![]() "Quality is the parent, the source of all subjects and objects." - Robert Pirsig |
NOTICE This Page Is In Near Final Stage of Writing, BUT..A) Please Note => Mythical Spirit Being’s Names, on this page, are italicized.
Please email me (Click Contact Me Bottom this page), if you want me to hurry up and finish.
Henry Gurr ZMMQ SiteMaster 11 Pm, November 4, 2021 . The Ancient System of Original Participation: “What Was Really There”, & How To Achieve “A Correct Understanding”, Concerning The World of Ancient Myth. “First: You Need To Be Absolutely Convinced How HUGE Is This World Of Ancient Myth. You Can Just Google To Find Thousands, “Mythical Gods & Goddess ”!!
Second: From The Fact That This World Of Ancient Myth Is HUGE, You Should Be Able To Firmly Realize, Just How Important The World Of Ancient Myth, Was To Ancient Peoples.
Third: You Also Must See That For Ancient Peoples (As They Understood It In Their Own World View), Their “ Spirit Persona Beings ”, Were The Mind & Power & Motive & And The Willful Agent, Behind Absolutely Everything That Happened In Their World:
And This Was True For All History, For All Cultures, For All The People Of Global Earth, For All Human Before Say 300 Years Ago!
This Excerpt From a Wikipedia Link, Supports My Above “Forces of Nature” +“Actions Psychological, or Physiological” (Most Ancient Myth WebPages, Do Not Discuss These Issue.)
Using Imagination, Historical Records / Artifacts & Projecting From How Present Day People React, Especially Religious Practices
a) Ancient Romans would pray to that reddish nighttime object called “Mars” , to come be with them to bravely conduce fierce frenzy warfare battle successfully. Aries is the Ancient Greek equivalent.
b) Ancient Romans would pray to that beautiful white & pure nighttime object called “Venus” , to come be with them to create desire, conduct the nights sexual love-affair successfully. Aphrodite is the Ancient Greek equivalent.
c) Ancient Romans would pray to “Lucina (Juno)” , to come be with them to, conduct their Labor & Child Birth successfully. Wikipedia says => “The title lucina (from the Latin lux, lucis, "light") links both Juno and Diana to the light of the moon, the cycles of which were used to track female fertility as well as measure the duration of a pregnancy. Priests of Juno called her by the epithet Juno Covella on the new moon…. “Hera is the Ancient Greek equivalent, but also is guider for marriage and the life of women. See Wikipedia. .Also see “Eileithyia” '' in Wikipedia.
d) Ancient Greeks would pray to Zeus to protect the weak. protect my home, help me to be strong against my fears, help me to safeguard those within my walls, and do right by all I meet. … Zeus is the sky and thunder god in ancient Greek religion, who rules as king of the gods of Mount Olympus, the highest mountain in Greece. Zeus is frequently depicted by Greek artists in one of three poses: standing, striding forward with a thunderbolt leveled in his raised right hand, or seated in majesty. For the Ancient Greeks, Zeus (Jupiter for Ancient Romans, ~Thor for Ancient Norsemen) was “The Father of the Gods.”.
…NOTE: The word ZEUS, meant to Ancient Greeks => Lightning Strikes!!! In other words => Literally, the making a sudden light / illumination. For The Ancient Peoples this was Eureka (sudden new discovery). Any mention or thought or apparition (appearance) of Zeus (& Metaphorically Simultaneously) included => What we moderns would call the concepts of the Sudden Illumination, Sudden Seeing, Light-Bulb, Flash Of Insight, AHA, Epiphany!! Click Here. (Many Thanks to Naomi Frost Hewett for pointing this out! ) e) Ancient Greeks, in their city of Athens, would pray to their local “Goddess Athena” , for protection, guidance, cunning, courage, skill, well-being, & wisdom, both for their own person and for their whole city of Athens. They often would go to “Athena’s” Temple Mount at the center of Athens to pray, offer food, burnt offerings, & money. This Temple is known to us as The Parthenon, and inside it as the central focus was a huge Statue of “Athena” . We can imagine that the food eventually kept Temple Staff well fed and the money, used to build the temple in the first place. ….A “Facts About Athena” Webpage says => “Known for protecting civilized life, Athena was the Goddess of the City. According to some sources, Athena was praised for her compassion and generosity. Athena was a patron of the arts and crafts, especially when it came to spinning and weaving. In later poetry, Athena embodied wisdom and rational thought.” [Also War & Battle Strategy.] …The WebPage “Hellenic Witch/Wiccan Worship of Athena” at end gives several example Prayers To “Athena” , possibly projected from ancient historical records.
f) Early Native Hawaiians, even up to the current day, pray and give offerings, to “Pele” for protection from the local Volcano’s furry. I (Henry Gurr) well remember a National Geographic Magazine Article that discussed the Hawaiian Volcano Goddess Pele, and showed villagers that had climbed to a Volcanic Crater Rim, and believing they were appeasing '' “Goddess Pele”, had placed offerings of food, flowers, and trinkets. Unfortunately Internet Searches and even NG Archives can’t find this article, but found the equivalent presented below =>
i) A Nov1983 Photo Caption says => “To !invoke the Goddess Pele, Kahmehameha in 1801 cast a gift -- a lock of hair wrapped in a leaf -- into a lava flow from Hualalm, after an eruption had covered a fishpond and endangered villagers. Shortly the volcano quitted -- and has not erupted since." A
ii) A Book About Hawaiian History says => “The temples of Pele were numerous, particularly in the neighborhood of old lava-flows, and their priests were always well sustained. The crater of Kilauea was especially sacred to the goddess, and the earth around it could not be safely disturbed. An offering was first made of a part of everything eaten there, and fruits, pigs, fowls, fish, and sometimes human beings, were thrown into the crater to appease the wrath of the goddess and avert a threatened overflow.”
iii) Another WebSite says => “With the recent eruption of the Kilauea Volcano, visitors are reminded of Pele’s presence in the volcano, where people come to feel her spirit and pray to her.
