robert Pirsig’s Book “Zen and The Art Of Motorcycle Maintenance” (ZMM), Because Pirsig Fully Discusses, How We Automatically Know What is Best AND What Is Good. “You just see it !!”
b) Especially this => In ZMM Chapter 1, where Author Robert Pirsig gives his book’s focus saying =>
“I would like, instead, to be concerned with the question ‘What is best,’” c) AND in Chapter 17 => “ The reluctant student might ask in class, ‘But how do we know what’s good?’ … but almost before the question was out of his mouth he would realize the answer had already been supplied. Some other student would usually tell him, ‘You just see it.’”
d) These above b) & c) as well as many other passages in ZMM, Nicely Support and well, aligns well with => The facts that our Problem Solving Brain (Network Of Neurons), Can and Does, Yield Optimal (Best or Near Best) Solutions, which are indeed Best or Near Best Solutions.
APPENDIX X cont: As They Read Passages From ZMM, 1) thru 9) Below =>
Throughout ZMM, Robert Pirsig Provides Many, Many, Examples Of Problem-Solving-Brain In Its Instants Of Action.
A) The ZMM Passages Below 1), 2), 3) & 4) Point To Our Ability To See “What Is Good” And Show This Is Closely Related The Ability To See “What Is.=> Best Or Near Best” . 1) “What is good, Phædrus, and what is not good—need we ask anyone to tell us these things? ”
2) “It is what he [Phaedrus] was saying months before in the classroom in Montana, a message Plato and every dialectician since him had missed, since they all sought to define the Good in its intellectual relation to things. ”
3) "But how do we know what’s good?" [or Best], but almost before the question was out of his mouth he [the student] would realize the answer had already been supplied. .... "You just see it. ”
4) “The way to see what looks good and understand the reasons it looks good, and to be at one with this goodness as the work proceeds, is to cultivate an inner quietness, a peace of mind so that goodness can shine through. ”
5) “I keep talking wild theory, but it keeps somehow coming out stuff everybody knows, folklore. This Quality, this feeling for the work, is something known in every shop. ”
“Now finally let’s get back to that screw. ”
“ Let’s consider a reevaluation of the situation in which we assume that the stuckness now occurring, the zero of consciousness, isn’t the worst of all possible situations, but the best possible situation you could be in. After all, it’s exactly this stuckness that Zen Buddhists go to so much trouble to induce; through koans, deep breathing, sitting still and the like. Your mind is empty, you have a "hollow-flexible" attitude of "beginner’s mind." You’re right at the front end of the train of knowledge, at the track of reality itself. Consider, for a change, that this is a moment to be not feared but cultivated. If your mind is truly, profoundly stuck, then you may be much better off than when it was loaded with ideas. ”
“The solution to the problem often at first seems unimportant or undesirable, but the state of stuckness allows it, in time, to assume its true importance. It seemed small because your previous rigid evaluation which led to the stuckness made it small. ”
“But now consider the fact that no matter how hard you try to hang on to it, this stuckness is bound to disappear. Your mind will naturally and freely move toward a solution. Unless you are a real master at staying stuck you can’t prevent this. The fear of stuckness is needless because the longer you stay stuck the more you see the Quality-reality that gets you unstuck every time. What’s really been getting you stuck is the running from the stuckness through the cars of your train of knowledge looking for a solution that is [ONLY] out in front of the train.”
[ Important => Because Mr Pirsig is saying that your Problem Solving Brain will, automatically, spontaneously, find a Solution (Answer), that is Best or Near Best.] “Stuckness shouldn’t be avoided. It’s the psychic predecessor of all real understanding. An egoless acceptance of stuckness is a key to an understanding of all Quality, in mechanical work as in other endeavors. It’s this understanding of Quality as revealed by stuckness which so often makes self-taught mechanics so superior to institute-trained men who have learned how to handle everything except a new situation.”
As You Read Next Below, Please Know That => “Quality” is Mr. Pirsig’s name for the automatic problem-solving action of our mind: Also in the below Mr. Pirsig sometimes uses “Value” as a word equivalent to his use of “Quality”.
B) The ZMM Passages Below 5) Thru 9) Point To Our Ability To See Value, And Proceed With Quality, Leading To “Peace Of Mind”: (Where Quality (Among Other Things) Is Equivalent To The Action Ability Of Our Problem Solving Brain.)
6) ”Quality is the leading edge is where absolutely all the action is. The leading edge contains all the infinite possibilities of the future. It contains all the history of the past. Where else could they be contained? ... The past cannot remember the past. The future can’t generate the future. The cutting edge of this instant right here and now is always nothing less than the totality of everything there is. .. [Quality] Value, the leading edge of reality, is no longer an irrelevant offshoot of structure. [Quality] Value is the predecessor of structure. It’s the pre-intellectual awareness that gives rise to it. Our structured reality is preselected on the basis of [Quality] value, and really to understand structured reality requires an understanding of the [Quality] value source from which it’s derived. ”
7) “This gumption trap of anxiety, which results from over-motivation, can lead to all kinds of errors of excessive fussiness. You fix things that don’t need fixing, and chase after imaginary ailments. You jump to wild conclusions and build all kinds of errors into the machine because of your own nervousness. These errors, when made, tend to confirm your original underestimation of yourself. This leads to more errors, which lead to more underestimation, in a self-stoking cycle. ”
“The best way to break this [self-defeating]cycle, I think, is to work out your anxieties on paper. Read every book and magazine you can on the subject. Your anxiety makes this easy and the more you read the more you calm down. You should remember that it’s peace of mind you’re after and not just a fixed machine.” [ < Important: Here notice the ultimate goal => “ it’s peace of mind you’re after !! ”
“When beginning a repair job you can list everything you’re going to do on little slips of paper which you then organize into proper sequence. You discover that you organize and then reorganize the sequence again and again as more and more ideas come to you. The time spent this way usually more than pays for itself in time saved on the machine and prevents you from doing fidgety things that create problems later on. ”
You can reduce your anxiety somewhat by facing the fact that there isn’t a mechanic alive who doesn’t louse up a job once in a while. The main difference between you and the commercial mechanics is that when they do it you don’t hear about it—just pay for it, in additional costs prorated through all your bills. When you make the mistakes yourself, you at ]east get the benefit of some education. ” ''
“Boredom is the next gumption trap that comes to mind. This is the opposite of anxiety and commonly goes with ego problems. Boredom means you’re off the Quality track, you’re not seeing things freshly, you’ve lost your "beginner’s mind" and your motorcycle is in great danger.[<Big Warning!] Boredom means your gumption supply is low and must be replenished before anything else is done. ”
“When you’re bored, stop! Go to a show. Turn on the TV. Call it a day. Do anything but work on that machine. If you don’t stop, the next thing that happens is the Big Mistake, and then all the boredom plus the Big Mistake combine together in one Sunday punch to knock all the gumption out of you and you are really stopped.” [Problem Solving Brain “Stuck” and Can’t Move Forward!]
“Unless you are a real master at staying stuck you can’t prevent this. The fear of stuckness is needless because the longer you stay stuck the more you see the Quality-reality that gets you unstuck every time.”
8) “Peace of mind isn’t at all superficial to technical work. It’s the whole thing. That which produces it is good work and that which destroys it is bad work. The specs, the measuring instruments, the quality control, the final check-out, these are all means toward the end of satisfying the peace of mind of those responsible for the work. What really counts in the end is their peace of mind, nothing else. The reason for this is that peace of mind is a prerequisite for a perception.” [Problem Solving Brain Moving Forward.] “of that Quality which is beyond romantic Quality and classic Quality and which unites the two, and which must accompany the work as it proceeds. The way to see what looks good and understand the reasons it looks good, and to be at one with this goodness “ [Problem Solving Brain Moving Forward.] “as the work proceeds, is to cultivate an inner quietness, a peace of mind so that goodness can shine through. ”
9) “ I’ve sometimes thought this inner peace of mind, this quietness is similar to if not identical with the sort of calm you sometimes get when going fishing, which accounts for much of the popularity of this sport. Just to sit with the line in the water, not moving, not really thinking about anything, not really caring about anything either, seems to draw out the inner tensions and frustrations that have prevented you from solving problems you couldn’t solve before and introduced ugliness and clumsiness into your actions and thoughts. … You don’t have to go fishing, of course, to fix your motorcycle. A cup of coffee, a walk around the block, sometimes just putting off the job for five minutes of silence is enough. When you do you can almost feel yourself grow.” [Problem Solving Brain Moving Forward.] “toward that inner peace of mind that reveals it all.”