******** o0OOO0o ******** To Show (Prove), That This Ancient System Of Original Participation, Must Have Been Once There & Big , We Need Only To Look In Our Own Daily Language, To See The Relic Remainders (And Reminders) Still Around Today : Such As These Familiar Examples => Day [Deos], Neptune, Dylan, Dawn, Aurora, Thor [Thunder}, Eros, Venus, Muse [Music], Jason, Arthur, Peter [from Jupiter] , & thousands more. Original Participation ALSO Indicated By => Sun’s-Day, Moon’s-Day, Tue’s-Day, Woden’s-Day, Thor’sDay, Frida’sDay, Saturn’sDay <= Our Names of: Days of week, Original Participation ALSO Indicated By => Janus, Februa, Mars, Aphrodite, Maia /Maiesta, Julius Cesar, Augusts Cesar, septem/seven, octo/eight, novem/nine, decem/ten, <= Our Months of year, where the last 4, are clearly not “Gods” .... Yet. . Original Participation ALSO Indicated By => Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn <= Our Names of: The Planets Of Our Solar System To Ancient people, Original Participation ALSO Indicated By => The “Running” of ALL Of Living & Non-Living World. By Various Living Personae, Having A Mind, And A Will, And Could Cause The Following To Happen.
a) Many of Human Internal Body Processes Heart Pumping, Lungs & Breathing, Stomach & Digestion & Gasses:
b) Early on the ancient Greeks believed that illnesses were " divine punishments" and that healing was a "gift from the “The Gods” … Many Diseases clearly & truly are “Evil Spirits” . Ancient Persons, I imagine, would have no trouble concluding that an invisible evil spirit” had entered (in-fluenced) into a person, Their body was thus literally "Possessed by evil spirits." ', and from this, the bad painful, high fever, disease. Something different took control of the person. Some “evil creature” had traveled systematically (thru thin Air), from one sick person to another. For 21st Century Moderns => The disease microorganisms, seen with our microscopes, are literally those “evil creatures” & "possessed" by the sick person. These "The Other" did indeed take control over that persons internal cellular processes for a cellular contest of life and death! Very much a struggle of competing forces! Indeed, even in our terms, the sick person is literally "influenced" , and then "possessed" by these “evil spirit creatures” , which through thin air, had entered into a sick person. YES" “Possessed (in-fluenced) by evil spirits." NOTE: In the above (and this document generally) I do not say “because" or “caused by”, when discus cussing the actions of “ Spirit Persona Beings'' ”:. Ancient Peoples did NOT have any concept of “cause” as do modern people.
-c) And also Psychological Moods, reflect action of a “ Spirit Persona Being ”. For Example Wikipedia says => “Temperament theory has its roots in the ancient theory of humourism. It may have originated in Ancient Egyptian medicine or in Mesopotamia, but it was Greek physician Hippocrates (460–370 BC) who developed it into a medical theory. He believed that certain human moods, emotions, and behaviours were caused by an excess or lack of body fluids (called "humours"), which he classified as blood, yellow bile, black bile, and phlegm.” … This form of “Willful Actor Agents” persisted in medicine up thru the 1600’s. d) Many Scientific / Technical Words, have their origin in Original Participation. For Example Wikipedia says => Alchemical writers used Classical figures from Greek, Roman, and Egyptian mythology to illuminate their works and allegorize alchemical transmutation.[27] These included the pantheon of gods related to the Classical planets, Isis, Osiris, Jason, and many others.” ... .. “The central figure in the mythology of alchemy is Hermes Trismegistus (or Thrice-Great Hermes). His name is derived from the god Thoth and his Greek counterpart Hermes.” Hermes and his caduceus or serpent-staff, were among alchemy's principal symbols.”
e) Even “Nature” (Latin “Natura” ), herself, was one of the “Willful Agent Actors”
in Original Participation, Original Participation Is ALSO Indicated By => III) Many of The Words We Yearly Encounter Every Halloween => On “All Halloweds Evening” .(Closely Related to All “Saints” Day and All “Souls” ’ Day..) '''
“Spirit, Soul, Saint, Angels, Daimon, Familiar, Genie, Genius, Jinni (OR Jinn Also Djinni Or Djinn), Shaitan; Double, Doppelgänger (OR Doppelganger), Fetch; Lemures, Manes; Incubus, Lamia, Succubus, Vampire, Zombie (Also Zombi); Cacodemon, Demon (OR Daemon), Devil, Fiend, Ghoul, Imp Heavenly-Host, Host, Ghost, Ghoul, Gnome, Gool, Grinch, Goblin, Gremlin, Ghost-Writing, Muse, Fairy, Elf, Troll, Little People, Forest People, Trickster, Night-Visitor, Phantom, Phoenix, Apparition, Bogey (Also Bogie OR Bogy), Familiar Spirit, Hant, Haunt, Materialization, Ogre, Phantasm (Also Fantasm), Phantom, Poltergeist, Shade, Shadow, Specter (Or Spectre), Spirit, Spook, Sprite, Vision, Visitant, Wraith, Bezelbulb, Satan, Devil, Demi-Gog, Demi-God, All-Saints, All-Hallowed, All-Hallows “-Evening, , not to mention “Gods, Goddesses, Divines and Deities” ..
a) Additional relic words, that illustrate what I have been calling => “Friends & Neighbors: Actors & Agents, Egos & Figurations; Forces, & Actions” :
-b) What Ancient peoples experienced as => “Living Persons: Lived Realities” !! ... A WebPage says: “They Are The Spiritual Part Of The Land, Forests, Water, And Air ' '' A visit to Google (or Wikipedia), will reveal volumes about any one Ancient “God” or “Goddess”´: ((Be it Greek, Roman, Egyptian, Babylonian, Chaldean, Norse, Northern European, etc.)) And remember there were thousands of them, going all the way back to The Civilizations of The Fertile Crescent, and probably way before, to what I would call “Dawn People”. We could conclude that the Roots Of Original Participation, probably going back well before, the dating of the earliest France & Spain Cave Paintings, the earliest being ~60,000 years ago!. ...However, a word of caution. => In reading WebPages on Ancient Myth or related “Gods & Goddesses” , you will practically never see any of Barfield’s Interpretation or Original Participation: This is because whenever people in our modern times (plus previous ~500 years), study a older civilization (2000 to 2400 years ago), they “overlay” their modern mind set, INTO the world of the Ancients.
' BOTTOM LINE: Because Of The Facts That The Ancient System Of Original Participation'', MUST Have Been Once THERE & BIG,
AND REMEMBER THIS =>In The Ancient System Of Original Participation: “Spirit Personas” Participated With The Ancient Person As => “Friends & Neighbors: Actors & Agents, Egos & Figurations, Forces & Actions” ,
'But By The Time Of Plato & Aristotle, The Traditional Thinking Was Weakening, And “The Gods” '' Were Less & Less Looked Upon As What Made Things Happen In Their World.
... Below I discuss “What Contemporary Current Day “Explanations” Of The So Called “Gods’ & ‘Goddess” , Distorts or Leaves Out”. FOR “DAWN PEOPLE” AND “ANCIENT CIVILIZATION PEOPLE, THEIR ANCIENT SYSTEM OF ORIGINAL PARTICIPATION, SHOULD BE UNDERSTOOD (AND IMAGINED), AS “A FELT PRESENCES”, THAT ARE MENTAL ARRIVALS, INTO THEIR CONSCIOUS MINDS.By Henry S Gurr, ZMMQ SiteMaster, October 30, 2021. FIRST: An Introduction To Mr. Owen Barfield's Interpretation of Myth, & Mythical Beings. ... In his book "Poetic Diction" , Chapter "Meaning and Myth" , when Mr. Barfield speaks of his "poetic" interpretation of Myth, he is thinking of a time, some 3500 to 7500 years ago, during the formation of the Ancient Civilizations of the Nile, Tigris, Euphrates, and Indus: River Valley Civilizations. This is of course way, prior to the Classical Greeks & Romans.
SECOND: Explaining Barfield’s Ancient System of Original Participation.
You already know a lot about many of “The Others” => Please scroll back to near page top, and think about the Section Titled => To Show (Prove), That This Ancient System Of Original Participation, Must Have Been Once There & Big , We Need Only To Look In Our Own Daily Language, To See The Relic Remainders (And Reminders) Still Around Today ''': In His Discussions Mr. Barfield Purposefully Uses Words “The Others” ''': This way we can Avoid the words, "Gods, Goddesses, Spirits, or Spirit Beings. "
a) I think we should avoid these (and closely related words) because such words are full of modern 21th Century Connotations will lead our mind away from a correct sense of The Mythical Beings of The Ancients.
b) 21th Century Connotations such as => God, a creator of the whole universe, a God that is the author that keeps this whole world running, a God that ensures that he fills all of us with the desire for life, and to keep on wanting to be good productive persons. Now such a creature or being, in reality, is so unperceivably immense and so all-encompassing, for example, the whole universe which came from the Big Bang 13 Thousand Million Years Ago.
c) Another hindrance for us in our modern times, is the HUGE Anthropomorphize practically all Mythical Beings. To understand this, please scroll down to and understand => D) How Did It Happen, That The So Called ‘Gods’ & ‘Goddess’, Closely Resemble Human Beings? The General (& Peculiar) Human Tendency To Anthropomorphize!! '''
There are other reason for avoiding such words as Gods, Goddesses & Spirits, beyond above-mentioned modern 21th Century Connotations: But these are harder to explain and available time prevents me from further explanation.
Henry Gurr’s OLDER (poorly written) explanation of these problems. Click Here. ******** o0OOO0o ******** THIRD: About “The Others” Barfield Says In His Book “Poetic Diction”.A) On p86.9: "The language of primitive men reports them, as direct perceptual experience. The speaker has observed a unity [a personality, a being], and is not therefore himself conscious of relation. But we, in the development of [our present human modern] consciousness, have lost the power to see this one as one. [ie an individual Other Being.] Our sophistication, like Odin's, has cost us an eye...."