10) “So the thing to do when working on a motorcycle, as in any other task, is to cultivate the peace of mind which does not separate one’s self from one’s surroundings. When that is done successfully then everything else follows naturally. “ [Problem Solving Brain Moving Forward.] “Peace of mind produces right values, right values produce right thoughts. Right thoughts produce right actions and right actions produce work which will be a material reflection for others to see of the serenity at the center of it all. That was what it was about that wall in Korea. It was a material reflection of a spiritual reality.”
11) “You should remember that it’s peace of mind you’re after and not just a fixed machine.”
12) “ In my mind now is an image of a huge, long railroad train, one of those 120-boxcar jobs that cross the prairies all the time with lumber and vegetables going east and with automobiles and other manufactured goods going west. I want to call this railroad train "knowledge" and subdivide in into two parts: Classic Knowledge and Romantic Knowledge. ”
… “In terms of the analogy, Classic Knowledge, the knowledge taught by the Church of Reason, is the engine and all the boxcars. All of them and everything that’s in them. If you subdivide the train into parts you will find no Romantic Knowledge anywhere. And unless you’re careful it’s easy to make the presumption that’s all the train there is. This isn’t because Romantic Knowledge is nonexistent or even unimportant. It’s just that so far the definition of the train is static and purposeless. This was what I was trying to get at back in South Dakota when I talked about two whole dimensions of existence. It’s two whole ways of looking at the train. ”
… “Romantic Quality, in terms of this analogy, isn’t any "part" of the train. It’s the leading edge of the engine, “ [Problem Solving Brain Moving Forward.] “ a two-dimensional surface of no real significance unless you understand that the train isn’t a static entity at all. A train really isn’t a train if it can’t go anywhere. In the process of examining the train and subdividing it into parts we’ve inadvertently stopped it, so that it really isn’t a train we are examining. That’s why we get stuck. ”
… “The real train of knowledge isn’t a static entity that can be stopped and subdivided. It’s always going somewhere.” [Problem Solving Brain Moving Forward.] “ On a track called Quality. And that engine and all those 120 boxcars are never going anywhere except where the track of Quality takes them; and romantic Quality, the leading edge of the engine, takes them along that track. Romantic reality is the cutting edge of experience.” [Problem Solving Brain Moving Forward.] “It’s the leading edge of the train of knowledge that keeps the whole train on the track. Traditional knowledge is only the collective memory of where that leading edge has been. At the leading edge there are no subjects, no objects, only the track of Quality ahead, .” [Problem Solving Brain Moving Forward.] “ and if you have no formal way of evaluating, no way of acknowledging this Quality, then the entire train has no way of knowing where to go. You don’t have pure reason—you have pure confusion. . The leading edge is where absolutely all the action is. The leading edge contains all the infinite possibilities of the future. It contains all the history of the past. Where else could they be contained? ”
“The past cannot remember the past. The future can’t generate the future. The cutting edge of this instant right here and now .” [Problem Solving Brain Moving Forward.>] “ is always nothing less than the totality of everything there is “ .
“Value, the leading edge of reality, .” [Problem Solving Brain Moving Forward.>] “ is no longer an irrelevant offshoot of structure. Value is the predecessor of structure. It’s the preintellectual awareness that gives rise to it. Our structured reality is preselected on the basis of value, and really to understand structured reality requires an understanding of the value source from which it’s derived. ”
“One’s rational understanding of a motorcycle is therefore modified from minute to minute as one works on it and sees that a new and different rational understanding has more Quality. .” [Problem Solving Brain Moving Forward.>] “ One doesn’t cling to old sticky ideas because one has an immediate rational basis for rejecting them. Reality isn’t static anymore. It’s not a set of ideas you have to either fight or resign yourself to. It’s made up, in part, of ideas that are expected to grow as you grow, and as we all grow, century after century. With Quality as a central undefined term, reality is, in its essential nature, not static but dynamic. .” [Problem Solving Brain Moving Forward.>] “ And when you really understand dynamic reality you never get stuck. It has forms but the forms are capable of change.”
13) “It Was The 2,400-Year-Old Tao Te Ching of Lao Tzu. “
… “He began to read through the lines he had read many times before, but this time he studied it to see if a certain substitution would work. He began to read and interpret it at the same time. “
“He read: “ “The quality that can be defined is not the Absolute Quality. “
“Phædrus read on through line after line, verse after verse of this, watched them match, fit, slip into place. Exactly. This was what he meant. This was what he’d been saying all along, only poorly, mechanistically. There was nothing vague or inexact about this book. It was as precise and definite as it could be. It was what he had been saying, only in a different language with different roots and origins. He was from another valley seeing what was in this valley, not now as a story told by strangers but as a part of the valley he was from. He was seeing it all. “
ATTENTION: IMPORTANT TO NOTE: Above in 2) & 5), Mr. Pirsig says => “Your Mind Will Naturally And Freely Move Toward A Solution.”
APPENDIX XI: QUIT & WAIT !!
A) The “Quit & Wait”, In The Literature On Problem Solving, Is Known As “Incubation”: Wikipedia Says The Creative Problem Solving Steps Are => Preparation, Incubation, Illumination, And Verification. As In This Passage=>
B) Some VERY Interesting & Valuable History, In Wikipedia Page About Jacqies Hadamard, In Section Titled => “On Creativity”. In his book “Psychology of Invention in the Mathematical Field. “
So There You Have It: These Above Experts Confirm Henry Gurr’s Saying ~28 Times (In This WebPage) “The Importance Of => ‘QUIT & WAIT’.
HERE IT IS IMPORTANT TO NOTE => Mr. PIRSIG HAS HIS OWN VERSIONS OF QUIT & WAIT:
… As stated above => This “Quit & Wait” is of course, entirely consistent with Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”. … AND as a net result of the Problem Solving Brain’s good Optimal (Best or Near Best) Brain Solutions & Quality Actions, is Robert Pirsig’s => “What you are after … Peace of Mind!” APPENDIX XII: A Discussion Of Henry Gurr’s OWN Observations
** Footnote: Dr. Fuller and members of the University of Nebraska at Lincoln ADAPT team conducted a workshop on our USCA Campus titled: “Logical Thought & Reasoning: A Piaget Model.”
A Summary Taken From Henry Gurr’s WebPage => “THE AHA IN TEACHING & TUTORING,” Which Describes => “Discover And Resolve Tutoring.” (DART)
NOTE: The Ideas And Conclusions Stated In This Document You Are Currently Reading, Are True To My Own (Henry Gurr) Direct Experience. And I Believe They Are True To The Mental Workings Of Most Other Persons, And Those Corroborated By The Literature.
But Additionally, As Fully Discussed In This Document, The Flash Of Insight (And Similar Mental Arrivals), Are Seen To Be A Quite Valuable Research Tool (And Probe), Into The Workings Of Our Own Mind!
… A) Book =>, “Phenomenology Of Perception.” (French: Phénoménologie de la perception. ).
… B) Extended Excerpts From Stanford Encyclopedia Of Philosophy/ =>
The Following Are Selection Of Excerpts Relevant To Henry Gurr’s Theory.
' a sensible that is about to be sensed poses to my body a sort of confused problem … I must find the attitude that will provide it with the means to become determinate … I must find the response to a poorly formulated question. And yet I only do this in response to its solicitation… . The sensible gives back to me what I had lent to it, but I received it from the sensible in the first place.' (PP: 259/222)
… “the agent of perception is the pre-reflective and anonymous subjectivity of the body, which remains enmeshed in and “connatural” with the world that it perceives.
… The senses are unified without losing their distinctness in a fashion comparable to the binocular synthesis of vision, .[<= YES ]
that is neither “spatialized” (as a pre-given container in which things are arranged) nor “spatializing” (like the homogenous and interchangeable relations of geometrical space).” … “Rejecting classic approaches to time that treat it either as an objective property of things, as a psychological content, or as the product of transcendental consciousness, Merleau-Ponty return to the “field of presence” as our foundational experience of time. This field is a network of intentional relations, of “protentions” and “retentions”, in a single movement of dehiscence or self-differentiation, such that “each present reaffirms the presence of the entire past that it drives away, and anticipates the presence of the entire future or the ‘to-come ” (PP: 483/444)”.