In other words => "These Others" such as Dionysus, Demeter, Persephone, Hades, Jupiter, etc … properly understood by additional study , will ultimately be seen as a "coded reports" of natural physical processes, and various human perceptions, and responses to the natural world around them!
B) On p88.3 He also says these Others were: "Reality once self evident, and therefore not conceptually experienced...."
C) On p92.1 He also says of these perceptions nature such as Orpheus, Demeter, Persephone, etc, "Mythology is the ghost of concrete meaning. Connections between discrete phenomena, connections which are now apprehended [by us moderns only] as metaphor, were once perceived as immediate realities. As such the poet strives, by his own efforts, to see them, and to make others see them, again."
"Direct Experiences" .... "Self Evident" .... "A Unity" .... "Immediate Realities" , .....….In the above passages, Barfield's conclusions are quite different from those of other authors who have studied myth. In addition, Barfield is saying; What Dawn People saw, we moderns can not, and that is why even the "experts" have been led astray.
FOURTH: From The Original Participation of River Valley Civilizations, We Can Postulate A Even Earlier Participation, of "Dawn People":If you have followed this discussion, you now must realize that in culture, new practices MUST have earlier versions, at successively older times in human pre-history. . And thus we wonder what must have been the precursors of Mythical Beings of the Ancient Civilizations of the Nile, Tigris, Euphrates, and Indus: River Valley Civilizations.. Again ….Based on his "poetic" reading of Myths, such as has come down to us in the historical & archeological record, Barfield further directs his (and our) Poetic Imagination, to how we should think about these Myths & their Mythical Beings, or people much earlier than the River Valley Civilizations, perhaps back to and indeed prior to practically any recognizable form of history.
A) The physical, geological, biological, and human body & human mind,
B) Since there has been little change, is valid to use the data & observations of Archeology, Anthropology, and Social ology, all the way back to earliest peoples.
Then imaginatively extrapolate with Barfield to understand the Worldview of what we could call "Dawn People", and what Barfield calls their Original Participation. The cave paintings in France and Spain (~25,000 to 66,000 years ago", would fall in the time period of "Dawn People". Their paintings are artistically highly developed, and show beautiful images of animals, but I am not aware of archeological artifacts during these times which could be interpreted as illustrating anything we, in modern terms, could call Mythical Behavior. Thus we may assume these "Dawn People", had not developed the representations characteristic of above mentioned "Ancient River Civilizations Peoples". ******** o0OOO0o ******** Below, I (Henry Gurr), Present My Own Hypothetical Model Of What Barfield Is Directing Our Attention To, In These Above Passages.
To Learn More How Original Participation Might Have Worked For Ancient People, Click Here. And AFTER The Page Comes Up, Scroll down to and start reading at => “4) The "distinctive characteristics of Original Participation" now follow:”. And as you read notice the sentences having => rock, echo, evil spirits=sickness, Pan, Panic, Aeolias, Venus, Jupiter, Saturn, Mercury, Mars, or other heavenly objects… . Continue reading down to and stop at=> “Barfield helps us understand the steps by which science, starting 2500 years ago, gradually "pulled itself" free from this morass.” .
APPENDIX I: WITH SOME REPETITION OF THE ABOVE, AN EXPANDED & DETAILED DISCUSSION OF =>
We In 21st Century, Should Understand & See Those Old-Time Ancient Persona, called “The Others” (‘Gods’ & ‘Goddess), AS Mental Arrivals, to their Conscious Minds. AND Although These Apparitions of ~Spirits Persons, Were Creations Of Their Own Human Minds AND existed nowhere else, This Is No Reason To Call That “System” => Mere Delusions, Useless Figments Of a Primitive Person’s Imagination!! In The World of Ancient Humans, We Better Should See, That Their Ancient System of Original Participation, Was For Them, Quite Functional, Wherein => Every One Of These “Gods” (“ Spirit Persona Beings ”:), Were Mental Arrivals, Into Their Consciousness Awareness.
Owen Barfield provides for us an new view into this incredibly vast Literature of Mythology of our forbearers => Using the accepted name of this world view, “Original Participation”, he suggests the Mythical Beings were for Ancient peoples, “Lived Realities”: By this he means we should understand the Mythical Beings “The Others” (the so called) “Gods, Goddesses, or Spirits”), were effectively experienced (by "Dawn People" & “Ancient Civilization People”), as living persons, with a mind, a will, and such were “the force”, behind practically ALL physical & psychological actions, those Ancient Humans experienced. Barfield calls these living persons, “The Others” , but pointing to ~the same thing, more familiar names are => Actors, Agents, Beings, Personalities, Personae, Characters, Forces, Physical Processes, Natural Events. etc. Referring to the written historical record, Barfield says (or implies) these “Lived Realities”, applied to Devine Mythical Beings” , through the eons of time. He helps us understand how the System of Ancient Original Participation “explains” the literally thousands of these he named “The Others” !!. How Might We Of 20th & 21st Century, “Visualize” What Dawn People Were Sensing?
a) Before sunrise, Dawn People could see the Orange Sky above Green Trees, as we do. But what is different is their extra sensory feeling of Personal Presence ... A Living Breathing Thinking Presence of a Friend ... we know as Dawn.
b) Similarly, Dawn People weathering a storm, could see lightning, feel wind & hear thunder as we do. But what is different, is they would sense the Personal Presence & Wrath of “The Mighty One ...Thor” ... up there in the clouds. And likewise feel a presence of an Other Person.... “Aeolias” ... flowing over their body & through their hair. A Living Breathing Thinking Presence of a Friend ... we know as wind. Correction, for wind, I should have written => Spirit, a Latin HoloPhrase meaning, all at once, Breath-Air-Wind-LivingSubstance-LifePrinciple-LivingPerson-&More!! .
{+c) Similarly when the sea became agitated, and dashing furiously against the rocks, you felt The Presence of “Ocean Master Neptune” was really THERE in a furious rage, you felt as if you were being twisted, in his hands!
d) Add to above => [http://www.biblepages.net/eoa15.htm |:Word “Theos = “He who sees”, “watcher” ]] In our own time ”Theos” is translated as “God” , but has all marks of Original Participation, with interesting connections going way back to 16th to 12th centuries BC, Mycenaean Greek Language: =>
d) Continued: The Mycenaean Greeks, were early founders of Greece (a bit N of Athens), and were very likely colonists from Egypt. Perhaps this will explain why: i) The Ancient Greek temples show cultural continuity from Ancient Egyptian Temples, and ii) Mycenaean meaning for ’Theos = “he who sees”, “watcher” , shows cultural continuity to the Ancient Egyptians, who considered the Sun Disk, the Eye of “Ra”, looking down on Egyptians, to see if they have been good moral persons!
e) Add to above => The so called Deja-Vu feeling I think might apply here: When a person, walks into a strange place, or even encounters a cooking food aroma ... there is a slow wave of strange sensation that comes .... Wait .... I’ve BEEN here! I just sense it!! AND where, did we find that food!! Deha-Vu, is an extra feeling of a presence, beyond the ordinary, and might help point an analog of Dawn Person’s sensing, felt awareness. Before and after the Deja-Vu, everything physical is the same: What’s different, is the feeling and related knowing. NOW .... apply this to a), b), c) above!!
f) Add to above => Persons Living Within Original Participation, Believing That “Spirit Persona Beings” Control Everything, and Believing That These “Spirit Beings” Could Be Talked To, Offer Prayers and Supplications For Help. Here are some ways how this might work => :
i)
g) The above a), b), c), “Visualize” What Dawn People Were Sensing, comes from Owen Barfield. To this Julian Jaynes, would add that, Dawn People Sensing, included Hallucinate Voices, sending messages, corresponding to a) Friendship, b) Wrath, & c) Rage. #LinksToG&G
At This Point You May Want Use This List Of Suggested Internet Links, OR Just Google To Find Thousands More, Of The So Called “Gods & Goddess”:
(To a good approximation.)
For all human history .................. Up to ~300 years ago.
For all human cultures ................. Except Modern Technological. (us).
For all the global earth ................. Mostly humans, but Chimpanzees???
Owen Barfield in his “Saving the Appearances” (UoL, 1960), p. 97, says =>
THUS => We Of The 21st Century, Can Take One of Two Views, Of The Incredibly Vast Literature Of the Mythology Of Our Forbearers. (This includes documents, & related physical artifacts, in the time period: well before 60,000 years ago, up to say 300 years ago.) A) VIEW #1: We Moderns, don’t believe in Apparitions, Ghost, Spirits, Little People, Forest People, Elves, Farias, Etc. '''These ideas are obviously stupid, and were The Overactive Creations Of Primitive Peoples’ Own Totally Superstitious Mind. THUS => Mere Delusions, Useless Figments Or Imagination!! As C S Lewis once said** “Lies, Dammed Lies”!!
B) VIEW #2: For The Ancient Greeks & Romans, Their so called ‘Gods’ & ‘Goddess’, Were Experienced as Real, Living Persons: Lived Realities. We In 21st Century, Should Understand These Apparitions of Spirits Persons, ( “The Others” or so called “Gods” & “Goddess” ), came as Mental Arrivals, plus perhaps as a “Felt Presence”. And although these were correspondingly, ”Were Creations Of Their Human Mind”, This Is No Reason To Call That “System”, Mere Delusions, Useless Figments of Their Imagination!! We In 21st Century, Should See Ancient Myth As => An Ancient System of Original Participation, wherein: “ Spirit Persona Beings ” were experienced as Friends & Neighbors: Actors, Agents, Egos & Figurations, Forces, and Actions. AND in In This World of Ancient Humans. Every One Of These “ Spirit Persona Beings ” (Came-Into-Consciousness), And Experienced As Mental Arrivals, plus perhaps a felt presence.!! B) cont. For More Discussion, See Robert Pirsig’s ZMM, Chapter 3, On Ghosts Vs Science. Also See Julian Jaynes’s Book => The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind.
SIDE NOTES:
a) Supreme Creator & Master of whole universe. And
b) Only ONE God is, or ever was, in this whole universe. And
c) God is NOT viewed completely differently than Ancient peoples.