… “Merleau-Ponty rejects the empiricist understanding of sensation, with its correlative “constancy hypothesis”, and the role empiricism grants to association and the projection of memory for treating the basic units of sensation as determinate atoms rather than as meaningful wholes. These wholes include ambiguities, indeterminacies, and contextual relations that defy explanation in terms of the causal action of determinate things. Intellectualism aims to provide an alternative to empiricism by introducing judgment or attention as mental activities that synthesize experience from the sensory givens,” … “Merleau-Ponty played a central role in the dissemination of phenomenology, which he sought to integrate with Gestalt psychology, psychoanalysis, Marxism, and Saussurian linguistics. Major influences on his thinking include Henri Bergson, Edmund Husserl, Martin Heidegger, Max Scheler, and Jean-Paul Sartre, as well as neurologist Kurt Goldstein, Gestalt theorists such as Wolfgang Köhler and Kurt Koffka, and literary figures including ... " … “the second area of focus in this early study. The Gestalt is “a spontaneous organization of the sensory field” in which there are “only organizations, more or less stable, more or less articulated” (NP: 193/79).
… Merleau-Ponty’s brief summary of Gestalt psychology, anticipating research presented in his first two books, emphasizes the figure-ground structure of perception, the phenomena of depth and movement, and the syncretic perception [a union or attempted fusion] of children. Nevertheless, Merleau-Ponty concludes—again citing Gurwitsch—that the epistemological framework of Gestalt psychology remains Kantian, requiring that one look “in a very different direction, for a very different solution” to the problem of the relation between the world described naturalistically and the world as perceived (NP: 198/82). Merleau-Ponty’s first book, "The Structure of Behavior" (SC), resumes the project of synthesizing and reworking the insights of Gestalt theory and phenomenology to propose an original understanding of the relationship between “consciousness” and “nature”. ...... Merleau-Ponty argues that ..... organic life and human consciousness are emergent from a natural world that is not reducible to its meaning for a mind; yet this natural world is not the causal nexus of pre-existing objective realities, since it is fundamentally composed of nested Gestalts, spontaneously emerging structures of organization at multiple levels and degrees of integration .
a) Biological Neural Networks form a very powerful computational mechanism, which can create an unsophisticated brute force, all purpose, general problem-solving biological device, that gets Optimal (Best or Near Best) Problem Solutions by massive parallel processing and massive in-depth memory! This mechanism, in other words, is a crude but effective, one size fits all, quite powerful sledge hammer. (These are the powerful consequences of what here in is called ‘‘ “Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory. ” '', which in turn is a VERY important italicized 11 word name & idea, as emphasized in this paragraph, and the next 3 paragraphs below.) .
b) Constitute a general problem-solving mechanisms, where we can see the possibility that => The Neural Networks actions are integrated, holistic, SPONTANEOUSLY self-built, self-organized, UN-supervised, follows its own rules, and runs fully on-automatic: The only apparent non-self (internal) control, seemingly comes from the sensory organs, external and internal.
c) As Is Required For ANY Theory (Explanation) of How Out (Biological Based) Mind Works => Such Neural Networks and their spontaneous actions must be and are, compatible with biological evolutionary development (phylogeny), from the very beginning of moving animals on earth.
d) Also Such Neural Networks and their spontaneous actions must be and are, compatible with biological growth and development (ontogeny), of a single organism from gestation to adult. )) ..
On the one hand, the idealist critique of naturalism should be extended to the naturalistic assumptions framing Gestalt theory. On the other hand, there is a justified truth in naturalism that limits the idealist universalization of consciousness, and this is discovered when Gestalt structures are recognized to be ontologically basic and the limitations of consciousness are thereby exposed. The notion of “behavior”, taken by Merleau-Ponty as parallel to the phenomenological concept of “experience” (in explicit contrast with the American school of behaviorism), is a privileged starting point for the analysis thanks to its neutrality with respect to classical distinctions between the “mental” and the “physiological” (SC: 2/4). The [Merleau-Ponty's book] "Structure of Behavior" first critiques traditional reflex accounts of the relation between stimulus and reaction in light of the findings of Kurt Goldstein and other contemporary physiologists, arguing that the organism is not passive but imposes its own conditions between the given stimulus and the expected response, so that behavior remains inexplicable in purely anatomical or atomistic terms . .
… Merleau-Ponty instead describes the nervous system as a “field of forces” apportioned according to “modes of preferred distribution”, a model inspired by Wolfgang Köhler’s Gestalt physics (SC: 48/46). Both physiology and behavior are “forms”, that is, total processes whose properties are not the sum of those which the isolated parts would possess…. [T]here is form wherever the properties of a system are modified by every change brought about in a single one of its parts and, on the contrary, are conserved when they all change while maintaining the same relationship among themselves. (SC: 49–50/47) Form or structure therefore describes dialectical, non-linear, and dynamic relationships that can function relatively autonomously and are irreducible to linear mechanical causality (see Thompson 2007). ..
… “At the level of life, form is characterized by a dialectical relation between the organism and its environment that is a function of the organism’s vital norms, its “optimal conditions of activity
and its proper manner of realizing equilibrium”, which express its style or “general attitude toward the world” ... " END Excerpts from =>
Excerpts From Wikipedia Give More Information => Phenomenology of Perception “(French: Phénoménologie de la perception ) is a 1945 book about perception by the French philosopher Maurice Merleau-Ponty, in which the author expounds his thesis of "the primacy of perception". The work established Merleau-Ponty as the pre-eminent philosopher of the body, and is considered a major statement of French existentialism.”
Excerpts From Wikipedia Give More Information =>
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib. APPENDIX XIV: SPECIAL-NOTES, DETAILS, QUALIFICATIONS, and LIMITATIONS Re This Document Concerning => Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” , Presented On The Page You Are Reading Right Now. … Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
… BUT Note Well => These Mental Arrivals ONLY Happen If These Are Problem Solving Brain’s Solutions, Which Are BEST or NEAR BEST, Or OPTIMAL, Or OF MAXIMAL COHERENCE: … Since This Above Sentence May Unclear => Here Are Some Meanings For The Above “BEST” => 1) The Word “BEST” In This Document You Are Currently Reading, Means What Is Stated In Most Dictionaries, and well corresponds to the usage of Robert Pirsig in his book “Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance”.
2) And the reader who knows English Language, will (from the context of the discussion of This Document), correctly understand our intended meaning, of the word “BEST”.
3) However, ANY word ALWAYS depends on context, and thus when the readers sees the word “BEST”, they should always substitute => “Optimal (Best or Near Best) Solution Brain To The Problem Of How To Respond With” =>
a) The Most Benefit (Most Coherence), To The Person’s Second By Second Sensory Input From The Given Local Surrounding Environment, and as well
b) Given The Person’s Limited Information And Past Experience.
4) Elsewhere in This Document it is stated that our Problem Solving Brain Makes => “Meaning” … “It’s Just There”! … “You Just See It!” …”You Just Know” There Is An Automatic Presence Of => “Clarity, Understanding, AND Meaning” Similarly this is how we know “Best” AND 47 Other Related Synonym Words Click Here.
5) THUS => For & In This Document => A Definition for “Best” => At or Nearly Optimal, Nearly Maximum Coherence. Close To Good Solutions & Answers, where over approximately 95% of mental Arrivals are without MAJOR error or misdirection.
5) A Useful Acronym for BEST => Brain Effective Solution Top. ))
… And Of Course The Above Paragraphs, For Meaning Of “BEST’, Also Applies To The Meanings of => “OPTIMAL”, and/or “MAXIMAL COHERENCE”, As Used In This WebPage. Continued APPENDIX XIV: SPECIAL-NOTES, DETAILS, QUALIFICATIONS, and LIMITATIONS
A) As A Working Definition For “Best”, Of Course, Different Individuals Facing The Same Problem, Their Problem Solving Brain => Will Generate Different “Best Or Near Best”, Solutions, Based On The Circumstances Of Their Particular Life Trajectory, That Exist At That moment In Time. 6) Solutions, as Mental Arrivals into Consciousness for certain person, would rarely be objectively the most beneficial for => other persons, and/or other environments, and/or other time frames.