So ... When it comes to any discussion of the World of Ancient Myth and System or Ancient Original Participation .... I think using those words ‘Gods’ or ‘Goddess’, carry meanings that is wrong, or at best very misleading. (There are probably other words, to be similarly avoided, but can’t think of them now.) APPENDIX II: How Did It Happen, That “The Others” (The So Called “Gods & ‘Goddess”), Closely Resemble Human Beings? The General (& Peculiar) Human Tendency To Anthropomorphize!! : YES: Closely Resemble Human Beings, Even to the extent that, in EVERY discussion of a named Mythical Being, there is typically an Image of the Being, that looks just like a human, dressed in clothing of some human cultural time-frame. These Images are => Drawings, paintings, photo of an Ancient Greek, Roman, Egyptian, etc) For examples of this => Google => Wikipedia + ANY Mythical Being Name, such as those Italicized On This Page. This is also true of practically ANY serious treatise on Ancient Myth. Anthropomorphized, Ancient Myth Is Just Crazy, As Judged By Logic & Science! However Myth Aficionados, Just Love The Crazy-Soap-Opera Of Classical Myth, And Can’t Get Enough Of It!! For Example C. S. Lewis or RR Tolkien. 1) To illustrate how extremely Anthropomorphized became, the myths of the Ancient Greeks, consider this excerpt from a contemporary academic lesson, on their ‘Gods’ & ‘Goddess’: [Quote]
“They resembled human beings in their feelings and habits, intermarrying and having children, and requiring daily nourishment to recruit their strength, and refreshing sleep to restore their energies. .... they were not considered to be exempt from human passions, and we frequently behold them actuated by revenge, deceit, and jealousy.” 2) Be aware that => Original Participation was crazy this way, ONLY in later stages of Greek & Roman Mythology, where even their people at the time, were realizing, how illogical and whacko their OWN Mythology had gotten!!
APPENDIX III: MORE ON => How Did It Happen, That “The Others” (The So Called “Gods & Goddess”), So Very Closely Resemble Human Beings? The General (& Peculiar) Human Tendency To Anthropomorphize!!: '''
As I Have Been Writing The Above Appendix I MENTAL ARRIVALS, AS SEEN IN THE ANCIENT SYSTEM OF ORIGINAL PARTICIPATION, I’m Discovering, Or I’m Reminded Of, Many “Connections”**
(( **James Burke’s Connections, was an excellent 1978, 1994, 1997, TV Series, essentially about Scientific Discovery, The Flash-of-Insight, or Lack of It. Hint! Hint! Mental Arrivals, wherein I’ll bet , Burke and Kuhn are barking up the same tree! )) QUICK INTERIM-SUMMARY
A) People of Ancient Civilizations, were just as intelligent, and functional as we are: Their System (which this page is called Original Participation), strange & utterly fantastic as it may seem to us, was nevertheless quite normal for them ….. And it worked!!! It had to, at least until inevitable decay set in, and forces of new Single God Religion came along.
B) We Humans Are In-Born Innate Problem Solvers, which by the Hopfield Model, finds Best Solutions, most of the time. This applies to both
1) People of the 21st Century (us). AND
2) Ancient Peoples, whether as individual persons, or whole communities, operating over Millennia. Of course, we assume that, human brain power is roughly unchanged through the last 60,000 years. ... So (for example to make a point) =>
With Resulting Good Validity => Human Brains Intellectually Built / Constructed BOTH => 3) Our 21st Century Science + Technology AND
4) What I have named Ancient System of Original Participation: “ Spirit Persona Beings ”: experienced as Friends & Neighbors: Actors & Agents, Egos & Figurations, Forces, & Actions.
…From the above, we can readily conclude Their Ancient System of Original Participation, had roughly the same validity for Ancient People, as our modern Cultural System has for us moderns!! Therefore Pease continue reading (& thinking about this), and you will see that Owen Barfield’s Original Participation System (with considerable support from Jaynes), stands big as the most plausible explanation!!
APPENDIX IV: Why / How We In 20th & 21st Century, Inherited An “IN-Correct Understanding” The World of Ancient Myth
To Experience (And ~See) This For Yourself: Discussion & Examples & Links => ''''''…How It Is That Interpreters of Ancient Myth, Indeed Any Person, Can’t See “What Owen Barfield Saw As being “Really There”!!
Yes, I Know, A Person With 20th & 21st Century” Modern Mentality, Can Fully Enjoy Ancient Myth.
Examples, Of What I’ve Been Saying: Here ate links to two examples of how “20th Century Modern” shows up, in in our 20th & 21st Century Thinking & Writing & Media, about the Ancients!!
...C) In typing A) above => I’m suddenly reminded here, of our USA movies, in their depiction Ancient Peoples Cecil Be DeMille Spectaculars come to mind, but of course, nearly all other movies, have An Inevitable Culture Bias: Lots of quite valid reasons, most of which apply to ANY media production:. a) As is true for most USA => Directors, screen writers, actors, producers, the viewing public, little know (or care), about Ancient Cultures, and if asked to contribute to a movie which is different from their OWN culture, they mostly couldn’t do it, or if they did, it would come out “wrong”..
b) When it comes to showing (or depicting), ANY different culture, box-office movie profitability, effectively rules-out practically ANY Authentic. Especially when it comes to cosmetics, hair style, behavior, mannerisms, communication style (gestures, body language, eye motion, etc) This is compounded by the “style”, that is economically constrained by available materials, fabrics, color, texture, surface finish, etc, etc, : So, for all these reasons, movies (and other modern media), end up being 20th & 21st Century” Modern”!! Our movies, .mostly can’t (and don’t) show / depict authentic, when it comes to cultures different from ours. And perhaps (hypothesis), the depiction of Ancient Cultures is even harder.
c) And if some Enlightened Movie Producer tried to “Go Authentic”, it has been a dud or failure at the Box-Office. We know the reason, and it is a variant of “Perceptual Blindness”: People can best see, what they have grown up with. What is familiar, they can perceive, plus see & understand. Most people, faced with a “non-familiar” movie, will pretty much fail to see the point of the movie: Instead, there will be dissonance, lack of “fit”, dis-comfort, dis-ease, can’-relate-to, troubled, bother-ated, disturbed, no intuitive connection, cognitive dissonance, etc. Such persons will think the movie is weird, peculiar, whacko, out-of-it, off-base, absurd, ludicrous, loony, loony tune, cuckoo-land, un-real, absolutely un-imaginable, can’t relate to it, you name it! Even if “the different”, is completely minor trivial!!. And typically, their mind will fixate on their trivial dis-likes, (aka TV’s Archie Bunker), and never, enjoy or get the point of the movie!!
…Thomas Kuhn, discussed elsewhere on this page (with links), would say approximately this => “The Authentic Movie and the Average Viewer, are operating with two different World Views, two different Paradigms. And almost axiomatically, different Paradigms are IN-Commensurate, and thus UN-Communicable, one to the other. Kuhn’s way of saying => Perceptual Blindness, Non-Seeing, Non-Understanding. … So in summary, just try the authentic: Most people will not like it, and the experts that might understand why & how authentic, will few indeed.
******** o0OOO0o ******** You May Be Interested To Know => How I Was Brought [Great Resistance & Blindness] to Discover Owen Barfield. As mentioned ~22 inches above, here my own experience, as to how originally I was VERY BLIND to Barfield. by Henry Gurr Here is Much More About => [[http://www.usca.edu/math/~mathdept/hsg/OwenBarfieldIntepretMythV67.html |
SIDE NOTE: “What Was Really There” Or What Is A “Correct Understanding”, Naturally Depends, On WHO Is Doing The Interpreting.
So For You Dear Reader, There Are Four Consequences, Concerning Most Of What You Will Actually Encounter, When Studying “Current-Day Literature About Ancient Myth” (including photos of related archeological artifacts), : 1) In the Myth Information presented, “Current-Day Literature About Ancient Myth” will a strong (and mostly unrecognized). Modern World View or Modern Mind-Set!!
2) As Barfield aptly points out Re this Literature => The author’s knowledge, is biased such that they can-not, (and consciously refuses to) actually see => '''What was really there!
-3) Because of THIS in 1) above, you will have your own perceptual blindness, when it comes to understanding, what the ideas of Owen Barfield or Julian Jaynes. 4) Which means you dear reader, will have to “step out of” your own Modern Thinking, in order to “penetrate the veil”, to a “correct understanding” AND It is the EXACT purpose of this document to HELP you do this!! And whether this document ACTUALLY HELPS YOU, it a crucial test of my writing ability!! You, Dear Reader, will do me a great favour to let me know, your reactions to this document and writing. Thank you. HSG
5) Two Suggested Examples of How To “Properly Interpret” Most Of What You Will Actually Encounter, When Studying “Current-Day Literature About Ancient Myth” (and photos of related archeological artifacts), :
Example #1: Mythology expert, Padraig Colum, and author of the mythology section of my encyclopedia stated; "The rustling of the leaves was supposed to be the murmuring voice of the goddess who lived in the tree. The hurrying stream was [supposed to be] a nymph rushing to join her lover, the sea." According to Mr. Barfield this is correct.Just remove the word "Supposed to be"!! The passage now reads "The rustling of the leaves was the murmuring voice of the goddess who lived in the tree. The hurrying stream was a nymph rushing to join her lover, the sea."
Example #2: Mythology expert, E.M. Behrens author of “The Project Gutenberg EBook of Myths and Legends of Ancient Greece and Rome”. In this good “Illustrated Hand-Book Of Mythology”, we can see a representative examples of how “20th Century Modern” shows up, in in our thinking or writing, about the Ancients!! THIS IS YET TO BE COMPLETED => An Example Of What I’ve Been Saying, Augmented WITH HSG Editing, To Remove 20th Century Mind Set, & Replace With The Mind Set Ancient System of Original Participation .
APPENDIX V: WHAT’S THE EVIDENCE THAT SHOWS THE ADMITTEDLY FANTASTIC, ABSURD, LUDICROUS ASSERTIONS, CONCERNING THE WORLD VIEW OF ORIGINAL PARTICIPATION, AS PRESENTED ABOVE ?? To See For Yourself, What Is Discussed Above, Here’s How Could (Should?) Study Ancient Myth: When You Get Some Free Time, Try Googling => “The Ancient Myths (Gods & Goddesses) of Ancient Greek & Roman Times. Just a brief look-around, (In Published Scholarship, WebPages, or Books), will a reveal a Fantastic & Massive Literature concerning this Long Ago Ancient Human Response to their world. For some people in our modern times => The study of Ancient Myth is Totally Engaging, and as they study the “Myth Literature: they find, all seems “True Fact”. And on surface it is true, in terms of remaining physical archeological artifacts, such as surviving ancient documents, statues, carvings, paintings, house wares, jewelry, and even buildings. This Is All To The Good. But, As I Have Already Stated, “ ... We As Modern Persons (Expert Or Not), Will “Read-Into” An Ancient Document (Or Ancient World View, Or Myth), To A Good Approximation, Mostly Our Own 20th Century Concepts. [All Of Them] Practically Un-Altered By What Ancient Literature (Or Archeological Artifacts) Actually Say Or Show:
1) To convince you, that there is a FAR better way to understand Old Myths, and the Ancient System of “God” & “Goddess” :
2) Various places on this page (including III) 3 inches below), I offer help “How to read correctly.”