7) Thus in this discussion, “Best” cannot be universal, or any form of “truth”. “Best” thus means => What an individual can come up with, based on their mental resources (past experience, quality of logical process, etc), for their immediate local environment, and at a particular moment in time, and that which will result in the most progress towards that person’s wants [or goals], for the least cost. People tend to work with “acceptable” rather than “optimal” solutions, at the personal conscious level.
8) Thus We See1 => “BEST” Is A Practical Operative Word, and there can never be an absolute “best” Thus in this context => “Best” may be (more simply) taken as simply the evident good Solutions Results that the Problem Solving Brain “Comes-Up-With”, whether=> Thinking, physical, actions, emotions, feelings, etc …. Whatever our Darwinian Evolved Brain, would have us do.
9) Thus We See2 => “Best” Is A Subjective Term, And Also Depends On =>
a) What Qualifications Is “Best” Based On? Or
b) Rather that the above 1) thru 9), “Best” might just as well => Be Defined As “Most Desirable”? Or
c) Simply “Best For The Biological Operation of An Organism And Its Situation, irrespective of what it owner’s Mind thinks about this!
d) However, In Many Cases For A Person => This “Best” May Be Simply Be I) “Most Desirable”, Ii) “Most Pleasurable” Or Sometimes iii) “Most Beneficial => To That Person’s Overall Darwinian Reproductive Evolutionary Success” , Irrespective Of What Its Owner’s Mind (Or Anybody Else), Thinks About This!
e) As is observed, nearly all automatic spontaneous Mental Arrival Solutions => Are generally Immediate, Whole, Complete, Clear, Understandable, and Full Of Meaning, such as in Poetry or Metaphor:
…ii) In above Blue Link, you may learn more by > Top > Edit > Find > metaphor . Especially study hits, 4, 15, 16, 19, & 24 thru 28.
… … …
Continued APPENDIX XIV: SPECIAL-NOTES, DETAILS, QUALIFICATIONS, and LIMITATIONS
HOWEVER => In Order For These Best Or Near Best Solutions To Be Generally FREE Of MAJOR FAILURES, MISDIRECTION OR SERIOUS ERROR =>
2) This Whole Arena Of Human Mental Disorder, Of Course, Has Had Considerable Study And Literature, An Entry Into Which Is Indicated In The Following Links. Wikipedia, for example lists some 240 major classified forms of mental illness, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mental_disorders
An Especially Excellent, Compact, Highly Recommended, Overview of the Current Research Status of Brain Science, Which Comes Out In This Wikipedia Full Discussion of Consciousness, Is Here.
Here You Should Pause To Notice: A Major Human Mental Disorder, Is Failure To Have “Normal” Consciousness, As Indicated By => The above words => Delirium, Delusion, Amnesia, etc. and
The below words => Sleep-Walking, Automatismm, Fugue State, Driving a car with no awareness, etc.
… NOTE Still to be completed, is a study of just how Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”, might contribute to the understanding of human mental disorders or other abnormal human mental functioning. Continued APPENDIX XIV: SPECIAL-NOTES, DETAILS, QUALIFICATIONS, and LIMITATIONS
… 1) When A Person In One Of These Above C) Mentioned UN-Conscious Conditions, They Still Can Accomplish Large Ranges Of Sensible Coordinated Appropriate, Functional Body Motions, And Portions Of Normal Appearing Behaviour.
… 2) Here We Should Immediately See That These “Zombie-Like” “UN-Aware, UN-Conscious, Behavior Functionings”, Have Properties In Common With Our NORMAL “Awake, Fully Conscious Mental State & Accompanying Behavior Patterns, As Commonly Understood By Ourselves And The Persons & Our Society Around Us. a) We all just might be in one of these UN-Aware & UN-Conscious, mental states, including Zombie, except for we have, awake clear awareness of Primary Conscious, plus various sudden, automatic, spontaneous, Mental Arrivals into our Conscious Mind: AND to prove our “awake clear awareness”, we can answer questions about our state of consciousness, and report remembered actions & thoughts, for several minutes earlier. “
b) AND Please understand very well => Sometimes, in our normal living, for relatively long portions of time, we are in fact, relatively UN-Conscious, because of simple lack of attention: For example =>
i) Driving a car at night when essentially “on automatic”, wherein we are not much aware of anything around or what is happening, or b) We really are concentrating and working hard at a certain task, but are “so-into-the-work”, that we are hardly aware we are doing it, or surroundings!! OR c) Periods of time when you are relaxing and not thinking of much at all.
ii) In very amazing abilities like a), b), & c), we will remain relatively UN-Conscious, ~ EXCEPT for when we come OUT of UN-Conscious, by the marvelous grace of Primary Consciousness (or Other Mental Arrivals), which are the ONLY WAY we know there MUST HAVE BEEN living unawares & mostly UN-Consciously!
iii) This “living unawares & mostly UN-Consciously”, is very similar to => The fact that we are nearly totally un-aware of our Problem Solving Brain Processes, running in our life at ALL times, with minimal clue of its presence:
iv) This is to be accepted, because as is stated elsewhere in This Document You Are Currently Reading =>
… NOTE: There are important functional reasons why we are totally un-aware of our UN-Conscious brain processes. Click here to go to Henry Gurr’s APPENDIX VII => Why Is It Necessary For The Workings Of Our Mind To Be Hidden From Us? … 3) CONCLUSIONS => => From The Above, And Other Observations, It Happens Lots Of Times That => Coordinated Seemingly Purposeful, Body Actions, Can Be Completed, Without Its Owner Being Alert Or Aware, And Having Some Degree Of Consciousness.
… 4) The Following Are Other Cases, Where There IS Functioning Of Consciousness, But No Memory Is Created, JUST AS IF The Person Was UN-Aware & UN-Conscious, Such as => a) Dementia, including Alzheimer’s “Dementia is a broad category of brain diseases that cause a long-term and often gradual decrease in the ability to think and remember that is great enough to affect a person's daily functioning.[Other common symptoms include emotional problems, difficulties with language, and a decrease in motivation. A person's consciousness is usually not affected. A dementia diagnosis requires a change from a person's usual mental functioning and a greater decline than one would expect due to aging. These diseases also have a significant effect on a person's caregivers.] .. The most common type of dementia is Alzheimer's disease,
b)dissociative fugue Dissociative fugue, formerly fugue state or psychogenic fugue, is a dissociative disorder and a rare psychiatric disorder characterized by reversible amnesia for personal identity, including the memories, personality, and other identifying characteristics of individuality. The state can last days, months or longer. Dissociative fugue usually involves unplanned travel or wandering, and is sometimes accompanied by the establishment of a new identity.
c) Similar to Alzheimer’s & Fugue State, there are other (somewhat) abnormal mental states, when memory may not be adequately formed: These may include => Hallucination, spurious non-real vision, false hearing of voices, dreaming, day-dreaming, reminisce, reverie, so called “lost is space”, even driving a car for long distance but no memory of it, medium to severe dementia.
… In other words => Our a) “normal” mental states, and above listed b) “abnormal states”, in have characteristics in common.
Continued APPENDIX XIV: SPECIAL-NOTES, DETAILS, QUALIFICATIONS, and LIMITATIONS
The above words => Delirium, Delusion, Amnesia, etc. and
The continued above words => Sleep-Walking, Automatismm, Fugue State, Driving a car with no awareness, etc.
… 1) From Your Reading Of The Above Section “C) Concerning Coordinated Behaviour While …. You Should Realize That What We Call Consciousness, Isn’t Always There.
… The fact that various levels of awareness happen & “Consciousness Can Readily “Come & Go” => Likely is because sometimes we really don’t need it. And
Darwin Evolution wise, the Consciousness System in animals, and most especially in humans, is a “Johnny-Come-Lately” facility, and by the evidence a relatively undeveloped & weak system.
Continued APPENDIX XIV: SPECIAL-NOTES, DETAILS, QUALIFICATIONS, and LIMITATIONS Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
D) It Is Totally Amazing How Good Our Brains Do In Fact Work, Most Of The Time!
Continued APPENDIX XIV: SPECIAL-NOTES, DETAILS, QUALIFICATIONS, and LIMITATIONS Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
E) Despite The Successes Of Above, There Are MAJOR Failures: We Observe, Some 2-5% Of The Time, Brain Solutions Do Have Serious Errors, Confusions, & Mis-Directions, Or Are Just Plain Wrong. Thus also, in this discussion, it should be taken all along that such major errors exist, must be recognized for what they are, with efforts to minimize them, and/or reduce their consequences. ' THE FOLLOWING DISCUSS HOW PEOPLE OFTEN “GO WRONG” AND THUS POINT TO LIMITATIONS TO => Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation of How Our Mind Works” '' 1) Professor Derek Zelmer Adds This: “We all are aware of solutions (ideas or conclusions), in other persons that are not logical to us, because their logic circuits worked differently. And we have all seen a person’s bad solutions based on spurious facts: Garbage in and garbage out. The first thing someone reading this ( Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”, ) is going to think about, are all of the awful solutions (ideas, conclusions), that they have seen from themselves and others, and thus immediately reject & dismiss (Henry Gurr’s Theory Explanation) propositions. ” One thing we often don’t realize, is that we tend to notice “the bad” much more often than “the good”. When all is running smoothly nobody much appreciates or notices it, but that one grinding gear gains an awful lot of attention.
2) Physicist David Bohm, In His Book Thought As System, At Length Points Out How Persons & Society, System-Wise, Systematically Are Involved In Vastly Counterproductive Behavior. Bohm points to built-in mutually opposing forces, motives, frameworks that block each other, to the point neither wins, and these festering problems remain!. All this clearly is created by the brains of persons involved, despite, the Best (or near Best) Solutions as stated by Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”. ! Thus there is considerably more to this story, and it is the purpose of Bohm’s book to find ways abound these evident problems and impasses.
3) Concerning Human Error, See Also =>
a) Book “The March of Folly: From Troy to Vietnam” a book by Barbara W. Tuchman, an American historian and author.
b) The Center for Inquiry focuses on two primary subject areas [relevant here is]: Investigation of Paranormal and Fringe Science Claims through the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry.
c) Book Steps to an Ecology of Mind a collection of Gregory Bateson's short works over his long and varied career. (1972 republished 2000) is insightful discussion of all manner of human aberrant behavior, such as alcoholics, schizophrenics, and his “Culture Contact and Schismogenesis”. These are summarized in link below => Part II: Form and Pattern in Anthropology AND Part III: Form and Pathology in Relationship
Continued APPENDIX XIV: SPECIAL-NOTES, DETAILS, QUALIFICATIONS, and LIMITATIONS:
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
A) Over 95 Percent Of The Time, Our Brain Very Quickly, Yields A Valid Problem Solution, Which Is A Single, Near Optimum, Holistic, Over-All, Solutions (i.e. best or near best answers), to life’s problems coming at us: Trustworthy, good solutions (answers), quick reliable recognition of danger, followed by optimum body motion response) most of the time: That’s a tall order, but one that we moment by moment, see all around us!!
B) By Contrast, There Is The Less Than 5 Percent Of The Time, Our Mental Arrivals Can Be: Confused, Scrambled Ideas, Messed Up-Thinking, Hay-Wire-Brain, Balled-Up-Mind, Etc: Such errors in our thinking must be recognized for what they are, with efforts to minimize them. For more on this subject of Errors, please scroll to near top at => **SPECIAL-NOTES, DETAILS, QUALIFICATIONS, and LIMITATIONS. This topic will be additionally expanded asap: Send email if you want to know more.
Not Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Some persons may seriously doubt Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”, and say that => “Brains and human bodies are so very, very, complex, with many, many, individual parts, each of which is unbelievably complex. THUS => For our brains, these persons say => Tthere just can NOT be “An optimal, “only-one-at-a-time”, best or near best answer / solution.” “And from this it follows that” => “There can NOT be such a Fundamental Criterion For Brain Operation.” A) REPLY1: Yes indeed the Bodies & Brains of Humans and Animals are Highly Complex!!
a) This Brain’s Single Solution (~”only-one-at-a-time”), is a direct inescapable corollary to a condition a Mathematical Maximum (i.e. Optimum) =>
b) And from this we clearly see in this case => Best (Near Best, Optimum) Solution, must be taken as The Fundamental Criterion For Brain Operation. AND
c) As stated above => The fact that this is exactly what observed, most of the time gives very strong support for the veracity of => Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” => .
AND THIS OVERALL EXPLAINS HOW => Irrespective of The Brain’s Massively Intervolved Intricate neuron structure we actually see => Single Condition Of Best (or near Best), AND This Can Be Sole Determinant In The Generation Of A Mental Arrive Into Our Consciousness. Please see additional discussion at Top > Edit > Find quick "single minded" .
B) REPLY2: From Complexity Science, The Concept called Emergent Properties, Explains How => Irrespective of The Brain’s Massively Intervolved Intricate neuron Structure,
DISCUSSION & A HELPFUL ANALOGY => It Is Not Necessary To Understand “The Insides” Of a Complex System, In Order To Efficiently Operate It! Examples include => Computer, Automobile, Your Body OR Even Your Own Brain!! And even if you could learn about & understand, “The Insides”, likely would be needless waste of time, or even cause brain overload:
Not Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
D) The Following Rather Long Excerpts, Concerning Emergence Should Make These Exceedingly Important Ideas Clear.
E) In Support Of This REPLY2, Wikipedia Excerpts Say This About Emergence [<< Note Last 5 Letters “gence”.]
(1) radical novelty (features not previously observed in systems);
(2) coherence or correlation (meaning integrated wholes that maintain themselves over some period of time);
(3) a global or macro "level" (i.e. there is some property of "wholeness");
(4) it is the product of a dynamical process (it evolves); and
(5) it is "ostensive" (it can be perceived).”
… ”Peter Corning suggests a narrower definition, requiring that the components be unlike in kind (following Lewes), and that they involve division of labor between these components. He also says that living systems (like the game of chess), while emergent, cannot be reduced to underlying laws of emergence: [Corning says => ] ”Rules, or laws, have no causal efficacy; they do not in fact “generate” anything. They serve merely to describe regularities and consistent relationships in nature. These patterns may be very illuminating and important, but the underlying causal agencies must be separately specified (though often they are not). But that aside, the game of chess illustrates ... why any laws or rules of emergence and evolution are insufficient. Even in a chess game, you cannot use the rules to predict “history” – i.e., the course of any given game. Indeed, you cannot even reliably predict the next move in a chess game. Why? Because the “system” involves more than the rules of the game. It also includes the players and their unfolding, moment-by-moment decisions among a very large number of available options at each choice point. The game of chess is inescapably historical, even though it is also constrained and shaped by a set of rules, not to mention the laws of physics. Moreover, and this is a key point, the game of chess is also shaped by teleonomic, cybernetic, feedback-driven influences. It is not simply a self-ordered process; it involves an organized, “purposeful” activity.”
F) “Viability Of Strong Emergence. [Wikipedia Article Continues => ]
“Although strong emergence is logically possible, it is uncomfortably like magic. How does an irreducible but supervenient downward causal power arise, since by definition it cannot be due to the aggregation of the micro-level potentialities? Such causal powers would be quite unlike anything within our scientific ken. This not only indicates how they will discomfort reasonable forms of materialism. Their mysteriousness will only heighten the traditional worry that emergence entails illegitimately getting something from nothing. “
… END Wikipedia: Emergence In Support of the above => Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (SEP) contributes these excerpts Concerning Emergent Properties of Complex System. =>
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
I) EMERGENCE CONCLUSION => What Is Displayed By On Your Computer Screen, Does NOT Come From Your Computers Complex System, Or The Several Computers That Operate (Or Serve Data On) The Internet. NOR Does It Does It Come From Your Complex Body & Brain, Physical Components, But Practically Entirely Depends On Emergent Mental Arrivals Into Your (And My) Conscious Actions, Arising From Our Respective Problem Solving Brains! J) CONSEQUENTLY: =>This Understanding Of Emergence, Leaves Us (Living Here At This Top Level Of Consciousness), At Liberty, To Carefully Observe The Systematics Of These Mental Arrival Solutions, To Organize What Is Seen (Observations & Data), Make Sense Of The Observations, Think Carefully What These Arrivals Mean, And Construct An Overall Understanding, Into A Theory (Explanation) Of How Our Mind Works => Which Other Persons Can Study, Such As You Dear Reader Are Doing Now! K) THUS WE SHOULD => a) From our observations, Construct A Clear, Well Organized, Compact, Summary Of Our Observations Of What Has Happened To Us In This World. And from this
b) Construct a very practical and useful Theory of How Our Mind Works. And thus
c) Provide an accurate & reliable guide, to get done efficiently, what we want to do.
d) And THUS from this viewpoint => This whole document, you are reading now, is effectively “A Brain Owners User’s Manual” l!
e) Yes, of course Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”, is yes indeed, A Theory, but a prime characteristics of a Good Theory, is that it is an accurate, practical guide, to efficient action, in a complex and uncertain world!