3) Reading next link next down, will also help. .
Then you too can properly read Barfield, and use his guidance to "breathe new life into myth".
APPENDIX VI A List Of Suggested Internet Links, And Ways To Usefully “Dig In.
a) To be absolutely convinced how HUGE is this World of Ancient Myth, IS!!
b) From the fact that this World of Ancient Myth is HUGE, you should FIRMLY realize, just How Important The World of Ancient Myth, was to Ancient Peoples.
c) You want to solidify in mind: That for Ancient peoples, this “SYSTEM”, was the Power & Motive & and Mind, Behind absolutely everything that happened in their world!!
a) Here is a starter list of These “The Others”, for just Ancient Greek Olympians.
This was The World of Original Participation, which The Ancients lived and biologically survived by!!! APPENDIX VII: MISCELLANEOUS DISCUSSION: A) My Answer(s) As To => Why You Haven’t Heard Anything About, Either Owen Barfield or Julian Jaynes.
B) My Answer(s) As To => Why You Haven’t Heard Anything About, Owen Barfield’s Interpretation of Myth, Or Similar For Jaynes
C) Myth Experts (Including Michael Sexson Of Bozeman MT), Are Invited To Please Show My Errors, And Point Me To The Needed Documents.
It is the purpose of the above 5 pages, to convince you dear reader, of the ”Reality of this “Ancient System of Original Participation: “ Spirit Persona Beings ”: experiences as “Friends & Neighbors: Actors & Agents, Egos & Figurations, Forces, & Actions.” .... Then to convince you to A) Provisionally Assume (as hypothesis), this System of Original Participation, and it’s “Earthly & Heavenly Hosts” of “ Spirit Persona Beings ”:, and then
B) As you read about Ancient Peoples, see if “makes sense”?? Then
C) Send me an email re what you conclude!!
…Originally I had only Owen Barfield’s merest sketchy clues, and barest vague hints, from which to tease out, that which I write & lay out above: BUT => As Barfield said about mentally entering The World of the Ancients: “We can use our imagination!” And this is what I have done in writing, this is For a Continuation of The Above Ideas, Here is My Much More Detailed Discussion Of “Owen Barfield’s Interpretation of Myth”.This is ~14 pages written 2001, and is my earlier Explication of “Mythical Persona” , As “Friends & Neighbors, Assert That, Dawn People, Directly Experienced Spiritual Realities” . SUMMARY:
SUMMARY WRAP-UP: Mind Set of The Ancient System of Original Participation
…Various places this document, has indicated ways (plus factual evidence), that you can see to see the truth of Owen Barfield’s ideas. As mentioned, one good technique is to adopt (as a Hypothesis), The Mind Set of The Ancient System of Original Participation. Then, on a daily basis, see if the words you use, and your reading of history documents (Bible included), can start to making a whole lot more sense!! As Barfield says, “The pot has been scoured clean!” Gone is Original Participation, and gone also are it’s “Spirit Deities” “Lived Realities”. No longer, do we pass our minutes, with Mental Arrivals (visits, communications) of “Friends & Neighbors: Actors, Agents, Forces, and Actions” .!! We STILL speak words like “Souls, Phantoms, Goblins, Trolls, Fairies” , Etc, but these are just Relic Remainders, that can only remind us, of what was ONCE a Living Word View, called Original Participation!. .... This is most especially true for the persons who are the authors of the Literature on Ancient Myth. This leaves you, as a reader faced with a Literature of Myth, which is serious Contaminated with 20th & 21st Century Concepts & World View, and makes you Perceptually Blind to ... “What was really there!!” But as Owen Barfield says, “We can use our Imagination!”, and mentally recreate the Ancient System of Original Participation, as it really worked, according to Owen Barfield! . . Attention: Researchers of Ancient Myth, Legend, Folklore, & Mythology:
... This is a situation that needs serious literary research. Please join me in this Quest.
For Further Reading: A) Much Of The /\Above/\ Is An Excerpt From Henry Gurr’s OLDER WebPage “Owen Barfield’s Interpretation of Myth” You May Read The Entire Page, Click Here. B) This Page (Which You Are Reading Now), Is Henry Gurr’s NEWER BETTER Version, In Which Owen Barfield’s “Original Participation”, As Is Seen From The Perspective of Henry Gurr’s “View Of How Our Mind Works.” C) More Information About HO3 Henry S Gurr’s Mental Arrivals., In His An Anatomy of An Idea Come To Mind! Flash of Insight! *** AHA *** I See!! D) Brain Owner’s Users Manual Click Here For Discussion 8 Each Poetry AND 17 Each Metaphor (=BridgeOverDeepWater) & THUS Big Connect To Above-Mentioned Henry Gurr’s “View Of How Our Mind Works.” Composed by Henry Gurr 140320:’ Revs:141003PostMbkPg,~141220Xlet,150416NuPg, 200119HO3b,211104Magor,
|
Recent Changes (All) | Edit Sidebar | Wiki Help | Page History | Edit Page | Powered by PmWiki |