Here see Henry Gurr’s FIRST Brain Owner User’s Manual Here see Henry Gurr SECOND Brain Owner User’s Manual ' L) In Other Words, Consistent With EMERGENCE, REPLY3 => The Construction Of Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”, And Its Applicability To Human Affairs (For Most Practical Purposes) => a) Should NOT and Is NOT much limited by the facts that => Brains and Human Bodies of Humans (& Animals) are so very, very, complex, with many, many, individual parts, each of which is unbelievably complex.!!
b) AND from the above we can see that Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”, just as well may be considered to be => A General Theory of Conscious Mind, as An Emergent Phenomenon, or brains of Humans & Animals!
END REPLY3 M) REPLY4: No Matter How You Slice It “Best Is STILL Best”!!
1) An overall global optimum Mental Arrival Solution, which has => A Largest Total Mental Solution Fitness .
2) And even IF the sub-sub-parts are considered individually, Each sub-sub-part can have an optimum fitness of it’s own, AND
3) When all of these finesses are combined, no matter what way, this will STILL “add up to” an overall Single Optimum Fitness => Which Is In-Total, A ~Greatest Total Mental Solution Fitness.
END APPENDIX XVI INSERT Re => A Computer Analogy Example, In Turn Can (“By Analogy”), Be Applied To The Actions Of Brains And Human Bodies. This Analogy Was Used To Explain “Emergence:
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
1) The Combined Atoms Of, A Physical Material System, Will Spontaneously Go To Lowest Energy, A Physical System Naturally Goes To Lowest Energy (Examples: Chemical reaction goes to completion. A fire will burn up all the wood.)
In other words => Many, many, atoms dynamically interacting as is known in material objects, will spontaneously go to a single state of lowest energy, which is recognized as a stable end product.
2) The Combined Neurons Of, A Brain System, Will Spontaneously Go To Single Optimum (Best or Near Best) Problem Solution Of Greatest Mental Coherence. => A Physical Brain Going To ~Greatest Total Mental Solution Fitness, where =>
Many, many, neurons, dynamically interacting as is known for the brain, will spontaneously go to a single stable neuronal network brain state, which in actual practice is to be identified as the mental state of greatest mental Quality or Overall Mental Coherence.
In other words the many neurons of the brain will spontaneously go to stable state of Problem Solution which is the best of near best answer, for the situation at hand, such as real world body action , or perception of what is out there.
3) SUMMARY & NOTE WELL => a) Consider the total energy of any physical material system, composed of atoms. => Irrespective of complexity, or how inter-weaved parts are assembled, there is still an overall Total Combined Global System Energy. AND as a Fundamental Physical Principle => For ANY physical material system, this Total Combined Global System Energy, will spontaneously slide to Minimum, given the means to do so! This is essentially equivalent to the Second Law of Thermodynamics, which states that the entropy of any isolated system always increases.
b) Consider the total coherence of any physical brain system, composed of neurons => Irrespective of complexity, or how inter-weaved parts are assembled, there is still an overall Total Combined Global System Coherence. AND as a Fundamental Physical Principle => For ANY physical neuron brain system, this Total Combined Global System Coherence, will spontaneously slide to Maximum, given the means to do so! This in essence might possibly be considered equivalent to a Second Law of Thermodynamics, for brains, which might possibly say that the ~”brain neuron interactive entropy” of any isolated brain neuron network system always increases.
A SUMMARY CAPSULE => : a) A Spontaneous Slide To Minimum Physical Atomic System Total Energy …
b) A Spontaneous Slide To Greatest Physical Brain Network of Neurons, Total Mental Coherence . i.e. Total Mental Solution Goodness of Fit to the situation at hand.
… The above SUMMARY & NOTE WELL + CAPSULE, are in full agreement with the theory established by => The Princeton Theoretical Physicist J. J Hopfield Physics Based Neural Network Model, With A Quite General Mathematical Proof, Shows Just How A Real, Physical Collection Of Interconnected Neurons, Spontaneously, Following Its Own Internal Quality Criterion, Might Truly And Reliably Be Able To Find Such “Near Best” Solutions.
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
a) Despite our “Brains and human bodies are so very, very, complex, with many, many, individual parts, each of which is unbelievably complex.
b) There can YES can be a Fundamental Criterion For Brain Operation such as => “An optimal, single, “only-one-at-a-time”, best or near best answer / solution.”.
c) Indeed, as stated several times in This Document => The Brain’s Single Solution, is a direct inescapable corollary to a condition a Mathematical Maximum => Where by definition there can be ~”only-one-at-a-time”, both locally and absolutely.. AND indeed this is what is observed! This consideration (in addition to other observations, adds support & confirmation for => This Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”.
d) In addition, as multiple times stated elsewhere in This Document => Prof Hopfield has mathematically shown that a Single, “All At Once”, Optimal Solutions, To Complex Neural Network Input is indeed possible, indeed likely, for a biological brain.
And Remember => All This Is Due To => The Massive Power, And Massive Content, of Our => ‘‘ “Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory. ” '' . Not Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
Again Remember The Massive Power, And Massive Brain Memory Content, of Our “Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory.” AND We CAN Think => “The UN-Thinkable!!”
APPENDIX XVII: A Preliminary List of => Specialized Phrases Used In This Document You Are Currently Reading:
A) Herein …, are abbreviated as => “The learning-perception-memory cycle, a regenerative upward spiral of ever improved memory. ”
B) Best, Is The Single Fundamental Criterion, For Brain Operation, and thus fundamental for a “How Our Brain Works” theory foundation => Its THE WAY, and as a practical matter, the ONLY WAY for a brain to find solutions (answers ), is to seek Single Best (or near Best) responses to our second by second sensory input from its surrounding environment.
C) Optimal Fit Memory Solution. Mental Arrival Into Our Conscious Mind, Optimum Problem Solution, Weighted Fit To Memory.
D) This above C), Overall Constitutes An Arrival At A Consciously Aware Mental State Of Knowing.
E) Such automatic brain process, Henry Gurr’s Proto-Theory, identifies in PROPOSITION 5c) as => Our problem Solving Brain, Automatically, In Response To Our Sensory Inputs (9 Senses), Creates What Is Herein Called “Primary Consciousness”.
F) We will say that these “Problem Solutions, Suddenly Automatically Spontaneously Mentally Arrive into our Conscious Mind.”
G) All Problem Solutions (That Mentally Arrive into Consciousness, Automatically Include Future Plans (Intentions), Along With Body Physical Adjustments, In Preparation For Appropriate Body & Mental Action(s): As repeatedly emphasized in the Page You Are Currently Reading => Brain’s Memory has been built up from => A very long history of Past Successful Creative Problem Solution. This Provides A Creatively, Ever Improved, Basis, For Future Plans & Resultant Behaviour.
… Moreover, Each plan for future action, is effectively an Intention, since it includes attendant coordination of the physical motion to accomplish this, while being open to the ongoing input from the external environment. See Proposition 12a) & Proposition 16).
. H) These above G) Are An Automatic Consequence of our “Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory”.
I) AND Although It Is Unknown (Even Inexplicable), How Our Brain Does It => Be Sure To Notice Very Well =>
…In The Process Of Generating, Constructing, Creating, Right-Before-Our-Mind’s-Eye) These Optimal Problem Solutions => As Directly Observed => Automatically Our problem Solving Brain Generates => Clear, Whole, Understandable, MEANINGS, Which Then Immediately Mentally Arrive Into Our Consciousness, Along With Our Ongoing Experience Of Primary Consciousness.
… =>-In Other Words Our Problem Solving Brain Makes Meaning, Sense of Truth, Beauty, Recognition, Insight, Knowing, Comprehension, Sense of Clear Understanding, and Importance. And All This With Felt Certainty !
J) All Is Slide To Better & Better Partial Fit Problem Solution! (See 30 each > Edit > Find > … All Is Slide To Better & Better Partial Fit Problem Solution.
K) Highest or Near highest Total Mental Solution Fitness
L) After a Solution The Mind, Never Stays There. It’s Always Moving To Better & Better!
M) Navigation Suggestions => Once You ARE AT THE START Of The PROPOSITIONS 1 thru 23, On The Page You Are Currently Reading =>
… Here Are Some Navigation Suggestions => For Quick Movement Between The Various PROPOSITIONS Of The Page You Are Currently Reading => a) To quickly move from one PROPOSITION to the Next > Do > Edit > Find > … PROPOSITION … (This can usually be done by pressing the keyboard combination Ctrl + F (or) Edit + F depending on what your computer’s keys say.)
b) To Return To Where You Were => Click The Back Arrow, perhaps several times, Usually In The Upper Left Of Your Browser,
c) To get back-to some earlier reading place, do b) above, perhaps nineteen times! When Ready => Click Here => To Go Directly To first of THE PROPOSITIONS.
Dear Reader => If you happen to notice => Other Phrases That Need Added To This Appendix XV ? Please send email! NOTE: As time passes, more will added here, from list saved into HSG ClpBdDump.doc APPENDIX XVIII: How The Books Of Poet, Linguist, & Philosopher Owen Barfield SUPPORTS The Discussion Of =>
… NOW: FOUR INTRODUCTIONS TO OWEN BARFIELD, Which You Will See At A), B), C), D), Below. AND As You Read, Please Especially Note Barfield’s =>“Evolution of Consciousness” A) Information About Owen Barfield’s FIRST Book “History In English Words”. (1926)
1) In The BELOW Passage From Owen Barfield’s Book “History In English Words”, We Especially Notice These Phrase => “Workings Of Men's Minds” AND “Evolution Of Consciousness” : These Topics Are Barfield’s Lifetime Focus, In ALL His Book, Starting In ~1926, At Age 28. =>
a) '' “ a 'felt change of consciousness'”, as in this =>
b) “Thus, an introspective analysis of my experience obliges me to say that appreciation of poetry involves a 'felt change of consciousness'.”
c) “The phrase must be taken with some exactness. Appreciation takes place at the actual moment of change. ….”
d) “.. but the actual moment of the pleasure of appreciation depends upon something rarer and more transitory. It depends on the change itself.” . ]]
B) Information About Owen Barfield’s SECOND Book "Poetic Diction's". (1928) 1) From "Poetic Diction's". , A Forward by Howard Nemerov, Who In Turn, Was Twice Poet Laureate Consultant To The United States Library Of Congress. Saying =>
2) From Wesleyan University Press, Internet Book Seller’s Show Following Statement Re => Owen Barfield’s Book “Poetic Diction: A Study In Meaning.” , 2nd Edition => ” “First published in 1928, 'Poetic Diction: A study in Meaning' presents not merely a theory of poetic diction but also a theory of poetry and a theory of knowledge.
3) In Praise for Owen Barfield:
… 4) “Owen Barfield: The History Of Language And The Evolution Of Consciousness”. An Essay by Richard G Patterson. This Is A Longer But Very Good Essay By A Writer Who Very, Very, Well Understands Owen Barfield's Works, And Thus Provides A Good Introduction To Barfield:
The Remainder of this Appendix XVIII, Is Devoted To Further Explanation Of Owen Barfield’s Ideas, Especially Barfield’s Ability To See Into “The Workings Of Human Minds, In The Creation of Meaning” =>
C) Owen Barfield’s Book “History in English Words,” [is]-“a book published when he was only twenty eight years old. [Ever since]-Barfield has been committed to the faith that "Words may be made to disgorge the past that is bottled up inside them, as coal and wine, when we kindle or drink them, yield up their bottled sunshine" D) A Passage (Emphasizing “Meaning”), From Owen Barfield’s SECOND Book “Poetic Diction” (1929), In Preface to the Second Edition.
'1) In The Following Passage From “Poetic Diction” , Chapter II, Section 4, Especially Notice it’s NOT => The Workings Of Men's Minds , BUT In This Case The => The Workings Of Barfield's Mind! .But of course, all the while Barfield is helping us, as readers, to see into The Workings Of Our Own Mind!, '' especially as we are experiencing Poetry, one of Barfield’s main focus.
2) Continuing From Above Re Owen Barfield’s Book “Poetic Diction” , Please Especially Note Well => His Phrases That EACH Very Effectively Illustrate His Important Observations, Re => Each Is Necessarily A New Solution, Which Mentally Arrives Into Consciousness =>
a) “A 'felt change of consciousness”.
b) “Appreciation takes place at the actual moment of change”.
c) “But the actual moment of the pleasure of appreciation depends upon something rarer and more transitory. It depends on the change itself.“
d) “Kindled by the passage from one plane of consciousness to another.”
e) “It [the meaning] lives during that moment of transition and then dies”,
f) “and if it is to be repeated, some means must be found of renewing the transition itself. ''
g) It is the movement which is the apprehension of meaning and not the recognition of a codified relationship of a word to an overall linguistic system.
h) Language is the storehouse of imagination; it cannot continue to be itself without performing its function.
i) But its function is, to mediate transition from the un-individualized [the un-aware], … to the individualized human spirit,” [Which has suddenly, automatically, spontaneously, become aware.],
Even MORE Praise for Owen Barfield: So If you Dare! By Robert L. Holter 5.0 out of 5 stars
Perennial and Profound! by Daniel J. Smitherman 4.0 out of 5 stars
Owen Barfield's Book Poetic Diction Is Truly An Astonishing Experience & Realize How Far Ahead Of It's Time & STILL IS!!
Reviewed in the United States on February 1, 2018 …One who reads Poetic Diction from the vantage of this historical perspective is due for a truly astonishing experience!! Barfield seems to anticipate the intellectual history of the more than sixty years which separate his book from us. He has fully synthesized literary and cognitive theory. At a stroke he rejuvenated and educated the romanticism of the early 20th Century. He explains how imagination discovers truth and formulates it into valid conceptual structures. He fully realizes that such a formulation implies the building and changing of those structures and accounts for this with “Evolution Of Consciousness.”
NOTE1: You May Find A Link To ~3 Pages Additional Discussion Of Owen Barfield’s Book “Poetic Diction” > By > Edit > Find > …. Richard Patterson….. NOTE2: You May Read ~6 Pages Additional Discussion Of Owen Barfield’s Book “Poetic Diction” > By > Edit > Find > …. Bobby Mathern ….. SUMMARY: in Owen Barfield’s Writings, Altogether, We See Very Good Confirmation Of PROPOSITION 10d) The Human Problem Solving, Brain Is The Factual & Practical, Sole Basis For The Creative & Innovative Force Behind ALL SOCIAL--CULTURAL CREATIVITY & INNOVATION => Which Is discussed As Barfield’s ‘Evolution of Consciousness, Taken Up Various Places (From The Beginning) In APPENDIX XVIII HERE ENDS: APPENDIX’s I thru XVIII: Since Readers Of This Document => Now Understand => Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”, They Are Now Strongly Urged => Every Time Readers See Words Such As These => 1) “Perception” (or “Pattern Recognition” ) they should substitute => “Mental Arrival Into Our Conscious Mind, “Best” (or “Near Best” Optimum Problem Solution, Partial Fit Weighted Fit To Memory”. (Abbreviated => “Problem Solution Optimal Fit Memory”.
2) “ Brain’s Memory” they should substitute => “Biological Brain Neural Network Optimizing Problem Solving, Content Addressable, Associative Memory”.
3) “Faced with a Proglem or need an answer” => They should substitute => “Brain Solution To The Problem Of How To Respond With Most Benefit (Most Coherence), To The Person’s Second By Second Sensory Input From Their Given Local Surrounding Environment, Given The Person’s Limited Information & Past Experience” (Abbreviated => A Practical Optimal Solution )
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib.
A) The purpose of This Document you are currently reading is => To tell you of A Striking New Theory Of How Our Mind Works. It Is A Radically New Kind of Theory Of Mind and A New KIND of “Philosophy of Mind. Studying This Document will require you to read slowly, closely, & think a lot about, because there are so many new & very unfamiliar ideas.
B) Of course you should ALSO read => Other “Important Authors”, relevant published articles, which will have much added explanation, justification, and supportive data, plus references. Many of such published articles, are mentioned on This WebPage You Are Currently Reading: These articles indicate how much other ‘Important Authors’ agree with & support => Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”, and conversely.
C) Among these “Important Authors”, you may read many ideas & results which may seem to have merely tangential connection with This Proto-Theory. BUT =>
D) This Document You Are Currently Reading, Also Employs Many Specialized Multi-Word Phrases That Are Master Motif’s, For The Ideas & Concepts Herein: For reader convenience these are Summarized In APPENDIX XIII: Specialized Master Motif’s Phrases Used In This Document You Are Currently Reading.
NOTE: Steps For Finding Henry Gurr’s “Important Authors” => Do (7 each) > Do > Top > Edit > Find > Important Authors
Do (9 each) > Do > Top > Edit > Find > … For Further Reading ….
For Further Reading #1 => READERS SHOULD PERHAPS READ FIRST => A Much Shorter Introductory & Compact Explanation of Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”. Click Here. ((NOTE: This is the 2nd down Blue Link in Menu at Top Left. ))READERS SHOULD PERHAPS READ SECOND => Collected Properties & Characteristics All Mental Arrivals Such As Flash of Insight PLUS Picture Analogies of Before & After A Mental Arrival are also shown.. Click Here.
…… …… …..
Thesis Panorama HSG Contrib. For Further Reading #2 => On Topics Related To “How Our Mind Works”: WHICH ARE ON VARIOUS OF HENRY GURR PAGES, THAT ARE RELATED TO (OR EXTEND) => Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”. A) In the MAIN MENU AT TOP LEFT, You Will See Listed MANY Pages, Which Comprise Henry Gurr’s ZMMQ WebSite =>
B) Please Especially Notice => The TOP EIGHT MENU Listed Pages Which Are => Based On Direct Observation: Explanation Of Best Available Theory Of “How Our Mind Works:” by Henry Gurr, In Which You Can Study To Learn The Following =>
Page 1) HenryGurrYouTubeLecture => Based On Direct Observation, Learn “How Our Mind Works. ” A Description With Audience Participation In Mind Demonstrations. Plus Mention That Hopfield Neuron Network Model, Explains How Our Brain Can Automatically, Spontaneously Find, Best Or Near Best Solutions of "Life's Problems Coming At Us."
Page 2) Suggest You START Your Study Here => HGurrCompactExplanation Of => Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works”.
Then Suggest You CONTINUE NEXT Page Below =>
…From scattered places in Henry Gurr’s 8 WebPages (hereby listed) “How Our Mind Works” => Here collected into one WebPage, are the ALL of the Properties & Characteristics Of Every Mental Arrival: (These are such as “Flash Of Insight”, which come automatically, spontaneously, Into Our Conscious Mind, For Our Every Waking Moment, Second By Second:) On this WebPage are also => Picture Analogies of Before & After A Mental Arrival are also shown.
C) For Further Reading #3 => Please Be Aware That There Are => FOUR DIFFERENT “BRAIN OWNERS USERS MANUALS” by Henry Gurr.1) This whole document, you are reading now => Was Constructed to Be a very practical and useful Theory of How Our Mind Works And thus =>
a) Provide an accurate & reliable guide, to get done quickly & efficiently, what we want to do.
b) And (although not stated here on) from this viewpoint => The whole Page You Are Currently Reading, is thus effectively A Brain Owners User’s Manual.
The Next THREE “For Further Readings” Are ALSO “Brain Owners Users Manuals”. 2) My FIRST Brain Owners User’s Manual! Is Where You Can => Learn More About The Many, Many Examples of The Flash of Insights, as well Other Mental Arrivals.
3) My SECOND Brain Owners User’s Manual! Is A Continuation Where You Can Learn => More On How To See In-Action (& Thus Learn More) About Our How The Problem Solving Brain, Gives Us Clear Thinking, On Demand,
4) My THIRD (Somewhat) Brain Owners User’s Manual! Is Where You Can => Learn More About How The Problem Solving Brain, Gives Us Analogy, Metaphor, Allegory, Simile, Similarity, & Other Similar Sympathetic-Poetic Associatives (SPA):
After this WebPage comes up, please scroll down to => Relation of Poetry to Metaphor. Relation of :
D) For Further Reading #4 => More On How Our Mind => Achieves Perception, Pattern Recognition, Where Even A Pattern Partial Fit Problem Solution, Can Be Highly Useful, Plus FURTHER Discussion of How This In Turn Gives Us Analogy, Metaphor, Similarity, Etc.
E) For Further Reading #5 => Internet Resources That Are Related To (Or Have Support For), Henry Gurr’s Proto-Theory, Please Consult These TWO Supplemental Readings Re “The Study of Mind”. : F) For Further Reading #6 => Ed Cooley, A Computer Expert, Noted Elements Of Computer Programming Which Have Some Confluence With This Proto-Theory, And Has Written A Page About His Experiences. For Ed Cooley Discussion Click Here. G) FOR FURTHER READING # 7 => IMPORTANT AUTHORS, WHOSE WORKS ARE RELATED TO (OR EXTEND), HENRY GURR’S “PROTO-THEORY PANORAMA EXPLANATION OF HOW OUR MIND WORKS” =>
SIDE NOTE: You Can Easily Read Brief Selected Passages For Each Above (Or Below), Mentioned Author by > Top > Do > Edit > Find > … Each Name ... ( This can usually be done by pressing the keyboard combination Ctrl + F (or) Edit + F depending on what your computer’s keys say.) (Click The Back Arrow, perhaps several times, Usually In The Upper Left Of Your Browser, To Return To Where You Were.) 2) Considerable Insight Into How Our Mind Works, Will Be Found In The Books & Articles of Linguist Philosopher Poet Owen Barfield, :
A) Inspiration (Barfield’s name for Mental Arrival), and
B) “Evolution of Consciousness” (Barfield’s name for The History of Human Being’s Cultural Growth & Development, especially of Language And Intellectual Understanding.
The Mental Arrivals of feelings, Interplayed With Emotions, Are Well Illustrated By Owen Barfield, In His Book “Poetic Diction:” . Click Here To Go To => APPENDIX I: The role of the General Problem Solving Brain in Feelings & Emotions:
a) “Inspiration”, such as “Poetic Inspiration” , where other authors would say for example=> “Flash Of Insight **AHA**, Suddenly Realized, It Hit Me. Light-Bulb, Lightning Bolt, Bolt-From-The-Blue, Epiphany, It-Just-Dawned-On-Me” .
b) “Sensations” , which result in “Figuration” of “Things”, , where other authors would say for example “We felt the wind, and suddenly saw the Ghost” . …
… Where the Italicized Words in a) & b) above are of course called Mental Arrivals , as much discussed in [[#HsgProtoTh | => Henry Gurr’s “Proto-Theory Panorama Explanation Of How Our Mind Works” , Presented on the Page you are reading right now.
******** o0OOO0o ******** Space does not permit any more mentioning other, insights, revelations, and neat explanations, that come from HSG’s Theory Of How Our Mind Works Thesis Panorama.
If You Know of Good Books, Authors, Articles, or have other Suggestions/Observations, Etc, Please Feel Free To Contact Me, With Any Idea That Would Make My Abovementioned Ideas & Conclusions Better!!
If you would like to read about the Hopfield model, my page on the subject is here: http://venturearete.org/ResearchProjects/ProfessorGurr/Documents/JJHopfieldModelHumanBrainAsGenProbSolver Sincerely Henry Gurr.
Compose by Henry S Gurr ZMMQ SiteMaster.July10’18; RevJan22’18; RevMar29’19; MajorRevMay15thru30’19,MajorRevNov18 thru Jan03’22, AddedMajorRevs&FixsJun29’22 thru Jul09”22, FmSctNtsFxNov5-13’22, & Jan12-15’23, May 13-21’23, June 14’23, Sept 25’23, March 14’24. File = ZmmqMuRv16..FmPostdHsg04..DyerFx55...Fx28+EdtFx29+FxsFmC&pMa4+Attn+Rev1
|
Recent Changes (All) | Edit Sidebar | Wiki Help | Page History | Edit Page | Powered by PmWiki |